Finally, HBP review...

Jul 25, 2009 14:17

I'm sorry cookiescene, I didn't do the film review yesterday ( Read more... )

book, book fair, harry potter, harry potter and the half blood prince, film review

Leave a comment

Comments 17

cookiescene July 25 2009, 12:53:42 UTC
wow, you made it so precisely, i like it a lot ^^ and i absolutely agree with almost all of your comments.

every Ron moment was just hilarious!lol, esp when H&R were fighting in potion class, haha xD he is soo funny!

but the most disappointing was, that there were no fight at all! cmon! what the hell they were thinking? for me it was the best moment in the book and they just simply ignored it! -.- i wanted to see chaos so bad, grrr :(

Reply

fahrenheit1993 July 26 2009, 02:23:49 UTC
Thank you so much♥
Haha, yes. Rupert did a really great job in this film, his facial expressions are brilliant, he really plays his role well:)
Absolutely! No fight at all! It is really the greatest moment in the book, I bet everyone wanted to see that moment, but they just simply ignore it! It was DEAD SILENCE, completely different from the book. I was like 'WHAT!? THEY CHANGE THIS? NO WAY, I'M GONNA PUNCH THEM IF I CAN' LOL

Reply

cookiescene July 26 2009, 10:14:34 UTC
i think everyone, who read the book waited fot that moment. and if they would cut every useless H/G scenes (esp when Ginny ties Harry's shoe oO), they would find time to make a wonderful and chaotic fight! xD

Reply

fahrenheit1993 July 26 2009, 12:26:23 UTC
Agreeeeee! If they could just cut all the useless scenes, add the chaotic fight, add the funeral... the film will be perfect!

Reply


alejandrita439 July 26 2009, 03:35:22 UTC
i agree with almost all your points...

i didnt like the ginny and harry scenes (actually i dont like the ship), they seem so forced, awkward and unnecessary.

i also hate that ginny rushed towards Harry, trying to help him when the death eaters were attacking

when ginny was the one that hide the book i was like ¨WTF, now how is harry going to discover were is the ravenclaw diadem?¨

I LOVE the harry/hermione scenes, they are always so awesome... :)

Reply

fahrenheit1993 July 26 2009, 04:24:42 UTC
thank you:)
agree, I don't like H/G shipping at all, so unnatural I'd say.
yes, definitely. it's useless that ginny rushed towards harry:(
another yes, guess they want to increse bonnie appearance frequency? they really want to change the whole thing, don't they?

I love H/HR scenes too, it's just I think there're too many. the book doesn't focus too much on them, because the theme of the book is Half blood prince and Dumbledore and Harry.

Reply


chlarkookie July 26 2009, 04:14:42 UTC
Hey! I'm really new to the HP fandom but wanted to read your review. :)

We agree in a bunch of stuff (and I haven't read the book, actually your review makes me wanna read it so much).

Most of Harry-Ginny, really waste of time. And I was expecting a bit more from the Dumbledore death, I mean... it's DUMBLEDORE!!

Loving all the H/Hr stuff and this movie made me laugh A LOT.

Awesome review :)

Reply

fahrenheit1993 July 26 2009, 04:31:36 UTC
Welcome to the HP fandom♥
Haha, thanks, you really should read the book. I always think that the books are most original and better than films.
Definitely, H/G scenes are uselessLOL Me too, I was so expecting Dumbledore's death, they just RUINED THE FILM/BOOK!
Yeah, love H/HR stuff too, and this time they add a lot of funny scenes, I think that was a success. Everyone laughs during the film:D

Thank you so much♥

Reply


xcyanidexsunx July 26 2009, 19:46:34 UTC
I TOTALLY agree with you, especially with this "8. HBP is supposed to be tensed, chaotic, heartbreaking, dangerous, but the film just gave me a dead silence feeling. I don't know why, maybe it's just my crazy feeling, but I really don't like the whole atmosphere." Also, H/G scenes... oh please, they didn't make any sense at all! and I like the ship but, in the book.
One thing I like were the scenes where the camera focused on Dumbledore's wand, The wand. But I agree with what you said about the Ravenclaw diadem, Harry had to hide the book, not Ginny. And, is it me or the films (not just this one) give the impresion that there's something between Harry and Hermione while in the books is clear that they're just friends?

Reply

fahrenheit1993 July 27 2009, 04:36:33 UTC
Brilliant!
Oh yes, the wand. I like the wand, I think the wand is, okay, elegantOTL
Yes, me too. It's like all the films are hinting that Harry and Hermione have something, they're always close! Maybe the producer ships H/HR tooLOL

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

fahrenheit1993 July 27 2009, 07:28:24 UTC
Yeah, me too. I don't care who's with Ginny, just not Harry.
YESSSS! I CAN'T BELIEVE IT TOO, RON IS EXCLUDED SO MUCH!!! AND THAT JUST DOESN'T MAKE SENSE!!
Absolutely. All of them have improved so much.
Haha, bellatrix is really realy CREEPY and the one(sorry I forget her name) who plays bellatrix is just wonderful, she acts welllll!!:DDD

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

fahrenheit1993 July 28 2009, 02:42:55 UTC
Yeah, I know. The creepiness is just creepy and awesome as well:DDDD
Sweeney Todd sounds so horrible and creepy when tv promotes it, I didn't dare to see it. But I know Helena did a very good job in it:D

Call my Janet, Laura:D

Reply


Leave a comment

Up