New Article

Sep 06, 2014 02:29

The next chapter is at beta, so it will be out in the next ( Read more... )

academic, qaf, update

Leave a comment

Comments 15

kmboatright September 6 2014, 07:23:54 UTC
Are you going to talk about Ben and Michael's friends Eli and Monty? And how marriage is portrayed as being "good" and how it's the opposite of the "bad" club going and promiscuous behavior evinced by those who are less mature (or at least those who are Brian)?

Reply

gaedhal September 6 2014, 19:26:40 UTC
This isn't a book for QAF fans. It's an academic book for use in graduate
school classes on media and/or LGBT studies. I'm writing about how marriage
is portrayed on the show.

Reply

kmboatright September 6 2014, 21:28:28 UTC
"This isn't a book for QAF fans. It's an academic book for use in graduate school classes"

I understood that.

"I'm writing about how marriage is portrayed on the show"

You're, in your own words, writing about how marriage is portrayed in the show.
So I was asking if one of the points you were going to cover is how, in the show, marriage is portrayed as the good, mature thing versus promiscuous club going as the bad, immature behavior.
That's not a topic just for QAF fans, and it isn't a topic just for people who want to rehash how Brian Kinney was mistreated. It's a topic throughout the show, and seems like it comes up often enough to deserve a place in any thing written on gay marriage that uses examples from QAF.

Reply

gaedhal September 6 2014, 21:33:34 UTC
Since I haven't even begun writing the article, I think you might
wait until I've at least outlined the thing before you assume
what I'm going to write.

Or else find someone to commission you to write it yourself.

Reply


wren_kt7oz September 6 2014, 09:39:53 UTC
Interesting.

In one case, a legal marriage in Canada.

In another, a ceremony without legal status in front of friends and de facto family.

And then the couple who called off their marriage, but were the ones, IMO, who most closely lived out the ideal of what a "marriage of true minds" can be - a union which supports and encourages both to be the best they can be and which allows them the space and room to grow to be that best.

I'm minded of Kahlil Gibran's injunction - "stand together, but not too near together, ...for the pillars of the temple stand apart, and the oak and the cypress grow not in each other's shadow". (Have I got that right? It's something like that. It's years since I read the Prophet.)

Would love to read the article when it's finished.

Reply

wren_kt7oz September 6 2014, 18:56:23 UTC
I can see mention of Michael and Ben and Mel and Linds, but who had the "marriage of true minds" on the show? Because it surely can't be that wreck of a relationship that was canon Brian and Justin. With the lying, the cheating, and continuous lack of communication, all the flowery words and phrases in the world can't make what Brian and Justin had a real marriage, either legal or "of true minds".

anon7

Reply

gaedhal September 6 2014, 19:28:02 UTC
See my comment above.

This isn't an article for fans. And I'm not going to work out my frustrations
with the show in it.

Reply


shadownyc September 6 2014, 12:35:34 UTC
I can't wait to read your article.

Reply


chadmom September 6 2014, 13:22:56 UTC
Congrats!

Reply

ljtilford September 7 2014, 06:43:26 UTC
DITTO

Ignore the trolls, you will be great.

INHO: The only lieing Brian did was to himself and Justin's were sins of omission

Reply


kinwad September 6 2014, 16:33:03 UTC
Congratulations, Gael!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up