Round Fifteen: Final Phase - RESULTS
ROUND FIFTEEN: FINAL PHASE - RESULTS
Whew whatever I said last night was certainly the right thing to say! We pulled in another 6 votes, so I would now like to pronounce you all with your Last Icon Maker Standing for this round!
kawaii_chicken
Rikku
And let's not forget our two runner-ups:
reldniws
Auron
dragon_gypsy
Zack
COMMENTS:
+ = positibe vote
* = general comments
: reldniws
[+] I just love how the texture work is. I love all the textures used, the simple cropping & negative space. It also goes very well with the quote used.
[*] This icon is nice, but I feel like it's almost too plain, like it needed something else.
: kawaii_chicken
[+] The center image alignment gives off an interesting look and is well accompanied by the text alignment. The magenta/red hues are a bit bright, but that's what make the icon stand out as well :)
[+] I love the bright colors, fun textures, and your wonderful use of text, as usual. ;P
[+] Beautiful colors and the text is laid out EXCELLENTLY
[+] I think the text use is very creative on this one, and the cropping makes it stand out perfectly. The texture in the back ties it all together without being too busy
[+] The coloring is really nice, and the placement of Yuna fits very well with the composition of this icon. I think maybe a different font would've worked better, though.
[+] While the text is slightly over-sharpened, the composition of background and character is wonderful and the vibrant colours are really pretty as well
: dragon_gypsy
[+] I love how the scene is really 'real' in this icon. great crop and colouring!
[*] Love the emotion in the icon, the coloring is a bit on the dark side but the contrast of the darks and blues make up for it.
[*]The coloring and crop are pretty, but I feel like a texture or text could have made it even better.
[*] Love the layout of this icon -- very dynamic and eyecatching
I'd like to thank all of the participants for this past round for joining us on our return round!
There are still a few more days left to sign up for round 16! We currently have 9 people so that means just one more before I can start with what I would like to be a minimum deck~ (though sign-ups will be left open through the first phase). See you all again on Friday!
Whew whatever I said last night was certainly the right thing to say! We pulled in another 6 votes, so I would now like to pronounce you all with your Last Icon Maker Standing for this round!
kawaii_chicken
Rikku
And let's not forget our two runner-ups:
reldniws
Auron
dragon_gypsy
Zack
COMMENTS:
+ = positibe vote
* = general comments
: reldniws
[+] I just love how the texture work is. I love all the textures used, the simple cropping & negative space. It also goes very well with the quote used.
[*] This icon is nice, but I feel like it's almost too plain, like it needed something else.
: kawaii_chicken
[+] The center image alignment gives off an interesting look and is well accompanied by the text alignment. The magenta/red hues are a bit bright, but that's what make the icon stand out as well :)
[+] I love the bright colors, fun textures, and your wonderful use of text, as usual. ;P
[+] Beautiful colors and the text is laid out EXCELLENTLY
[+] I think the text use is very creative on this one, and the cropping makes it stand out perfectly. The texture in the back ties it all together without being too busy
[+] The coloring is really nice, and the placement of Yuna fits very well with the composition of this icon. I think maybe a different font would've worked better, though.
[+] While the text is slightly over-sharpened, the composition of background and character is wonderful and the vibrant colours are really pretty as well
: dragon_gypsy
[+] I love how the scene is really 'real' in this icon. great crop and colouring!
[*] Love the emotion in the icon, the coloring is a bit on the dark side but the contrast of the darks and blues make up for it.
[*]The coloring and crop are pretty, but I feel like a texture or text could have made it even better.
[*] Love the layout of this icon -- very dynamic and eyecatching
I'd like to thank all of the participants for this past round for joining us on our return round!
There are still a few more days left to sign up for round 16! We currently have 9 people so that means just one more before I can start with what I would like to be a minimum deck~ (though sign-ups will be left open through the first phase). See you all again on Friday!