Results - Round 2 Challenge 1

Sep 07, 2012 23:23

Results are finally ready for the first challenge in Round 2. Thank you to everyone voting; there was a great turnout!

click to find out! )

r02.ch01, results

Leave a comment

Comments 16

kungfuwaynewho September 8 2012, 03:28:20 UTC
Feedback on 5, unscreened is fine.

Reply

ghanimasun September 9 2012, 02:59:22 UTC
LEAST
#05 - The icon is too busy, between the colors, stripes and text; love the crop and layout, however
#05 - (no reason given)

BEST
#05 - I like the risk taken with this and I think it worked out nicely. The colors are bold but not overly vivid, the slightly skewed subject orientation and background fading really make the subject pop. I don't like the text though; it's hard to read and would have benefitted from a clearer font.

Reply


december21st September 8 2012, 04:05:10 UTC
Excellent! My icon was truly awful, and deserved to get voted off the island.

I can only be proud that I gave the next-to-last person another round of life.

Keep on iconing, 'Scapers!

Reply

ghanimasun September 9 2012, 03:02:04 UTC
Thanks for participating! Did you want any of the feedback for that icon?

Reply


jsfunction September 8 2012, 09:56:35 UTC
Oh, I'm sad to see you go, december21st :/
And congrats to shan! :)

I'd love to know the maker of 7, I really loved it and would like to use with credit.

Of course I'd like to see my feedback (yay thanks for the votes!), unscreened is fine. I forgot to put this in the feedback thread but I've always kinda thought this could be a default, like in turbo_rumble where all the feedbacks just get posted like this. This way others can learn from the feedback you get too!

Reply

ghanimasun September 9 2012, 03:23:31 UTC
BEST
#03 - lovely warm colors
#03 - Texture looks great and the colors are beautiful
#03 - The warmth of the background and shading fit the emotion displayed in the crop. Focus is soft but not too soft, and I like how Aeryn's thumb merges with the background.
#03 - reason: I love the crop, the coloring and the texture.
#03 - Beautiful icon! I love the yellow colouring :)

Reply

ghanimasun September 9 2012, 05:20:36 UTC
Also thanks for the feedback. That might be a good idea to distribute feedback like that, but it depends on how others feel about their feedback being made public really. I don't want to force anyone into that without warning. Maybe it's something I could install the next round though if there is interest/support.

Reply

torzy86 September 13 2012, 04:45:32 UTC
7 is mine and of course you can use it :D

Reply


jacquelee September 8 2012, 10:22:53 UTC
I DIDN'T GET ANY NEGATIVE VOTES!!! YAY!!! I can die happy now! :D

Reply

ghanimasun September 9 2012, 03:25:37 UTC
CONGRATS :D

Would you like the positive feedback you got?

Reply


shan_3414 September 8 2012, 22:39:00 UTC
Eee, thanks so much for the votes, guys!

I'd like my feedback; unscreened is fine. :)

Reply

ghanimasun September 9 2012, 03:41:11 UTC
BEST
#09 - love the cropping and placement; and the muted pinks and purples are a lovely balance
#09 - love the texture and the crop. Very well done icon
#09 - The way you've made her smoothly blend into the background/textures is very skillful and looks gorgeous!
#09 - The crop is great and the light looks amazing.
#09 - texture/colouring is seamless.
#09 - Great crop, lovely soft coloring. Love the hazy texture.
#09 - reason: I really like the soft coloring and the texture use.
#09 - (no reason given)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up