Comments | elite_treehill: APPLICATION POST!

fixthepuzzle in elite_treehill

APPLICATION POST!

Jan 19, 2009 13:50

MAKE SURE YOU HAVE READ THE RULES.

( The Application )

applications

Comments 77

Bevin is cool!!!! velvetmidnightx February 10 2009, 20:38:58 UTC

Hey I'm Tara and I post my icons at my shared journal eternalfixation

( ... )

N glance18 February 10 2009, 21:55:34 UTC

Ugh this is my first time doing this. If I come off rude or mean it's not my intention, it's just constructive criticism.

Sorry but it's a no from me for now. There's a bit of overuse in the Hue/Saturation department. But I do really like some of your croppings and your use of text in the last one. :) So maybe just tone down the Hue/Saturation and maybe work on your coloring and texture use a little and re-apply in the future! :D

Re: N velvetmidnightx February 10 2009, 22:27:35 UTC

No you don't come off rude or mean at all, I really appreciate you taking the time to give me constructive criticism.
Thanks for the advice and I will try to do all that =)

N fixthepuzzle February 11 2009, 02:17:13 UTC

Sorry but I'm going to have to say no too, I really like some of your cropping and the style of icons like 4 and 10 but I think you need to tone down the hue/saturation and sometimes your reds over power your icons a bit. Definitley re-apply when you think you've improved!

Thread 5

Bevin is cool makry13 February 10 2009, 22:43:23 UTC

Name:Makry
I post at assezbelle
Yes to criticism

( ... )

Y glance18 February 10 2009, 23:10:40 UTC

You're totally getting a yes from me. :D The only thing I would say is maybe try out some different colorings for some variation and maybe using different texts, although finding the perfect text for each icon is a serious pain. But all and all I really like your icons!

Y fixthepuzzle February 11 2009, 02:20:06 UTC

Yes from me as well. I really love your cropping and use of textures, if anything watch out for washing your icons out a bit, like in 5 but otherwise I really lobe 1, 3, and 4. :) Check your invited in a sec.

Re: Y makry13 February 11 2009, 02:32:17 UTC

TY :D

I´ll check the invite, although LJ is being a pain in the ass with invites, cause I haven´t received one that was sent tp me days ago

lily_vanilla February 22 2009, 23:26:40 UTC

Hey I am Lea and post my icons in my personal LJ

Here's some of my art work:

( ... )

N glance18 February 24 2009, 06:24:30 UTC

Lots and lots of potential but at this point it's going to have to be a no. Maybe work on the colorings and you'll be good to go. ;) Although I do quite like the coloring in the 8th one. Be sure to re-apply in the future! :D

Re: N lily_vanilla February 24 2009, 11:19:00 UTC

what's wrong with the coloring? Can you be a little more specific?

Bevin. :) jai_23 March 1 2009, 19:29:28 UTC

I'm Jai and I post at my creative community, loveiscacophony. Constructive criticism is welcome. :)

( ... )

Y glance18 March 1 2009, 20:31:19 UTC

You're getting a total yes from me!

Re: Bevin. :) fixthepuzzle March 1 2009, 21:05:23 UTC

I really love your cropping but I would try to stay away from oversharpening. Sending you an invite now. :)

Re: Bevin. :) jai_23 March 1 2009, 21:09:17 UTC

Thank you! ♥

Bevin born_butterfly March 1 2009, 20:19:31 UTC

I'm Laura and I post at violet_clouds :)

Criticism is cool :) Haven't made a lot of OTH icons yet though :)

( ... )

Y glance18 March 1 2009, 20:29:08 UTC

You're definitely getting a yes from me. Pretty!

Y fixthepuzzle March 1 2009, 21:03:39 UTC

These are beautiful! Sending you an invite now. :)