Leave a comment

Comments 20

txduck February 24 2011, 15:37:08 UTC
thanks for the mods choice :)
comments for #5 please... unscreened is fine

Reply

shadowserenity February 24 2011, 15:58:42 UTC
You're welcome :). I thought your icon was wonderfully creative.

- Brilliant colors and the textured background fits the style of the cover art beautifully.
- I adore the pop art quality to this icon; the use of two primary colours just makes this icon jump out at me; excellent work.

Additional:
- I love the idea, it's very original but I think there are too many dots, especially on his face.
- I love this idea!
- I really liked the 'comic' style to this icon. Interesting idea.
- I really liked the texture use and framing in this icon, the only reason it wasn't a favourite is because the texture would have been more suited to a more cartoon-like image.

Reply


xafirah February 24 2011, 15:49:19 UTC
Congratulations! The winning icons are GORGEOUS!

Unscreened comments for #1 please :) Thank you.

Reply

shadowserenity February 24 2011, 15:59:59 UTC
- Good use of black and white and interesting composition; the "&" seems to bring the icon together, for me.
- [Great composition and colouring. I really like the use of the ampersand to tie the whole thing together]

Additional:
- I have no idea what font that is, but that is a gorgeous "&"!
- great example of a well-contrasted B&W icon.
- [perfect contrast, also the "&" symbol is great addition to the icon, gives the meaning]

Reply

xafirah February 24 2011, 16:15:32 UTC
Thank you!

"I have no idea what font that is, but that is a gorgeous "&"!"
The font is called "Adorable"
http://www.dafont.com/adorable.font

Reply


shadowserenity February 24 2011, 16:01:19 UTC
My results for transparency:

#2:
- I like the simplicity of this icon! The image is crisp, and the centered crop works well.
- The changed background and coloring go really well with the icon.

Additional:
- Great coloring and background replacement!
- Great colouring and crop

Reply


aquietmess February 24 2011, 16:33:51 UTC
Can I have the comments for #10, please? Unscreened is fine :)

Reply

shadowserenity February 24 2011, 23:02:18 UTC
- Good contrast for the black and white; however, there is too much negative space in the icon and the balance feels off. Maybe a closer crop on Riker might help?
- The background used is over-blurred and takes away from the overall icon.

Reply


blueleopard87 February 24 2011, 16:50:24 UTC
Comments for 11, please. Unscreened is fine. :)

Reply

shadowserenity February 24 2011, 23:03:36 UTC
Congrats on Members' Choice :).

- What's not to love about this icon? It's perfect. Colors, details, background texture.
- I like the use of colors in the background from the character, but the character isn't faded into it.
- The subtly of the colors and the crop are great.
- clean and simple, works well

Reply


Leave a comment

Up