Round 15: Phase Four - Results
I'm SO sorry for the huge delay. I had some stress with my apprenticeship starting on Thursday, but now I'm back and we're onto the next round.
ROUND FIFTEEN: PHASE FOUR - RESULTS
SAYING GOODBYE
Relm - instantwings
Sorry to see you both go.
RESULTS
Scarlet: +2
Relm: -1 *
Serah: +3, -1 = +2
Zack: +1, -2 = -1 *
Penelo: +2, -1 = +1
Auron: +7 Favorite Icon of the Phase!
* Since Zack and Relm had the same amount of points, I decided in favor of the one who had positive votes, too
[+] = positive vote; [-] = negative vote; [G] = General comment
: Scarlet
[+] It's so cute!
: Relm
[-] I like the repeating image, but the top half is muddy/blurry looking which kind of throws me off. Also the "i"in artist is overlapping rebellious and it looks a little sloppy.
: Serah
[+] Great texture use!
[+] Not crazy over the coloring but the texture usage is nice, and the text is great as well.
[-] The texture used isnt the most flattering to use for the image chosen. Its not as good as the others.
: Zack
[-] The figure seems a tad oversharpened, and it is too dark to be able to make out clearly. Perhaps it might have been better to raise the brightness of the icon a little.
[-] The cropping's great but the dark coloring makes it difficult to distinguish what's in the icon.
: Penelo
[+] I like how shiny/shimmery this looks on my computer and I love the drop shadow on the text.
[-] It's a nice icon, but the light blob comes off as a little strong, and the text doesn't make sense.
: Auron
[+] Really pretty icon. The text placement really gives it a sense of movement!
[+] I adore the cropping, the coloring, the bold typography, it's a fabulous icon, nicely done.
ROUND FIFTEEN: PHASE FOUR - RESULTS
SAYING GOODBYE
Relm - instantwings
Sorry to see you both go.
RESULTS
Scarlet: +2
Relm: -1 *
Serah: +3, -1 = +2
Zack: +1, -2 = -1 *
Penelo: +2, -1 = +1
Auron: +7 Favorite Icon of the Phase!
* Since Zack and Relm had the same amount of points, I decided in favor of the one who had positive votes, too
[+] = positive vote; [-] = negative vote; [G] = General comment
: Scarlet
[+] It's so cute!
: Relm
[-] I like the repeating image, but the top half is muddy/blurry looking which kind of throws me off. Also the "i"in artist is overlapping rebellious and it looks a little sloppy.
: Serah
[+] Great texture use!
[+] Not crazy over the coloring but the texture usage is nice, and the text is great as well.
[-] The texture used isnt the most flattering to use for the image chosen. Its not as good as the others.
: Zack
[-] The figure seems a tad oversharpened, and it is too dark to be able to make out clearly. Perhaps it might have been better to raise the brightness of the icon a little.
[-] The cropping's great but the dark coloring makes it difficult to distinguish what's in the icon.
: Penelo
[+] I like how shiny/shimmery this looks on my computer and I love the drop shadow on the text.
[-] It's a nice icon, but the light blob comes off as a little strong, and the text doesn't make sense.
: Auron
[+] Really pretty icon. The text placement really gives it a sense of movement!
[+] I adore the cropping, the coloring, the bold typography, it's a fabulous icon, nicely done.