Leave a comment

Comments 3

astrothsknot October 23 2006, 23:45:09 UTC
looks like we won't be agreeing on much this week!

I hear you on how Dean's one-liners had an edge of cruelty about them, but for me that made it funnier. I found Dean scary when he confronted the father and when he was warning Neil. Like you, I loved that bit. It's a change from last year when they'd be dragging him out kicking and screaming. Now, man's an adult. Let him stand or fall by his own choices.

Did you see Torchwood?

Reply

astrothsknot October 23 2006, 23:46:42 UTC
And the last five mins that everyone's raving about? Dean needs punched. That is all.

Reply

fairyd123 October 24 2006, 19:54:31 UTC
It's been fascinating to see how diverse everyone's reactions to this ep was. I've seen reviews comparing it to Route 666 and I've seen incredibly positive reviews like yours. Personally because I felt that the plot was weak and the guest cast lousy the ep will never be a favourite in the same way as say Faith or Phantom Traveler or Dead in the Water ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up