1.12 results

Mar 24, 2008 17:41



Eliminated

xelanoops
with -21 points



Voter's choice
red_fullmoon
Mod´s choice
lauradumb




POINTS:
1.-3/+5/+5 = +7
2.-5/-3/+5/+5 = +2
3.-3/-5/-3/-5/-5 = -21
4.-5/-3/+5 = -3

LEAST FAVOURITE COMMENTS:

#01 - there's too much going on in the text, icon looks unbalanced

#02 - the green bit to the side seems out of place
#02 - the cropping is too close and the text is hard to read over his face

#03 - i feel there's lack of contrast in the icon, plus the light effect is a bit distracting and so is the breaking of the word.
#03 - the unaligned text looks sloppy
#03 - the red light texture doesn't look that great, and the icon is boring.
#03 - the text & the light texture cover too much if the icon

#04 - the too much contrast makes gaspard look like a sculpture. the darker test is also a bit unreadable.
#04 - the top line of text is almost unreadable
#04 - the scratchy texture ruins the icon, since the text and cropping are good. but the texture has thrown it off.

FAVORITE VOTE COMMENTS:

#01 - all nicely composed, the text work is great.
#01 - great composition and love the positioning of the text

#02 - gorgeous cropping and light balance
#02 - creative, great coloring. I love how the text was used in relation to the image. :D great icon!

#04 - great text and the cropping & shrinking of the image is done very well.

Congratulations to everyone who participated! The next challenge will be up shortly and the skips post was updated.

round one: results

Previous post Next post
Up