CAGE MATCH WOOO

[_thirty2flavors]

SO here is the final cage match poll, based on the winners for the cage match polls for each season & the specials.

Poll Most of these were pretty clear-cut, except s3 which was one vote away from being a 3-way tie (runners-up being Human Nature/Family of Blood and Blink). S5 was probably the biggest margin, with Vincent & The Doctor winning by an

Comments

[_thirty2flavors]

Midnight is great too. I think the s4 poll gave me the hardest time picking an absolute favourite, though I went for Turn Left in the end.

[_thirty2flavors]

Midnight is probably the spookiest episode IMO. I remember just being delightfully creeped out the whole time.

[kilodalton]

Midnight is probably the spookiest episode IMO. I remember just being delightfully creeped out the whole time.

YOU KEEP SAYING EXACTLY WHAT I'M THINKING!!!! XD

[_thirty2flavors]

Midnight is great. I like that it's sort of RTD-does-a-Moffat-episode, but you can still see the difference in their signature styles -- RTD's horror is very much based on the human element more than the supernatural. And that's what makes it creepy; I'm not worried about statues moving when I'm not looking, but humans doing horrible things or turning on each other/being selfish in a crisis situation is a very real thing.

[cassandra_elise]

I love Midnight, too. That's probably my favorite of series four, and it's definitely on my top ten list. But so is Turn Left. <3