Episode Poll: Season Four

[gabrielleabelle]

Please forgive me if I don't reply to comments on this one. I'm on the sick side of things. Discuss with each other!

Also, next week will be my customary post-season week off. The S5 polls will start the week after, 12/27, with Buffy vs. Dracula.

But now we're wrapping up S4! You all know what that means!

Comments

[pfeifferpack]

Hope you get feeling better soon!

Living Conditions bothered me because Buffy was SO out of proportion nasty to her roommate even before finding out she was a demon. Really....she was happy the girl was a demon so she could kill her with good conscience????? WHY??? The girl only wanted to live like a human and go to college for the most part.....it made Buffy look petty and mean-spirited and she's not like that.

*hugs*
Kathleen

[botias]

I think Buffy was acting nasty because the demon girl had been stealing Buffy's soul for her own use, but it's been awhile. :)

[tigerpetals]

Yes, that's why she was increasingly over-the-top mean.

[relurker]

Buffy has Slayer intuition! She could feel the inherent wrongness of Kathy, and then there's the soul sucking thing: she wasn't working with her full set of good qualities.
Actually, I think about this episode every time Giles or someone else underestimates and undermines Buffy: here's another proof that she gets these things on a level that's different from that of us non-supernatural people.
(And, wow! I'm disagreeing with Pfeifferpack! There must be something wild in the air.)

[pfeifferpack]

LOL.....no one says my opinions are right LOL!

You make a good case for Buffy's instincts being in play. I had forgotten the soul sucking part of it. Okay...maybe I was too hard on Buffy and had a bit too much sympathy for Kathy. Still not my favorite episode but Buffy isn't as out of character as I thought given the whole soul sucking thing.

*hugs*
Kathleen

[relurker]

(True, no one says your opinions are right, it's just that usually I read your comments and think oh, that's what I was going to say if I had realized I was thinking it!)
: )