Not just him (possibly his advisor),,it is his dissertation committee. Not always a friendly pack, and I have seen them be difficult to work with. In niggly ways.
So, with a mountain of fieldwork and primary sources, the thesis committee turns him down. Is that standard academic practice, or is his committee just a bunch of *ping!* ?
I forsee said thesis committee getting firsthand experience of steel-age customs and legalities.
Okay, that's fair. I would hope that Asher wouldn't commit a generalization error like that in his work, though, without having appropriate comparative material to work with. Considering what he has, he should be able to produce an (inter)stellar thesis/dissertation, though.
Comments 40
Reply
Reply
..seriously, who at that university is going to try to physically mess with him? Honestly?
Reply
They probably dont realize jus t wha t he has gone through yet.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
I forsee said thesis committee getting firsthand experience of steel-age customs and legalities.
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
I believe the phrase is "extended participant-observer case study".
Reply
Leave a comment