Something that never stopped bothering me ever since I read OotP

Oct 04, 2005 00:22

The passage I'm referring to is the following ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 4

(The comment has been removed)

eruwen310780 October 4 2005, 01:05:26 UTC
I'm glad that I'm apparently not stupid (hey, if even the Ravenclaws don't know...) ;)

Maybe it's just Dumbledore being his weird self, and the fact that he's talking to serpents is just another Mark Evans? Hmm.. I don't know, but I for one wouldn't like it.

About the twins: my guess is as good as yours, I was thinking along the lines of futuretelling/divination. Far-fetched, obviously, since neither of them has ever shown affinity to that particular branch of magic...

Reply


lyssepoo October 11 2005, 11:43:37 UTC
I think she's trying to say that Dumblie is asking if Harry was the snake and if they were actually the two entities (sp?) at once. That's how I took it.

Reply

eruwen310780 October 12 2005, 03:23:33 UTC
yeah, but why is Harry then symbolised as a snake? JKR made it perfectly clear that the snake thing isn't one of Harry's innate abilities, but something that happened accidentally when Voldemort tried to kill him...

Reply

lyssepoo October 12 2005, 14:13:59 UTC
I figure he's not really symbolized as a snake... I think Dumbledore was simply asking if the snake and Harry were one and the same, and if they were of two minds or one.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up