Fright Night Rec List
Yeah, I have to do it, if for no other reason than to keep track of all my favourites over at the Kinkmeme.
There's not going to be enough of it yet to where there's much point breaking it into different ships, it's just pretty much Peter with ANYONE (definitely skewed towards Peter/Charley, though).
99 Problems by glinda4thegood
Adult
Peter/OC Succubus - A stage magician walks into a bar, after the second worst night of his life. Minor spoilers for movie.
Rec Notes: I think the only fic on this rec list so far not from the Kinkmeme. A bit of an odd pairing, as I'm not usually into OC's, and a bit of a misquote of my favourite song at the moment in the beginning (nitpick: Should be "If you're having girl problems, I feel bad for you son") but the dialogue and execution of this one is just so much fun I can't not rec it. And "Watch me pull a hard-on out of your pants." might be my favourite line, ever.
An Accented Truth by Anonymous
Teen
Peter/Amy/Charley - Prompt: Charley is secretly Russian. Amy is secretly English. Peter is secretly Scottish. Jane is secretly Australian. Jerry is secretly Irish. Why all the secrets? Why are they all hiding? Who is the worst at faking an accent? Who finds out and what happens when they do?
Rec Notes: Hee! Totally hilarious crack!fic in which all of the characters are secretly the nationality which the actors actually are. I adore this one. With bonus blink-and-you'll-miss-it threesome!
Art and Play Piercings by Anonymous
Teen, so far
Peter/Charley - Prompt: For part of his new show, Peter gets a corset piercing. Charley is caught between being horrified and turned on.
Rec Notes: Currently a WIP, and I can't wait for the rest (at which point I'm hoping the rating will go up, *wink wink*)! I have a bit of a piercing kink, so this one delights me (but I swear this wasn't my prompt! I just got lucky). Link goes to part 1 of, currently, 4.
Define by alex_caligari
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: A take-off of Ianto's conversation about Jack in Torchwood Children of Earth: "It's not men, it's just him." How would our two vampire hunters define their relationship?
Rec Notes: Another one from the Torchwood prompt, written by the OP actually, and very fun. Excellent banter between Peter and Charley, and a cute little fail!seduction attempt from Peter.
Eighteen by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Teenagers can be jealous creatures, and Peter obviously can't keep his dick in his pants - I'd like to see what happens when Peter fucks someone else after they've been fucking regularly, and Charley has to deal with his feelings of jealousy.
Rec Notes: Yeah, it's my prompt so I'm predisposed to like it, but you have to admit this is a difficult one to tackle, and the anon here managed to pull it off quite well, making Charley jealous but still trying desperately to play it cool and making Peter more amused and flattered by that jealousy than annoyed. Love it!
Et tu Brute? by skyeblux
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Is that a stake in your pocket or are you just happy to see me?
Rec Notes: A fun fill to one of the first prompts on the kinkmeme which was posted way back in August of ought-11, this one threatens to get sad and makes you think that Peter's joined the legions of the bloodthirsty undead, but stick with it and you'll be pleasantly surprised!
Friction by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Clueless. One of them's clueless, but it works out in the end.
Rec Notes: Rec'd because, while there's a plethora of Peter/Charley in the Kinkmeme, very little of it is actually sexually explicit, so yeah. I appreciate that. :) Plus: FROT. Yeah. My buttons: this pushes them.
Handling by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Charley has to bathe Peter for some reason...he's injured or drunk or just manipulates the situation that way, who knows. Would love it if this leads to a first time handjob for Peter from Charley in the bath.
Rec Notes: This was my prompt, and I'm mighty proud of it - liked it so much I ended up filling it myself eventually. Not only is this a fabulous fill, but it's eerily similar to what I wrote myself, which just speaks to the fact that I love this scenario and this fic is exactly what I wanted! Hot stuff.
Hypothetical by Anonymous
ADULT
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Peter's feeling horny and gives Charley a call... After all, Peter's got himself a sexy voice...
Rec Notes: When I saw the "phone sex" prompt, I honestly couldn't imagine anyone making it work. It just seemed so OOC. Well, I WAS WRONG. This might be my favourite Fright Night fic thus far. It's funny, it's completely in character and the voices are just dead-on PERFECT. And, oh, it's so damn hot your computer might melt down. Do yourself a favour and go read it!
Monkey On His Back by corycides
Adult
Peter/Ginger - Prompt: Peter masturbates to thoughts of Ginger after another disappointing filthy showgirl.
