"Once upon a time," said Zhuangzi, "I dreamed that I was a butterfly, fluttering hither and thither, to all intents and purposes a butterfly. I was conscious only of my happiness as a butterfly, unaware that I was Zhuangzi
( Read more... )
[The day after this exchange, Huo comes by Gai's house to drop his copy of the Tao Te Ching. Two pages in, the book conceals a handwritten page telling the following story:]
There once was a fish - a great predatory creature, a veritable whale - who dreamed that he was a man. The dream was very vivid, and he could not seem to let it go. What if he truly was a man, a fisherman and not a whale? What if he was in fact dreaming that he lived in a bowl with the other creatures of the sea? He tried and tried to wake up, but to no avail.
Finally, as he drifted down, exhausted, he came upon a girl-crab with a shell of many colors.
"Sweet fish," she said, "you are right. You are in fact a fisherman, trapped in a dream. But you cannot wake up because you are not the one dreaming. My brother dreams that he is a clam under a rock, but in truth, he is a boy holding a bowl. If you wish to go back to being a fisherman, then you must startle him very badly. He leap out of his shell and drop the bowl and you will be free."
But a small pale fish who swam next to the whale said to him, "you mustn't do this. Who is to say that when the bowl falls, we will not all spill out and die?"
The whale thought of that, and at last he said: "then I will do something else. My teeth are sharp. I will bite this clam-boy very badly so that he faints, and I will bite his crab sister too. Then when they are no longer dreaming this dream, perhaps we will not be trapped, and could wake ourselves if we wish."
The whale thought that this was a grand idea, and immediately swam away to plan how he will bite the clam under the rock and the colorful crab. He cautioned the pale fish: "the crab has many friends. Once we swam in the same colorful school, but now they must not know what I wish to do. You must tell no one of this."
But the small pale fish thought, "there is still danger in this. I should tell of it to the green frog. He has been in the bowl for a long time and is wise in its ways." And so the little pale fish swam away, to ask for the frog's counsel.
[Much delayed quicklog!]spandexisyouthSeptember 8 2011, 19:19:23 UTC
[Some of the things he got. The green frog was one of them, the pale fish... who the people in this were, he knew. But Gai was a bit worried about the bowl being dropped, or biting Fugue and Mother.]
[Part of the delay in approaching Huo was embarrassment. He was bad with metaphors and everyone knew it, but he still wanted to try. The other part was that if someone had been reading the journals, they might have picked up on the hidden message of discussion between him and Huo, and he wanted to keep this as safe as possible. Especially as the whale had told Huo not to tell.]
[So it's a few days later that Gai knocks on Huo's door, wondering if he could propose a walk down to the yard to speak of biting fish.]
[Much delayed quicklog!]getsome_sleepSeptember 9 2011, 16:52:40 UTC
[It was only a moment before the door swung open, and Huo greeted him with a smile that, along with its usual politeness, held a touch of eager relief.]
Gai-jun. I have been expecting you. [The delay hadn't concerned him terribly, but had not added to his peace of mind either. Things were in motion now, no day wasted.
(And he had written the information in that Gai-resistant code of metaphor. There was that.)]
[Much delayed quicklog!]spandexisyouthSeptember 9 2011, 21:43:27 UTC
That is good! [Even if it meant that Huo knew exactly how befuddled Gai would likely be. Oh well. There wasn't a way it could be a surprise.]
Tea would be lovely. I thank you. [He stepped in, removing his shoes at the door and following Huo. His voice was a bit rueful when he spoke again.] I have a feeling you have expected me ever since your last visit to my place. I am good at some things, but others I am not. At least I am good at drinking tea!
[Much delayed quicklog!]getsome_sleepSeptember 11 2011, 15:10:44 UTC
Tea it shall be, then. [Huo grinned slightly, but kept any teasing to himself. However they would hold it, this was not going to be a very cheerful conversation.
But perhaps hopeful. Perhaps.]
I apologize for communicating in such an obscure manner, [he said as he stirred the coals in the hearth to life.] One cannot be too careful, and even more eyes than usual are alert to this particular topic. Our whale is no fool, and the school of colorful fish knows much and more.
Re: [Much delayed quicklog!]spandexisyouthSeptember 11 2011, 21:26:53 UTC
[Gai took a seat, watching Huo get to work. He didn't mind the amusement; he was used to it and this was... well, something close to a friend. Getting there. Maybe already there. Gai wasn't sure how to define Huo, but at least the strategist was not an enemy anymore.]
I understand. We do not have the luxury of being colorful fish, slipping away when... when... [Metaphor. Gai was going to have a headache later, he knew it.] the waves become... big? Choppy! When they become choppy! [He felt a little too triumphant over that, he knew.]
