Oz:
A manly necklace and she'd get him something else with that if it were actually Christmas for them but it's... not.
Dexter:
The Breakfast Book cookbook.
Shinji: Some sheet music for his cello - more cheerful music, notably, and probably modern songs transposed for cello.
Kurt:
Burberry navy scarf, though this is an imitation as Willow doesn't have $300 to drop. xD;; It's Dalton colors, though?!
Blaine: Copy of the
UNC Achordants' CD.
Azula: Another sleep aid satchel since hers probably wore out by now, and bath salts because she thinks she needs to relax. XD
Spike: Some personally baked cookies because of William getting nostalgic over his mother, and a skull and crossbones patterned
Snuggie.
Robert: It'll look like a small white candle with a purple string tied tightly around it several times. Attached note: "Burn the candle to a stub and the next question you ask someone will be answered truthfully. I wasn't sure what to get you that you wouldn't already have, but I thought the truth might cover it! I tested it and it does work. --Willow" As a note, this really should actually work.
Tony: A couple random Iron Man comics that the nerd at the store told her were good. You can choose, Norr. XD
Yako: Encyclopedia Demonica, published 832 A.D. and translated to Japanese in 1995. Willow has the English translation but thought Yako would like it in Japanese. It's an enormous book and very stuffy.
Cross: All the ingredients for performing the ensouling spell, along with instructions. It's mostly a bunch of herbs, a bowl, some small throwing bones, and what looks like a small crystal ball (which is the Orb of Thesulah).
Nena: A really cute top of some kind.
Maybe this in black.
Donna: Silver bracelet with a
jade charm that promotes peaceful handling of stress. The effect is probably very subtle and mild.
Itsuki: A collar for his cat that looks like a
magical girl collar. Attached note: "Since you aren't a magical girl yourself, I thought you needed one somewhere in your life. Happy Holidays! --Willow"
Harry: The Chronicles of Narnia paperback set. And she's performing a spell on it so his relatives don't notice them.
Naoto: Whatever she and Harry end up buying her on their shopping expedition, probably something generic like a scarf.
IF I FORGOT SOMEONE SHOOT ME TELL ME and also present ideas are much appreciated.