Rec Notes: There's not nearly enough Peter/Ginger out there, for some weird reason, and this one serves it up nicely as a flashback, with a wonderful twist at the end.
Need by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Peter knows he's not the best thing for Charley, so he decides that for Charley's own good, he should break up with him. CHARLEY AIN'T HAVING IT. He screws Peter's guilt into submission.
Rec Notes: I love that Charley does not put up with Peter's asshattery in this one, and I love the sex, of course. Contains m/m penetration, but not very graphic.
Peter/Charlie - first time, but I'm straight! by Anonymous
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Sexually!confused Charley, getting introduced to the wonders of gay sex via Peter.
Rec Notes: Amusing, not-very-graphic (but for language, from Peter of course) sexytiems between Peter and Charley. I like the casual ambivalence from Peter in this one, because of course shagging his male friends is all just another day, for him.
Scars and Lifelines by alex_caligari
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Battle Scars. Peter's didn't escape his first encounter with vampires unscathed. Charley learns his lover's body one old wound at a time.
Rec Notes: YOU GUYS, THIS FIC. I already rec'd this separately on my LJ because I love it so much. Maybe it's my tattoo kink, I dunno, but I find the idea of Charley writing on Peter's body both endearing and incredibly hot.
She Was a Showgirl by Anonymous
ADULT
Peter/Nameless Showgirl - Prompt: "I fucked her. Filthy." Write it. Because I have to know what Peter Vincent considers "filthy".
Rec Notes: Yeah, this was TOTALLY my prompt, and my god, I could not have asked for a better fill than this. Yeah: FILTHY is damn right! In case neither are your bag: includes fisting, and anal sex.
Sleight of Hand and Twist of Fate by hiddentimelord
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: When he was a little kid, Charley got lost in Las Vegas, and was helped out by a kind young man who found him and took him home to his mum and cheered him up with some slieght-of-hand and other little magic tricks. The man never showed up again, but Charley never forgot him.
Years later, Peter has long since forgotten this incident, but Charley still remembers. When he sees Peter stripping off the wig and fake facial hair that first time, he realizes he's found his childhood hero/crush again. he figures this must be some kind of destiny.
Rec Notes: Very sweet and fluffy. I think I like this one just because I'm in love with the idea of young!Peter Vincent. Also, we don't see enough of Peter doing magic tricks in fic, IMHO. Link goes to part 1 of 5.
Tear You Apart by hiddentimelord
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Years after the incident with Jerry, Peter, Charley and Amy have all gone their separate ways. Charley's fairly well adjusted with his life, living single, all that jazz. Then one day Peter shows up at dusk, said he looked him up. For old times sake, Charley invites him in, but Peter's not really Peter anymore. One of Jerry's friends got to him. Something human inside still needs Charley, but it's almost all gone, and Charley starts to realize that something's really wrong with his old friend.
Rec Notes: Nearly not rec'd just because the idea of Peter getting turned makes me unbelievably sad, but this one is good and (spoilers?) Peter doesn't get staked, and Charley lives and remains human. I like, in this one, that there's enough of Peter left in him to recognize that he doesn't want to kill or turn Charley. Contains m/m penetration and lots of biting.
Tourists by Anonymous
ADULT
Peter/Tenth Doctor/Rose - Prompt: Peter/Tenth Doctor/Rose Tyler (well that's pretty self-explanatory, isn't it? :) )
Rec Notes: Doctor Who crossover, in case that isn't obvious. Sweet zombie Jesus, this one is hot. I like that absolutely no explanation is provided for why Rose and the Doctor decide they're totally going to fuck Peter Vincent, or exactly why Ten and Peter resemble each other so closely (though it's hinted at), it's basically just kind of "Hi, let's screw!" WHICH IS PERFECTLY FINE. Contains m/m penetration, if that's not your thing.
Untitled by Anonymous
Teen
Peter/Amy and Peter/Charley (but both only friendly), Amy/Charley - Prompt: Peter and Charley are best buddies now, out on their vampire slaying escapades every other weekend, and quite frankly, Amy is sick of being neglected. She corners Peter one day and after some bartering, insulting and a whole lot of "I saw him first", they finally reach a compromise.
Rec Notes: Cute and funny, totally in character conversation between Amy and Peter wherein she calls him on the fact that he's totally hogging her boyfriend.
Untitled by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Amy - Prompt: Because Amy needs more lovin'...