But perhaps if... if a frog and one fish were to not... ripple? Much? When they swim, they will be beneath a whale's notice.
Re: [Much delayed quicklog!]getsome_sleepSeptember 12 2011, 20:53:20 UTC
[If nothing else - and of course there was much else - one could hardly fault Gai for lack of determination. As appreciative as he was entertained, Huo nodded, offering Gai a more encouraging smile along with a cup of tea. The thick aroma sweetened the air - perhaps it would sweeten the dealings.]
Frogs are very nimble, it seems, [he said.] And that is good, when they must avoid both a certain crab and a certain clam. How difficult it is to be surrounded by creatures of the sea. [He sipped his tea, slowly, thoughtful.] I hope that you have found my book enlightening, in regard to the nature of dreams and waking.
[Much delayed quicklog!]spandexisyouthSeptember 12 2011, 21:08:25 UTC
[Gai took the cup and was relieved to get a smile and a compliment. He'd been trying to prepare for open amusement at his attempts.]
They have to be. Otherwise people eat their legs. [It was said quietly, an aside. Taking a drink, Gai shook his head.] I... tried. And I got very confused. Some of it I was able to grasp. But much was... deeper than I could swim. The... sea life... was something that I... [There were so many pauses and trailings off. Gai wished this sounded more natural.] That I was familiar with. But the... behavior patterns were not.
[Much delayed quicklog!]getsome_sleepSeptember 12 2011, 22:24:56 UTC
Indeed. [Amusing as Gai's forays into metaphor were, Huo was no longer smiling very much. Danger hovered over them - that much bore repeating. They dealt now with things that even the Yard would not protect them from. No - there was no longer safety anywhere in Edensphere.]
I shall assume, [he replied after a moment's thought,] that it is the biting that troubles you most. It is strange for a whale to bite clams or crabs. [That was the most important aspect of the plan, after all, the most unexpected detail in Orca's intentions.] But it seems that the crab and clam of our tale are hardy creatures. If devoured whole, all that happens is that new ones appear. The wise fisherman must think of a different way to be rid of them.
[Much delayed quicklog!]spandexisyouthSeptember 13 2011, 06:52:48 UTC
[Slowly Gai nodded. Swallowing whole was... killing, then. Because they came back from that. So Orca had a different plan that would wound them but not bad enough to kill. But what could keep Fugue under wraps?]
If a fisherman was determined. So is the whale looking to ...become a fisherman and catch some fish?
[The strangest thought occurred to Gai then. He didn't think Huo would have skipped over it at this point if it was important, but.]
A time ago a fish went to visit a squid. He told the frog that he learned nothing, but the frog wonders if... if perhaps the currents have shifted. And that what once... the tide did not bring in, it does now?
[Great. He'd just mixed everything, because now he was calling Huo fish and tide both.]
[Much delayed quicklog!]getsome_sleepSeptember 14 2011, 20:02:17 UTC
[That nod spoke of understanding, Huo was reasonably certain. But glib as his tongue was, he could not put in metaphor the truth of what Orca intended to do to Fugue and Mother - what he had told Orca to do. He would have to get creative.]
So he is. I have read a most interesting book on the subject. [He rose to pick through one of the bookshelves, extracting one volume on wildlife - and the book on on the brain that had given him the idea for the surgery to begin with.]
Here, come and see. [He glanced back, briefly frowning, but understanding the thought behind Gai's words. They were not illogical, or unfair.]
Alas, squids are none too talkative. But whales are. Did you know that they are not fish at all, but mammals, like you and I? [Both a spice to the conversation - it had to sound at least a little casual to passing ear - and another hint. Orca was like them, at least in this.]
[Much delayed quicklog!]spandexisyouthSeptember 17 2011, 23:47:10 UTC
[Gai came over, joining Huo by the bookshelves, looking at the books Huo had pulled out. Gai nodded when Huo said squids were not talkative. It was a comfort to know he hadn't been deceived.]
Whales... [What was that supposed to mean?] They are... I... No. I did not. I have not studied whales much. That means they have hair? And do not have eggs. So it is interesting that they are like us like that. Ah. Are they... like us in other ways?
[This conversation had him so lost. Gai hoped he figured out what was being said soon, otherwise he might be of no help whatsoever.]
[Much delayed quicklog!]getsome_sleepSeptember 18 2011, 19:43:05 UTC
[Ah, probably too much. But at least it was on no crucial point.] Creatures of similar kinds share common interests, [Huo answered, keeping his tone light.] If I were to choose a friend, I would rather have a whale than a fish.
