Currently "Good to Have You With Us", by The Killers. Probably because it's short and simple and makes me happy.
Since we're on music and I've been meaning to do this, how about My Supernatural Music Wishlist!
Songs I'll probably cry if they don't use:
"Sympathy for the Devil", by The Rolling Stones.
"Won't Back Down" or "Refugee" by Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers.
"Fortunate One", by Creedence Clearwater Revival.
"Superstition", by Stevie Wonder.
"Twilight Zone", by Golden Earring.
Songs they should've used but blew their chance:
"Roadhouse Blues" by The Doors. (for the Roadhouse.)
"Midnight Rider" by The Allman Brothers. (for the FBI-on-their-ass storyline.)
"The Joker", by Steve Miller Band. (for the Trickster.)
"Werewolves of London", by the late-great Warren Zevon. (For a cool Werewolf story.)
Songs that aren't essential but make me think of Show.
"Blue on Black", by Kenny Wayne Shepherd.
"New Dark Ages", by Bad Religion.
"Shelter from the Storm", Bob Dylan.
"Golden Age", by Beck.
Of course any more AC/DC, Johnny Cash, or BOC is always welcome. And there's tons of Zeppelin I'd die for, but that's never gonna happen. I'd share all of these, but mediafire is being slow. :P