Peter and Amy bond over having been (or nearly been) vampires. Because they're both who they are, this results in sexytimes. Energetic sexytimes. Maybe with some (not breaking the skin) biting.
Feel free to include Charley, after the fact.
Rec Notes: In what the OP admits is a fill to their own prompt, but oddly, no one else seems to want to touch this pairing, which is a shame. It makes sense that Amy might go to Peter seeking a kindred soul who was nearly turned, and it makes sense that Peter would absolutely not say no if she came onto him. Very sexy fic, and I like that Charley, at the end, does not drag the "You-fucked-my-girlfriend" thing out for too long.
Vamp Killers Extraordinaire by Anonymous
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Charley and Peter are vampire hunting and end up separated briefly. They are forced to have a silent conversation through windows at opposite ends of a room.
Rec Notes: Hilarious little fic in which Charley and Peter have to have a silent conversation across a room ala Partners in Crime.
Various drabbles by multiple authors
Teen - Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: The kinkmeme is all about shortfic, right? Let's go shorter! Give me some sexy bunches of a 100 words. The smuttier, the better! Or silly or cute, or whatever. Just some Peter/Charley goodness in tiny packages.
Rec Notes: What a wonderful idea! I myself have contributed a couple to this, and from what I can tell at least 3 other authors have as well. Drabbles are so much fun because they're so challenging (and warning: some folks on the kinkmeme apparently do not quite grasp the "100 words" concept, but oh well, they're still good). I'm hoping this one will keep getting filled (heh) for awhile.
Why by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: A take-off of Ianto's conversation about Jack in Torchwood Children of Earth: "It's not men, it's just him." How would our two vampire hunters define their relationship?
Rec Notes: Rec'd because it's hot sex between Peter and Charley, and you shouldn't need any more reason than that! But if you do, there's also fun dialogue which made me giggle, and it's fun to see Charley be the aggressor once in awhile. Contains penetration, FYI.
Your Mom by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Jane - Prompt: Jane is lonely, and even though she knows it's wrong to flirt with her son's new best friend (who might actually be Charley's secret sometimes boyfriend, your choice prospective writer), Peter is closer to her age anyway and very attractive. Of course, Peter goes along with it.
Rec Notes: See, I told you I ship Peter with just about everybody! Sexy and funny fic in which Peter totally does Charley's mom, because he so would.
There's not going to be enough of it yet to where there's much point breaking it into different ships, it's just pretty much Peter with ANYONE (definitely skewed towards Peter/Charley, though).
99 Problems by glinda4thegood
Adult
Peter/OC Succubus - A stage magician walks into a bar, after the second worst night of his life. Minor spoilers for movie.
Rec Notes: I think the only fic on this rec list so far not from the Kinkmeme. A bit of an odd pairing, as I'm not usually into OC's, and a bit of a misquote of my favourite song at the moment in the beginning (nitpick: Should be "If you're having girl problems, I feel bad for you son") but the dialogue and execution of this one is just so much fun I can't not rec it. And "Watch me pull a hard-on out of your pants." might be my favourite line, ever.
An Accented Truth by Anonymous
Teen
Peter/Amy/Charley - Prompt: Charley is secretly Russian. Amy is secretly English. Peter is secretly Scottish. Jane is secretly Australian. Jerry is secretly Irish. Why all the secrets? Why are they all hiding? Who is the worst at faking an accent? Who finds out and what happens when they do?
Rec Notes: Hee! Totally hilarious crack!fic in which all of the characters are secretly the nationality which the actors actually are. I adore this one. With bonus blink-and-you'll-miss-it threesome!
Art and Play Piercings by Anonymous
Teen, so far
Peter/Charley - Prompt: For part of his new show, Peter gets a corset piercing. Charley is caught between being horrified and turned on.
Rec Notes: Currently a WIP, and I can't wait for the rest (at which point I'm hoping the rating will go up, *wink wink*)! I have a bit of a piercing kink, so this one delights me (but I swear this wasn't my prompt! I just got lucky). Link goes to part 1 of, currently, 4.
Define by alex_caligari
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: A take-off of Ianto's conversation about Jack in Torchwood Children of Earth: "It's not men, it's just him." How would our two vampire hunters define their relationship?
Rec Notes: Another one from the Torchwood prompt, written by the OP actually, and very fun. Excellent banter between Peter and Charley, and a cute little fail!seduction attempt from Peter.
Eighteen by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Teenagers can be jealous creatures, and Peter obviously can't keep his dick in his pants - I'd like to see what happens when Peter fucks someone else after they've been fucking regularly, and Charley has to deal with his feelings of jealousy.