[He showed Gai one book, then another.] Here - this as for whales. And this second one may prove useful to someone of varied interests like yourself. It is on the subject of brains and their function. [He leafed through the latter book, eventually handing it to the other man open on a creased page that he had read a hundred times. One paragraph’s title was bold and underscored: Transorbital lobotomy.]
[Much delayed quicklog!]spandexisyouthSeptember 18 2011, 20:04:53 UTC
[He was sorry that he didn't grasp all of the subtle things Huo spoke about. Gai felt clunky. Even now he was a little lost. If they were all fish, according to the rainbow writers, was Huo saying that he did like Orca? More than most of the residents? Except no, wait, Huo was supposed to be a fish. So Huo was speaking of... being human? Gai rubbed a temple.]
I... think I would prefer the fish.
[Gai took the whale book, leaning in to see where Huo opened the page and accepting it as he read. After a bit of reading Gai shuddered, but he understood, or thought he might.]
This seems to be something that a clam might already be fond of.
[Much delayed quicklog!]getsome_sleepSeptember 21 2011, 11:31:21 UTC
No. I do not think you will. [Huo shook his head, about ready to give up on that line of conversation. There were things that they would simply not achieve - and in truth, he thought darkly, this was really all for their own comfort. If the Tree really wanted to know, it would know, no matter how well they might wrap it.
Instead, he focused on the book. Gai's dismayed response was expected. There was no way to present the procedure anything but ghastly.] No one is fond of such things. Even one such as myself who is not unhappy to lose all memory wishes to retain all his other faculties. Done properly, this procedure cuts away all mental ability - [he hesitated only for a moment before completing -] as surely as one cuts a stalk from its roots.
[Much delayed quicklog!]spandexisyouthSeptember 22 2011, 06:46:52 UTC
...No? [Gai's expression was pained. He was so lost now. There were some things he was good at, but this was beyond his grasp. He felt like he was letting Huo down as well as others at the same time.] But... swimming... [One of the rainbow writers had called them fish before, too, swimming up and down. He wouldn't prefer people like him? Or did Huo mean someone else?]
[Gai swallowed as Huo spoke.] Incapacitated. [Fugue would be alive and yet unable to do anything to the Sphere. It was cruel and disturbing and yet... possibly practical.] That would be... quite a bite. [Sometimes you had to be practical. The ninja part of Gai could understand doing that to Fugue, but not to Mother. It wasn't right to do it to her too.] But I am not sure why the clam will be bothered too.
There once was a fish - a great predatory creature, a veritable whale - who dreamed that he was a man. The dream was very vivid, and he could not seem to let it go. What if he truly was a man, a fisherman and not a whale? What if he was in fact dreaming that he lived in a bowl with the other creatures of the sea? He tried and tried to wake up, but to no avail.
Finally, as he drifted down, exhausted, he came upon a girl-crab with a shell of many colors.
"Sweet fish," she said, "you are right. You are in fact a fisherman, trapped in a dream. But you cannot wake up because you are not the one dreaming. My brother dreams that he is a clam under a rock, but in truth, he is a boy holding a bowl. If you wish to go back to being a fisherman, then you must startle him very badly. He leap out of his shell and drop the bowl and you will be free."
But a small pale fish who swam next to the whale said to him, "you mustn't do this. Who is to say that when the bowl falls, we will not all spill out and die?"
The whale thought of that, and at last he said: "then I will do something else. My teeth are sharp. I will bite this clam-boy very badly so that he faints, and I will bite his crab sister too. Then when they are no longer dreaming this dream, perhaps we will not be trapped, and could wake ourselves if we wish."
The whale thought that this was a grand idea, and immediately swam away to plan how he will bite the clam under the rock and the colorful crab. He cautioned the pale fish: "the crab has many friends. Once we swam in the same colorful school, but now they must not know what I wish to do. You must tell no one of this."
But the small pale fish thought, "there is still danger in this. I should tell of it to the green frog. He has been in the bowl for a long time and is wise in its ways." And so the little pale fish swam away, to ask for the frog's counsel.
Reply
[Part of the delay in approaching Huo was embarrassment. He was bad with metaphors and everyone knew it, but he still wanted to try. The other part was that if someone had been reading the journals, they might have picked up on the hidden message of discussion between him and Huo, and he wanted to keep this as safe as possible. Especially as the whale had told Huo not to tell.]
[So it's a few days later that Gai knocks on Huo's door, wondering if he could propose a walk down to the yard to speak of biting fish.]
Reply
Gai-jun. I have been expecting you. [The delay hadn't concerned him terribly, but had not added to his peace of mind either. Things were in motion now, no day wasted.
(And he had written the information in that Gai-resistant code of metaphor. There was that.)]
