Where to next when science fiction becomes science fact?

Jun 04, 2010 13:10

This post has been bouncing around in my head for a while now and it still might not yet be fully formed ( Read more... )

science fiction

Leave a comment

random_alex June 4 2010, 06:42:19 UTC
I adore hard sf but have never read it for the what-next factor; it's always, I think, been more about the interactions with tech than the tech itself, for me. I've certainly never read it for predictions. I cannot imagine doing so and don't understand the people who do! It should be about commenting on the present, and present possibilities... if you want *my money, anyway :)

Reply

girliejones June 4 2010, 06:52:02 UTC
I like the "what if" factor or the "what would would happen if" or "how would it work if".

What do you like about the interactions with tech? I find it fascinating since I really do like hard science in my fiction, and I am interested in how I think you are a harder SF reader than me, like I let the engineering team down.

Reply

random_alex June 4 2010, 07:00:28 UTC
I think I have an advantage in *not* having the engineering background, tbh. I know enough science that stuff doesn't completely throw me- and I (usually!) know when things are totally made up and can figure out whether I approve of that or not - but I'm not hampered by getting cross when things aren't exactly right, which I know happens for some sciencey friends (and happens to me with historical fiction).

I do enjoy the what-if factor, because of the way it comments on society as it is now. I think that's where I like the interactions with technology, actually: what if people lived in an enormous spaceship? what if AIs were a reality of life? what if artificial uteruses became the norm? - stories that deal with that sort of tech and how society works as a consequence are cool.

Reply

girliejones June 4 2010, 07:02:23 UTC
I agree with you though I was surprised by how quickly I got over space opera, in that case.

Reply

random_alex June 4 2010, 07:04:06 UTC
I adore space opera. Good space opera, that is. :D It pushes all the right buttons for me.

Reply

girliejones June 4 2010, 07:06:40 UTC
I want to love it and I don't :(

Reply

random_alex June 4 2010, 07:09:04 UTC
very sad for you, from my perspective! However, if you're still getting your sf hit, it's all good - as long as we don't get into a slanging match about who reads 'better' stuff... :D

Reply

girliejones June 4 2010, 07:11:21 UTC
Would *we* get into such a slanging match?

I have liked space opera, I think I just have read a lot that was the same. Which is probably my fault in what I have chosen. And maybe not continuing to read through more of it.

Reply

random_alex June 4 2010, 07:20:03 UTC
I doubt it, but it would be pretty funny :D

I guess, as with a lot of these sorts of things, I feel like I'm coming to it late so I'm still running to catch up. Additionally, I've mostly only read newer space opera, so perhaps I'm benefiting from not having read the older, potentially annoying stuff?

Also, I have a really bad memory, so it takes me longer to get annoyed by repetition than it does for other people .

Reply

girliejones June 4 2010, 07:27:14 UTC
And to be fair, I am mostly referring to short stories - and that could be part of my problem, in that you know, space operas should be looooong and novel length and in that vein I love love love Iain M Banks.

Reply

editormum June 4 2010, 09:34:06 UTC
Would you class LMB's Vorkosigan series as space opera? Cos I love that :) It's totally about the people, not the science :)

Reply

girliejones June 4 2010, 11:58:51 UTC
I haven't read LMB

Reply

editormum June 4 2010, 11:59:59 UTC
Oh, you should! Well, I love it, so maybe you won't though :)

Reply

girliejones June 4 2010, 12:01:11 UTC
I'm never gonna get to read everything!

Reply

editormum June 4 2010, 12:02:52 UTC
I loaned the first two of the series to Terri. She's hooked...

Even if you give up everything else you do, including work and sleep, you can't read everything. I regret that :)

Reply

girliejones June 4 2010, 12:04:10 UTC
I regret that too. Though I bet if I gave up TPP I'd *feel* like reading a lot more than I do.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up