jadelennox has a post open for spoilery discussion of Justine Larbalestier's Liar. Most of us commenting so far liked it, I think, but were hoping for it to be a better book than it was, so there's a lot of analysis rather than blind squee.
[NOTE: link goes to the LJ post; the discussion is in the DW post. That is because it is SPOILERY and if you accidentally click the link just because it's there I AM NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR SPOILING.]
I am tracking it for discussion purposes. I'm hoping someone will say something I disagree with and I can get into an ~intellectual argument~ over it but so far everyone's pretty much just being sensible. :(