Round 4, Challenge 5, Results
The votes are counted, and the turn out is much better this week! THANKS!:D
Unfortunately, we have to say goodbye to an iconmaker this week too:(
But congratulations to the winner!
Eliminated:
river_sunshine : -7
People's Choice:
dance_the_dance : +5
- Banner will come as soon as I have the time to make it!
[ voting tally]
01: +1+1+1+1+1= +5
02: -1-1+1-1= -2
03: +1+1+1+1= +4
04: -1-1-1-1-1-1-1= -7
Comments:
To eliminate:
02 - Evangeline's skin a bit too yellow and bad text placement.
02 - The text doesn't fit the icon.
02 - Far too light, and the text is hard to read. Also, it could use a little more contrast
04 - It's too much white on the face and the cropping looks pretty bad
04 - The icon is too lightened and too blurry, her hair has a blue shine as well which doesn't work appealing.
04 - The icon looks a bit too blurry, it is too light, and the crop is too centered.
04 - Didn't follow the Special Rule.
04 - The crop is quite plain and her cheeks have unnatural color
04 - The blue tint to her hair is strong and unflattering
04 - The colouring seems really too much - she looks like a puppet or something
To keep:
01 - Very nicely done
01 - Interesting crop and nice subtle coloration
01 - Beautiful b/w color, the text match perfectly and love the touch of color on the hair.
01 - I really like the text with the little text under it!
01 - Great use of text and tinytext. It really fits in.
02 - Nice, soft coloring and text
03 - Good cropping and coloring. Text placement is so good.
03 - The coloring is really beautiful! The cropping also is stunning, and brings out the beautiful curly hair. Just stunning!
03 - Lovely contrast & coloring.
03 - The cropping is beautiful, and the text is perfect. The colouring is bright and vibrant without being overbearing and the simplicity is wonderful!
Unfortunately, we have to say goodbye to an iconmaker this week too:(
But congratulations to the winner!
Eliminated:
river_sunshine : -7
People's Choice:
dance_the_dance : +5
- Banner will come as soon as I have the time to make it!
[ voting tally]
01: +1+1+1+1+1= +5
02: -1-1+1-1= -2
03: +1+1+1+1= +4
04: -1-1-1-1-1-1-1= -7
Comments:
To eliminate:
02 - Evangeline's skin a bit too yellow and bad text placement.
02 - The text doesn't fit the icon.
02 - Far too light, and the text is hard to read. Also, it could use a little more contrast
04 - It's too much white on the face and the cropping looks pretty bad
04 - The icon is too lightened and too blurry, her hair has a blue shine as well which doesn't work appealing.
04 - The icon looks a bit too blurry, it is too light, and the crop is too centered.
04 - Didn't follow the Special Rule.
04 - The crop is quite plain and her cheeks have unnatural color
04 - The blue tint to her hair is strong and unflattering
04 - The colouring seems really too much - she looks like a puppet or something
To keep:
01 - Very nicely done
01 - Interesting crop and nice subtle coloration
01 - Beautiful b/w color, the text match perfectly and love the touch of color on the hair.
01 - I really like the text with the little text under it!
01 - Great use of text and tinytext. It really fits in.
02 - Nice, soft coloring and text
03 - Good cropping and coloring. Text placement is so good.
03 - The coloring is really beautiful! The cropping also is stunning, and brings out the beautiful curly hair. Just stunning!
03 - Lovely contrast & coloring.
03 - The cropping is beautiful, and the text is perfect. The colouring is bright and vibrant without being overbearing and the simplicity is wonderful!