Round 3 // Challenge 12

[shadowserenity]

Awesome quality, everyone. It'll be difficult to choose!

When voting on the Part 2 redo icons, please remember you are focusing on improvement. Is the new icon an improvement over the original? Part 1 is voting as usual. Please use the example voting format.

The Lowdown:
. You must vote for one icon in Part 1: your one (1) favourite (the entry you consider to be the best). Likewise, you must vote for four icons in Part 2: two (2) least favourite and two (2) favourite. You must provide a reason for all votes.
. Please remember that you are judging on technique, not personal preference. Reasons such as "I dislike this character and I can't believe you used my least favourite colour for your background" are not acceptable.
. To assist you, please head over to obaona's guide to giving good crit.
. For a further look at the voting rules, see the user info.
. Please remember anyone can vote.
. Comments are screened.

Example voting format:

Part 1
F:
## - [reason]

Part 2
LF:
## - [reason]
## - [reason]

F:
## - [reason]
## - [reason]



PART 1: PERIOD DRESS

1

2

3

PART 2: REDO
(OLD > NEW)

1.
>

2.
>

3.
>

4.
>

5.
>

6.
>

Voting concludes Monday, 9th May, 11PM EST.