American Idol, top 9
BLAKE: I hate Mack the Knife. With the burning fire of a thousand suns. And as much as I love Blake, even he couldn't get me to listen to this whole thing without cringing throughout. He was in tune, I'll give him that. That's pretty much all I can give him, lol.
PHIL: The big notes were good. But I thought that most of the song was too slow. Where was the beat Tony told him to put in? I couldn't hear it.
MELINDA: I don't think anybody else (except maybe Lakisha) could've handled the complexity of this song as smoothly as Melinda did. I say it every week, but that's because it's always true. Pro. Star. Finale.
CHRIS: His voice isn't rich enough for this song. Still boring. Still want him gone.
JORDIN: Lovely tone, lovely girl, solid performance. Is there anything this girl can't do?
GINA: Very strong vocal, but it didn't seem like Gina to me. I miss my rocker girl, even as good as she was.
SANJAYA: He wants to prove to America that he can sing? Not with this vocal. *cries*
HALEY: Haley's trying too hard to be the sexy one now. She's losing the singing part of it. Blech.
LAKISHA: Excellent choice of song for her, though probably on the safe side. Great way to end the show. I'm just repeating myself on her every week, lol.
My Top 3 (in order): Lakisha, Melinda, Jordin
My Bottom 3 (in order): Sanjaya, Haley, Chris