Round 4, Challenge 1, Results
I have to say, I am a bit disappointed this week, we only got 5 votes, when we have 13 participants and 51 members! I would really appreciate it if you'd just take a minute and vote:) For the next result-post, only the people who have voted will be allowed to get their comments.
But thanks to the people that did votes of course!:)
Unfortunately, we have to say goodbye to two iconmakers this week too.
But congratulations to the winner!
Eliminated:
own_world : -6
xtine005 : -2
People's Choice & mod's choice:
imaginary_lives : +4
- Beautiful coloring and great cropping, as always!
[ voting tally]
01:-1-1-1-1-1-1= -6
02:-1+1= 0
03:+1+1+1+1= +4
04:-1= -1
07:+1+1= +2
09:-1-1= -2
12:+1= +1
13:+1+1-1= +1
(If your icon number is not listed, you recieved no votes).
Comments:
To eliminate:
01: The coloring is too purple and it doesn't fit with the icon
01: Undercontrast
01: The coloring is too blue
01: The icon is too blue
01: The coloring is washed out and the croping a little boring
02: Everything is too centered and the picture seems like nearly not colored.
04: The icon is too over-sharpened
09: The icon is oversharpened
09: The background texture and the font used aren't pretty
13: Can't see the facial features
To keep:
02: I like the simplicity & the text suits the icon well
03: Awesome crop and coloring
03: Good coloring and use of the empty space
03: Like the composing and coloring
03: Lovely coloring and cropping, very simple but very pretty icon
07: Very natural-looking coloring
07: Simple but efficient
12: The colouring is beautiful
13: Like the back&white coloring and the use of the texture
13: Beautiful black-and-white coloring and the pinkish bar looks amazing
But thanks to the people that did votes of course!:)
Unfortunately, we have to say goodbye to two iconmakers this week too.
But congratulations to the winner!
Eliminated:
own_world : -6
xtine005 : -2
People's Choice & mod's choice:
imaginary_lives : +4
- Beautiful coloring and great cropping, as always!
[ voting tally]
01:-1-1-1-1-1-1= -6
02:-1+1= 0
03:+1+1+1+1= +4
04:-1= -1
07:+1+1= +2
09:-1-1= -2
12:+1= +1
13:+1+1-1= +1
(If your icon number is not listed, you recieved no votes).
Comments:
To eliminate:
01: The coloring is too purple and it doesn't fit with the icon
01: Undercontrast
01: The coloring is too blue
01: The icon is too blue
01: The coloring is washed out and the croping a little boring
02: Everything is too centered and the picture seems like nearly not colored.
04: The icon is too over-sharpened
09: The icon is oversharpened
09: The background texture and the font used aren't pretty
13: Can't see the facial features
To keep:
02: I like the simplicity & the text suits the icon well
03: Awesome crop and coloring
03: Good coloring and use of the empty space
03: Like the composing and coloring
03: Lovely coloring and cropping, very simple but very pretty icon
07: Very natural-looking coloring
07: Simple but efficient
12: The colouring is beautiful
13: Like the back&white coloring and the use of the texture
13: Beautiful black-and-white coloring and the pinkish bar looks amazing