Round 3, Challenge 8, Results
The votes are counted, thanks to all that voted:)
Unfortunately, we have to say goodbye to two iconmakers this week too, but stay tuned for the next round;)
And congratulations to the winner!
The new challenge will be up soon.
Eliminated:
amber_km: -8
imaginary_lives: -7
People's Choice:
arbuus: +5
[ voting tally]
1:-1-1-1-1-1-1-1= -7
2:-1+1-1-1-1+1= -2
3:+1+1-1+1-1= +1
4:+1+1+1+1+1+1= +6
5:-1-1-1+1-1= -3
6:-1-1-1-1-1-1-1+1-1-1= -8
Comments:
To eliminate:
01: Seems a bit overcontrasted, unexciting crop
01: The icon is too blurred
01: The awkward glow around her takes away from the icon
01: Icon is oversaturated
01: There's a weird grey glow around her that made looks bad the picture, but I love the yellow glow.
01: Evi looks weird, she scares me on that icon
01: Too sharp around her eyes, and the yellow is districting compared to the rest of the icon.
02: The icon is too blurred and a bit too dark.
02: The icon is blurry, could be a bit more contrasted and the brush is distract.
02: Icon looks too dark and blurry + the texture doesn't fit it.
02: The text at the bottom doesn't work well, and the image looks blurry.
03: Don't like the use of the text, the color can better but it has a good cropping.
03: The colouring does not compliment the icon.
05: A bit dark and tightly cropped
05: It looks too dark and the crop isn't good
05: Not only is the icon too busy, but it is a little less interesting than the others. There is nothing that really draws someone's attention to it.
05: The cropping gives the icon an unbalanced feeling.
06: Not enough contrast, and the pink dot in the bottom corner is attention grabbing, which throws off the balance.
06: Icon is oversharpened
06: Too bright and contrasted
06: The icon is a bit too sharp & undercontrasted
06: There are way too many conflicting elements in the icon
06: Lacks a little bit contrast; the red spot is distracting
06: She is way too pale and the quality of the icon is not the best a bit blurry and washed out
06: The coloring and the pink effect on the left side don't compliment the icon
06: The image quality has lessened and the image looks washed out because of the lack of contrast.
To keep:
02: The black area around Evi draws the attention to the main focus of the icon and draws out her eyes.
02: It is nice that the image is balck and white, it stands out
03: Awesome crop and coloring and the use of tinytext.
03: I like the crop & the coloring
03: Beautiful coloring and the brush is really well used!
04: Great text use
04: Nice use of texture
04: creative use of text and textures
04: I like the concept
04: I love the color and the use of the textures. the text totally fix and it's so perfect.
04: Lovely colouring and the text is brilliant as well.
05: Good cropping and colouring
06: The warm colors really compliment the image, and the light texture is well used.
Unfortunately, we have to say goodbye to two iconmakers this week too, but stay tuned for the next round;)
And congratulations to the winner!
The new challenge will be up soon.
Eliminated:
amber_km: -8
imaginary_lives: -7
People's Choice:
arbuus: +5
[ voting tally]
1:-1-1-1-1-1-1-1= -7
2:-1+1-1-1-1+1= -2
3:+1+1-1+1-1= +1
4:+1+1+1+1+1+1= +6
5:-1-1-1+1-1= -3
6:-1-1-1-1-1-1-1+1-1-1= -8
Comments:
To eliminate:
01: Seems a bit overcontrasted, unexciting crop
01: The icon is too blurred
01: The awkward glow around her takes away from the icon
01: Icon is oversaturated
01: There's a weird grey glow around her that made looks bad the picture, but I love the yellow glow.
01: Evi looks weird, she scares me on that icon
01: Too sharp around her eyes, and the yellow is districting compared to the rest of the icon.
02: The icon is too blurred and a bit too dark.
02: The icon is blurry, could be a bit more contrasted and the brush is distract.
02: Icon looks too dark and blurry + the texture doesn't fit it.
02: The text at the bottom doesn't work well, and the image looks blurry.
03: Don't like the use of the text, the color can better but it has a good cropping.
03: The colouring does not compliment the icon.
05: A bit dark and tightly cropped
05: It looks too dark and the crop isn't good
05: Not only is the icon too busy, but it is a little less interesting than the others. There is nothing that really draws someone's attention to it.
05: The cropping gives the icon an unbalanced feeling.
06: Not enough contrast, and the pink dot in the bottom corner is attention grabbing, which throws off the balance.
06: Icon is oversharpened
06: Too bright and contrasted
06: The icon is a bit too sharp & undercontrasted
06: There are way too many conflicting elements in the icon
06: Lacks a little bit contrast; the red spot is distracting
06: She is way too pale and the quality of the icon is not the best a bit blurry and washed out
06: The coloring and the pink effect on the left side don't compliment the icon
06: The image quality has lessened and the image looks washed out because of the lack of contrast.
To keep:
02: The black area around Evi draws the attention to the main focus of the icon and draws out her eyes.
02: It is nice that the image is balck and white, it stands out
03: Awesome crop and coloring and the use of tinytext.
03: I like the crop & the coloring
03: Beautiful coloring and the brush is really well used!
04: Great text use
04: Nice use of texture
04: creative use of text and textures
04: I like the concept
04: I love the color and the use of the textures. the text totally fix and it's so perfect.
04: Lovely colouring and the text is brilliant as well.
05: Good cropping and colouring
06: The warm colors really compliment the image, and the light texture is well used.