LIMS 1 :: Challenge 1 :: Results
:( We have to say goodbye to the following contestants...
Eliminated:
lady_boromir | -8/+0
&
imeccentric | -7/+0
People's Choice:
silverseaicons | -0/+3
&
qwertykate88 | -0/+3
Mod's Choice:
qwertykate88
I loved the texture use and the color is lovely! :D
Tally:
01. -0/+3
02. -1/+0
03. -5/+0
04. -0/+1
05. -3/+0
06. -3/+2
07. -2/+0
08. -2/+0
09. -0/+1
10. -2/+0
11. -8/+0
12. -7/+0
13. -1/+0
14. -6/+1
15. -0/+3
16. -0/+1
17. -2/+1
18. -4/+0
If you icon number is not listed, you received no votes. Congrats!
Comments:
:: Negative ::
02 - Bad cropping.
03 - The text is hard to read
05 - The swirl is nice, but the coloring doesn't really fit.
05 - Sorta blurry, and needs more sharpening.
05 - Yet again the icon looks kind of pixaly. The coloring is to pink.
06 - There's too much cyan, and the colours are oversaturated, making the image too grainy.
06 - It was sharpened a bit too much.
06 - I like the coloring but it's a little too sharp.
07 - Mmm, I don't like the croping very much, and also the coloring
07 - There doesn't seem to have been much done to the coloring, and the icon could use more details (text, brushes, etc.)
08 - Reason- The face looks distorted and it's way too red. Also the background doesn't really fit with count olaf.
08 - The red is a little too strong.
10 - Too blurry.
10 - nice but the whites alittle much and the font isnt too exciting
11 - The cutout border is distracting and unnecessary. It breaks up the image too much.
11 - The icon is too scratchy and overall just way too busy.
11 - The inverted border does not fit well with this already busy picture. That effect is better saved for a very simple picture.
11 - hmm, well, It was a good idea, but the repeated image is jut confusing.
11 - The center border is very distracting
11 - The icon looks a bit pixaly and it doesn't look like the coloring was messed with much.
11 - kind of confusing with the box thingy.
11 - Reason- The picture is boring and too plain. Also the little green thing around it doesn't flatter the photo at all.
12 - The coloring is too overpowering.
12 - The blue is oversaturated and looks unnatural. It decreases the quality of the image.
12 - The coloring is very contrasted and washed out
12 - I don't like the coloring, it's way too blue to my liking
12 - The coloring is a little too...blue and bright. And it's difficult to read the text.
12 - The colour seems off and it's blurry, hard to see.
12 - It's a good icon but the blue is too strong.
13 - there's not much interaction with the icon. its kind of plain and the text is boring.
14 - The coloring is a little too much and I don't like the text that's cutting across their heads.
14 - The coloring is too much, especially all the red on their faces. The texture doesn't really fit the picture.
14 - colroing is quite purple and too saturated/burned. nice use of texture though.
14 - It's a little bit blury, and the tiny text looks like a bunch of blocks, plus the black text is unreadable.
14 - Reason-Theres way too much going on in the picture and the coloring doesn't work with the picture. Also the faces are too red and fuzzy.
14 - Colors are badly over saturated.
17 - The coloring on her lips seems almost flourescent.
17 - It seems too plain. The coloring is ok but there needs to be more going on. Try using textures and brushes, if not text.
18 - Cropping Klause in there made the icon odd looking. It's also a little too dark.
18 - It's too simple and the colors are too dull
18 - the coloring is odd and the blending is wierd too
18 - Blending looks silly.
:: Positive ::
01 - It has the perfect balance of colour, not to mention that it isn't oversharpened or blurry.
01 - The coloring is amazing, it's not to simple and the quality is great!
01 - Cropping and text work well with the image.
04 - The cropping is good. And I like the color given to it.
06 - The coloring is amazing and really sticks out from the rest of the icons.
06 - I really like the coloring in this icon, and the cropping, and it looks simple, yet beautiful :)
09 - The coloring is really pretty and great use of text!
14 - wonderful coloring. fun. vibrant.
15 - Lovely colouring that really fits the image and the story. Simple, yet effective.
15 - The coloring is lovely, the texture is perfect, and the text is simple and not overbearing. Really captures the mood of the movie.
15 - The coloring is lovely; not too bright or bold. And the use of text and textures is lovely as well.
16 - Reason- It is really creative and the coloring is really good but unusual.
17 - excellent cropping, coloring and overall use of simply iconry.