Rec Notes: Yeah, it's my prompt so I'm predisposed to like it, but you have to admit this is a difficult one to tackle, and the anon here managed to pull it off quite well, making Charley jealous but still trying desperately to play it cool and making Peter more amused and flattered by that jealousy than annoyed. Love it!
Et tu Brute? by skyeblux
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Is that a stake in your pocket or are you just happy to see me?
Rec Notes: A fun fill to one of the first prompts on the kinkmeme which was posted way back in August of ought-11, this one threatens to get sad and makes you think that Peter's joined the legions of the bloodthirsty undead, but stick with it and you'll be pleasantly surprised!
Friction by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Clueless. One of them's clueless, but it works out in the end.
Rec Notes: Rec'd because, while there's a plethora of Peter/Charley in the Kinkmeme, very little of it is actually sexually explicit, so yeah. I appreciate that. :) Plus: FROT. Yeah. My buttons: this pushes them.
Handling by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Charley has to bathe Peter for some reason...he's injured or drunk or just manipulates the situation that way, who knows. Would love it if this leads to a first time handjob for Peter from Charley in the bath.
Rec Notes: This was my prompt, and I'm mighty proud of it - liked it so much I ended up filling it myself eventually. Not only is this a fabulous fill, but it's eerily similar to what I wrote myself, which just speaks to the fact that I love this scenario and this fic is exactly what I wanted! Hot stuff.
Hypothetical by Anonymous
ADULT
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Peter's feeling horny and gives Charley a call... After all, Peter's got himself a sexy voice...
Rec Notes: When I saw the "phone sex" prompt, I honestly couldn't imagine anyone making it work. It just seemed so OOC. Well, I WAS WRONG. This might be my favourite Fright Night fic thus far. It's funny, it's completely in character and the voices are just dead-on PERFECT. And, oh, it's so damn hot your computer might melt down. Do yourself a favour and go read it!
Monkey On His Back by corycides
Adult
Peter/Ginger - Prompt: Peter masturbates to thoughts of Ginger after another disappointing filthy showgirl.
Rec Notes: There's not nearly enough Peter/Ginger out there, for some weird reason, and this one serves it up nicely as a flashback, with a wonderful twist at the end.
Need by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Peter knows he's not the best thing for Charley, so he decides that for Charley's own good, he should break up with him. CHARLEY AIN'T HAVING IT. He screws Peter's guilt into submission.
Rec Notes: I love that Charley does not put up with Peter's asshattery in this one, and I love the sex, of course. Contains m/m penetration, but not very graphic.
Peter/Charlie - first time, but I'm straight! by Anonymous
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Sexually!confused Charley, getting introduced to the wonders of gay sex via Peter.
Rec Notes: Amusing, not-very-graphic (but for language, from Peter of course) sexytiems between Peter and Charley. I like the casual ambivalence from Peter in this one, because of course shagging his male friends is all just another day, for him.
Scars and Lifelines by alex_caligari
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Battle Scars. Peter's didn't escape his first encounter with vampires unscathed. Charley learns his lover's body one old wound at a time.
Rec Notes: YOU GUYS, THIS FIC. I already rec'd this separately on my LJ because I love it so much. Maybe it's my tattoo kink, I dunno, but I find the idea of Charley writing on Peter's body both endearing and incredibly hot.
She Was a Showgirl by Anonymous
ADULT
Peter/Nameless Showgirl - Prompt: "I fucked her. Filthy." Write it. Because I have to know what Peter Vincent considers "filthy".
Rec Notes: Yeah, this was TOTALLY my prompt, and my god, I could not have asked for a better fill than this. Yeah: FILTHY is damn right! In case neither are your bag: includes fisting, and anal sex.
Sleight of Hand and Twist of Fate by hiddentimelord
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: When he was a little kid, Charley got lost in Las Vegas, and was helped out by a kind young man who found him and took him home to his mum and cheered him up with some slieght-of-hand and other little magic tricks. The man never showed up again, but Charley never forgot him.
Years later, Peter has long since forgotten this incident, but Charley still remembers. When he sees Peter stripping off the wig and fake facial hair that first time, he realizes he's found his childhood hero/crush again. he figures this must be some kind of destiny.
Rec Notes: Very sweet and fluffy. I think I like this one just because I'm in love with the idea of young!Peter Vincent. Also, we don't see enough of Peter doing magic tricks in fic, IMHO. Link goes to part 1 of 5.
