Leave a comment

krasnoludek September 11 2010, 07:05:22 UTC
1) I agree with you that DADT being unconstitutional under the 1st amendment is more surprising than under the 5th. The NYT article listed two examples given by the prosecution to argue that the law was unjust. They were both examples where someone's private, hidden conversations were discovered against their will. It seems the only way they could have complied with the law was to never talk about these subjects with anyone, which then is a pretty heavy restriction of speech. And as the judge determined, the government didn't have a strong enough interest for security to restrict such speech.

3) I'm reasonably glad this pastor got his publicity, because it's mostly been negative. His fringe status became apparent by the collective shaming he got from round the spectrum and that hopefully made people with somewhat similar personal opinions reconsider the consequence of such intolerance.

4) I find it funny that the teabagger's twitter refers to her as "Gov. Palin" as if she still had a leadership position in government and wasn't just a celebrity now.

Reply

secret_panda September 11 2010, 12:26:29 UTC
Re (4): former governors (and presidents, senators, congresspeople, and doubtless many other positions) get the title "governor" even after they leave office. So, like, President Carter is still "President Carter" even though he's no longer president, and technically you probably could call our current Secretary of State "Senator Clinton," though that would be rather silly.

Reply

krasnoludek September 11 2010, 22:41:03 UTC
I had only really heard this in the context of presidents, and not lesser positions.

Reply

secret_panda September 12 2010, 03:42:41 UTC
I don't know where the line is, but she's definitely still Governor Palin. (And hopefully she won't augment that title anytime soon!)

Reply

easwaran September 12 2010, 04:41:08 UTC
I definitely hear about Governor Dean all the time. It's a bit weirder when I hear about "Senator so-and-so" if they're no longer senator. I'm not sure why that title seems weirder to me.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up