Come in. I shall brew us some tea.
Reply
Tea would be lovely. I thank you. [He stepped in, removing his shoes at the door and following Huo. His voice was a bit rueful when he spoke again.] I have a feeling you have expected me ever since your last visit to my place. I am good at some things, but others I am not. At least I am good at drinking tea!
Reply
But perhaps hopeful. Perhaps.]
I apologize for communicating in such an obscure manner, [he said as he stirred the coals in the hearth to life.] One cannot be too careful, and even more eyes than usual are alert to this particular topic. Our whale is no fool, and the school of colorful fish knows much and more.
Reply
I understand. We do not have the luxury of being colorful fish, slipping away when... when... [Metaphor. Gai was going to have a headache later, he knew it.] the waves become... big? Choppy! When they become choppy! [He felt a little too triumphant over that, he knew.]
But perhaps if... if a frog and one fish were to not... ripple? Much? When they swim, they will be beneath a whale's notice.
Reply
Frogs are very nimble, it seems, [he said.] And that is good, when they must avoid both a certain crab and a certain clam. How difficult it is to be surrounded by creatures of the sea. [He sipped his tea, slowly, thoughtful.] I hope that you have found my book enlightening, in regard to the nature of dreams and waking.
Reply
They have to be. Otherwise people eat their legs. [It was said quietly, an aside. Taking a drink, Gai shook his head.] I... tried. And I got very confused. Some of it I was able to grasp. But much was... deeper than I could swim. The... sea life... was something that I... [There were so many pauses and trailings off. Gai wished this sounded more natural.] That I was familiar with. But the... behavior patterns were not.
Reply
I shall assume, [he replied after a moment's thought,] that it is the biting that troubles you most. It is strange for a whale to bite clams or crabs. [That was the most important aspect of the plan, after all, the most unexpected detail in Orca's intentions.] But it seems that the crab and clam of our tale are hardy creatures. If devoured whole, all that happens is that new ones appear. The wise fisherman must think of a different way to be rid of them.
Reply
If a fisherman was determined. So is the whale looking to ...become a fisherman and catch some fish?
[The strangest thought occurred to Gai then. He didn't think Huo would have skipped over it at this point if it was important, but.]
A time ago a fish went to visit a squid. He told the frog that he learned nothing, but the frog wonders if... if perhaps the currents have shifted. And that what once... the tide did not bring in, it does now?
[Great. He'd just mixed everything, because now he was calling Huo fish and tide both.]
Reply
So he is. I have read a most interesting book on the subject. [He rose to pick through one of the bookshelves, extracting one volume on wildlife - and the book on on the brain that had given him the idea for the surgery to begin with.]
Here, come and see. [He glanced back, briefly frowning, but understanding the thought behind Gai's words. They were not illogical, or unfair.]
Alas, squids are none too talkative. But whales are. Did you know that they are not fish at all, but mammals, like you and I? [Both a spice to the conversation - it had to sound at least a little casual to passing ear - and another hint. Orca was like them, at least in this.]
Reply
Whales... [What was that supposed to mean?] They are... I... No. I did not. I have not studied whales much. That means they have hair? And do not have eggs. So it is interesting that they are like us like that. Ah. Are they... like us in other ways?
[This conversation had him so lost. Gai hoped he figured out what was being said soon, otherwise he might be of no help whatsoever.]
Reply
[He showed Gai one book, then another.] Here - this as for whales. And this second one may prove useful to someone of varied interests like yourself. It is on the subject of brains and their function. [He leafed through the latter book, eventually handing it to the other man open on a creased page that he had read a hundred times. One paragraph’s title was bold and underscored: Transorbital lobotomy.]
Reply
I... think I would prefer the fish.
[Gai took the whale book, leaning in to see where Huo opened the page and accepting it as he read. After a bit of reading Gai shuddered, but he understood, or thought he might.]
This seems to be something that a clam might already be fond of.
Reply
Instead, he focused on the book. Gai's dismayed response was expected. There was no way to present the procedure anything but ghastly.] No one is fond of such things. Even one such as myself who is not unhappy to lose all memory wishes to retain all his other faculties. Done properly, this procedure cuts away all mental ability - [he hesitated only for a moment before completing -] as surely as one cuts a stalk from its roots.
Reply
[Gai swallowed as Huo spoke.] Incapacitated. [Fugue would be alive and yet unable to do anything to the Sphere. It was cruel and disturbing and yet... possibly practical.] That would be... quite a bite. [Sometimes you had to be practical. The ninja part of Gai could understand doing that to Fugue, but not to Mother. It wasn't right to do it to her too.] But I am not sure why the clam will be bothered too.
Reply
Leave a comment