Tear You Apart by hiddentimelord
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Years after the incident with Jerry, Peter, Charley and Amy have all gone their separate ways. Charley's fairly well adjusted with his life, living single, all that jazz. Then one day Peter shows up at dusk, said he looked him up. For old times sake, Charley invites him in, but Peter's not really Peter anymore. One of Jerry's friends got to him. Something human inside still needs Charley, but it's almost all gone, and Charley starts to realize that something's really wrong with his old friend.
Rec Notes: Nearly not rec'd just because the idea of Peter getting turned makes me unbelievably sad, but this one is good and (spoilers?) Peter doesn't get staked, and Charley lives and remains human. I like, in this one, that there's enough of Peter left in him to recognize that he doesn't want to kill or turn Charley. Contains m/m penetration and lots of biting.
Tourists by Anonymous
ADULT
Peter/Tenth Doctor/Rose - Prompt: Peter/Tenth Doctor/Rose Tyler (well that's pretty self-explanatory, isn't it? :) )
Rec Notes: Doctor Who crossover, in case that isn't obvious. Sweet zombie Jesus, this one is hot. I like that absolutely no explanation is provided for why Rose and the Doctor decide they're totally going to fuck Peter Vincent, or exactly why Ten and Peter resemble each other so closely (though it's hinted at), it's basically just kind of "Hi, let's screw!" WHICH IS PERFECTLY FINE. Contains m/m penetration, if that's not your thing.
Untitled by Anonymous
Teen
Peter/Amy and Peter/Charley (but both only friendly), Amy/Charley - Prompt: Peter and Charley are best buddies now, out on their vampire slaying escapades every other weekend, and quite frankly, Amy is sick of being neglected. She corners Peter one day and after some bartering, insulting and a whole lot of "I saw him first", they finally reach a compromise.
Rec Notes: Cute and funny, totally in character conversation between Amy and Peter wherein she calls him on the fact that he's totally hogging her boyfriend.
Untitled by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Amy - Prompt: Because Amy needs more lovin'...
Peter and Amy bond over having been (or nearly been) vampires. Because they're both who they are, this results in sexytimes. Energetic sexytimes. Maybe with some (not breaking the skin) biting.
Feel free to include Charley, after the fact.
Rec Notes: In what the OP admits is a fill to their own prompt, but oddly, no one else seems to want to touch this pairing, which is a shame. It makes sense that Amy might go to Peter seeking a kindred soul who was nearly turned, and it makes sense that Peter would absolutely not say no if she came onto him. Very sexy fic, and I like that Charley, at the end, does not drag the "You-fucked-my-girlfriend" thing out for too long.
Vamp Killers Extraordinaire by Anonymous
Teen
Peter/Charley - Prompt: Charley and Peter are vampire hunting and end up separated briefly. They are forced to have a silent conversation through windows at opposite ends of a room.
Rec Notes: Hilarious little fic in which Charley and Peter have to have a silent conversation across a room ala Partners in Crime.
Various drabbles by multiple authors
Teen - Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: The kinkmeme is all about shortfic, right? Let's go shorter! Give me some sexy bunches of a 100 words. The smuttier, the better! Or silly or cute, or whatever. Just some Peter/Charley goodness in tiny packages.
Rec Notes: What a wonderful idea! I myself have contributed a couple to this, and from what I can tell at least 3 other authors have as well. Drabbles are so much fun because they're so challenging (and warning: some folks on the kinkmeme apparently do not quite grasp the "100 words" concept, but oh well, they're still good). I'm hoping this one will keep getting filled (heh) for awhile.
Why by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Charley - Prompt: A take-off of Ianto's conversation about Jack in Torchwood Children of Earth: "It's not men, it's just him." How would our two vampire hunters define their relationship?
Rec Notes: Rec'd because it's hot sex between Peter and Charley, and you shouldn't need any more reason than that! But if you do, there's also fun dialogue which made me giggle, and it's fun to see Charley be the aggressor once in awhile. Contains penetration, FYI.
Your Mom by Anonymous
Adult
Peter/Jane - Prompt: Jane is lonely, and even though she knows it's wrong to flirt with her son's new best friend (who might actually be Charley's secret sometimes boyfriend, your choice prospective writer), Peter is closer to her age anyway and very attractive. Of course, Peter goes along with it.
Rec Notes: See, I told you I ship Peter with just about everybody! Sexy and funny fic in which Peter totally does Charley's mom, because he so would.