AND THE ROUND 1 LAST ICON MAKER STANDING IS.....

[aurelia]

Before I announce the winner, sorry it's so late. My internet is FINALLY bloody well working. And also, thank you to everyone who participated in Round 1 here at garnerlims and congratulations to the following 3. :D I'll make your banners this weekend.


SECOND RUNNER-UP
michelle_sarah (+6 points)


FIRST RUNNER-UP
nutmeg_05 (+7 points)



ROUND 1 LAST ICON MAKER STANDING
herm_weasley (+ 14 points)



PART 1:
TALLIES: ( Click here for your #'s)
SET 1: +6
SET 2: +2
SET 3: +1

COMMENTS:
Set 01:
- excellent use of reversal in the first icon, effective use of mirroring in the second icon
- These icons are really creative. The first icon has a really good coloring and great composition and use of texture. The second icon has got really nice contrast and nice use of texture too.
- great colouring and blending
- it looks very professional
- this duo was set apart from the rest due to its creativity and it's experimentalism. I haven't seen many icons like the first one made in the set. The coloring is also gorgeous and brings depth and charisma to the pictures.
- Really innovative use of cropping and texture.

Set 02:
- the variety in the styles is nice - the colouring on the first one is coloured very well :)
- the colouring is spot on and the b&w one is good too :)

Set 03:
- LOVE THE COLORING OF THE FIRST ICON AND REPEATING IMAGES OF BOTH LOOK VERY NICE

PART 2:
TALLIES:
ICON 1: +3
ICON 2: +3
ICON 3: +3

COMMENTS:
Icon 01:
- good text placement
- good colouring and use of text
- HAS BEST COLORING AND NICE CROP ALSO LOVE THE TEXT

Icon 02:
- I like the colouring and crop
- I like the vibrant colours
- Lovely colouring!

Icon 03:
- Nice coloring and the borders fit really well.
- nice colouring
- cropping and coloring don't take away from the emotion of the picture.

PART 3:
TALLIES:
HEADER 1: +1
HEADER 2: +5
HEADER 3: +3

COMMENTS:
Header 01:
- nice blending :)

Header 02:
- The colouring and blending are stunning, and I like the combination of both the scribbley script text and the clean serif.
- very original, nice and colourful
- AWSOME COLORING AND BLENDING OF IMAGES TEXT LOOKS GREAT TOO
- very creative, great composition
- Wow this header is just amazing! The colors really fit well together, and it's just perfect:D

Header 03:
- the simplicity and coloring. there isn't other pictures in there with either colorings that don't match up or the text being too overwelming. It gets to the point.
- I think the texture and blending of the pic are fantastic!
- lovely colouring