Comments | fantasyreaders: The Bone Palace

comrade_cat in fantasyreaders

The Bone Palace - Amanda Downum

Dec 11, 2010 21:47

The Bone Palace

( Read more... )

author last name: d, high fantasy, review

Comments 8

phoenixfalls December 12 2010, 05:20:04 UTC

Does The Bone Palace stand on its own, or do you need to read The Drowning City first?

comrade_cat December 12 2010, 05:54:11 UTC

Well, let me put it this way: I don't know, because I haven't read The Drowning City yet. So if I missed anything it wasn't enough to make The Bone Palace not make sense.

The timeline seems to be:
prologue of Bone Palace
Drowning City
[+3 years]
Bone Palace

where Drowning City is sort of Isyllt going to another country and doing stuff mostly unrelated to Bone Palace.

phoenixfalls December 12 2010, 06:11:59 UTC

I see. THAT'S why I couldn't find your review of The Drowning City anywhere in the archives. ;)

comrade_cat December 12 2010, 06:28:31 UTC

That's why. ;)

Thread 5

calico_reaction December 13 2010, 15:37:59 UTC

Is this book a direct sequel to The Drowning City?

calico_reaction December 13 2010, 15:38:26 UTC

Sorry, just saw that you already answered that very question! :)

In which I am bemused. . . pingback_bot March 29 2011, 00:07:44 UTC

User phoenixfalls referenced to your post from In which I am bemused. . . saying: [...] by Amanda Downum. I picked it up because of this review [...]