** The BYES POST has been updated.
Eliminated:
lady_boromir | -8/+0
&
imeccentric | -7/+0
People's Choice:
silverseaicons | -0/+3
&
qwertykate88 | -0/+3
Mod's Choice:
qwertykate88
I loved the texture use and the color is lovely! :D
Tally:
01. -0/+3
02. -1/+0
03. -5/+0
04. -0/+1
05. -3/+0
06. -3/+2
07. -2/+0
08. -2/+0
09. -0/+1
10. -2/+0
11. -8/+0
12. -7/+0
13. -1/+0
14. -6/+1
15. -0/+3
16. -0/+1
17. -2/+1
18. -4/+0
If you icon number is not listed, you received no votes. Congrats!
Comments:
:: Negative ::
02 - Bad cropping.
03 - The text is hard to read
05 - The swirl is nice, but the coloring doesn't really fit.
05 - Sorta blurry, and needs more sharpening.
05 - Yet again the icon looks kind of pixaly. The coloring is to pink.
06 - There's too much cyan, and the colours are oversaturated, making the image too grainy.
06 - It was sharpened a bit too much.
06 - I like the coloring but it's a little too sharp.
07 - Mmm, I don't like the croping very much, and also the coloring
07 - There doesn't seem to have been much done to the coloring, and the icon could use more details (text, brushes, etc.)
08 - Reason- The face looks distorted and it's way too red. Also the background doesn't really fit with count olaf.
08 - The red is a little too strong.
10 - Too blurry.
10 - nice but the whites alittle much and the font isnt too exciting
11 - The cutout border is distracting and unnecessary. It breaks up the image too much.
11 - The icon is too scratchy and overall just way too busy.
11 - The inverted border does not fit well with this already busy picture. That effect is better saved for a very simple picture.
11 - hmm, well, It was a good idea, but the repeated image is jut confusing.
11 - The center border is very distracting
11 - The icon looks a bit pixaly and it doesn't look like the coloring was messed with much.
11 - kind of confusing with the box thingy.
11 - Reason- The picture is boring and too plain. Also the little green thing around it doesn't flatter the photo at all.
12 - The coloring is too overpowering.
12 - The blue is oversaturated and looks unnatural. It decreases the quality of the image.
12 - The coloring is very contrasted and washed out
12 - I don't like the coloring, it's way too blue to my liking
12 - The coloring is a little too...blue and bright. And it's difficult to read the text.
12 - The colour seems off and it's blurry, hard to see.
12 - It's a good icon but the blue is too strong.
13 - there's not much interaction with the icon. its kind of plain and the text is boring.
14 - The coloring is a little too much and I don't like the text that's cutting across their heads.
14 - The coloring is too much, especially all the red on their faces. The texture doesn't really fit the picture.
14 - colroing is quite purple and too saturated/burned. nice use of texture though.
14 - It's a little bit blury, and the tiny text looks like a bunch of blocks, plus the black text is unreadable.
14 - Reason-Theres way too much going on in the picture and the coloring doesn't work with the picture. Also the faces are too red and fuzzy.
14 - Colors are badly over saturated.
17 - The coloring on her lips seems almost flourescent.
17 - It seems too plain. The coloring is ok but there needs to be more going on. Try using textures and brushes, if not text.
18 - Cropping Klause in there made the icon odd looking. It's also a little too dark.
18 - It's too simple and the colors are too dull
18 - the coloring is odd and the blending is wierd too
18 - Blending looks silly.
:: Positive ::
01 - It has the perfect balance of colour, not to mention that it isn't oversharpened or blurry.
01 - The coloring is amazing, it's not to simple and the quality is great!
01 - Cropping and text work well with the image.
04 - The cropping is good. And I like the color given to it.
06 - The coloring is amazing and really sticks out from the rest of the icons.
06 - I really like the coloring in this icon, and the cropping, and it looks simple, yet beautiful :)
09 - The coloring is really pretty and great use of text!
14 - wonderful coloring. fun. vibrant.
15 - Lovely colouring that really fits the image and the story. Simple, yet effective.
15 - The coloring is lovely, the texture is perfect, and the text is simple and not overbearing. Really captures the mood of the movie.
15 - The coloring is lovely; not too bright or bold. And the use of text and textures is lovely as well.
16 - Reason- It is really creative and the coloring is really good but unusual.
17 - excellent cropping, coloring and overall use of simply iconry.
** The BYES POST has been updated.