Oh, thanks for your comment (and sorry it took me so long to reply to it). I am glad you liked my review and could agree with most points. :-) Though it's sad you didn't like the ending at all. I mean, I wasn't fond of it in the beginning, either, but after giving it some serious thought, I can see what they (maybe) were trying to show and that's okay for me now. I've actually even started to like it. Maybe you'd be interested in goldvermilion87s thoughts on who actually won in the end. She basically agrees with my points, but examines the final scene in much more detail.
And yes, I totally loved reading all the fandom reactions and participating in the discussions! So much fun and as you said: excellent literary criticism and the most in-depth discussions I've had for some time!
I've actually wanted to do a review for every episode. However, I haven't managed to write one for the Hounds of Baskerville yet... One, my holidays are over and I have less time for livejournal (such a sad world ^^) and second, while I enjoyed the episode it was much more straight-forward and less controversial than the last. I've only seen it once and I can't some up with any detailed analysis. But that may change upon a re-watch. ;-) So maybe there is hope for a review on the weekend. And then there'll be Reichenbach - are you scared already as well??
And yes, I totally loved reading all the fandom reactions and participating in the discussions! So much fun and as you said: excellent literary criticism and the most in-depth discussions I've had for some time!
I've actually wanted to do a review for every episode. However, I haven't managed to write one for the Hounds of Baskerville yet... One, my holidays are over and I have less time for livejournal (such a sad world ^^) and second, while I enjoyed the episode it was much more straight-forward and less controversial than the last. I've only seen it once and I can't some up with any detailed analysis. But that may change upon a re-watch. ;-) So maybe there is hope for a review on the weekend. And then there'll be Reichenbach - are you scared already as well??
Reply
Leave a comment