Comments | dw_cosplay: Rose Boomtown Scarves

themarchingoboe in dw_cosplay

Rose Boomtown Scarves

Nov 04, 2011 14:19

So I've been lurking in this community for a while now. I have been planning a Boomtown outfit for a while now and was planning to knit my own scarf. But! You guys are awesome and you've pointed out an alternate scarf from Forever 21 (the post is here: http://dw-cosplay.livejournal.com/1056126.html#cutid1). So I went to go look at the scarf in ( Read more... )

companion: rose tyler, scarf, episode: boom town

Comments 10

acciochocolate November 4 2011, 21:27:38 UTC

Thanks for the info and the pics! I have the scarf from Target from years ago that was posted about way back in the early days of the comm, but I may have to check these out. :)

helping_capn_j November 4 2011, 22:29:41 UTC

I have the first one and it sheds over my wool coat like mad. I might go out and get the second one. I like the knit on it so much more.

stars_fell November 4 2011, 23:31:21 UTC

I'm not a Rose expert by any means, but I have to say that I like the colors on the second scarf better as well.

beagleinspace November 4 2011, 23:43:07 UTC

The second one looks like a spot on replica of the FP Fairytale Forest scarf!

(The comment has been removed)

beagleinspace November 7 2011, 02:25:57 UTC

I'm in the same boat, but when I think of how much I've worn it, it's not that bad.

Although, because the F21 version is so much cheaper and width-wise is close to the original, I kinda want to get two and attempt to combine them to make a super long version.

ravenmist7 November 5 2011, 02:24:01 UTC

I have the 2nd scarf and it is wonderful! It's my new favorite scarf. I originally had the 1st one in hand, but changed my mind when I saw how vibrant the colors on the 2nd one were and swapped them. I'm so glad I did.

themarchingoboe November 5 2011, 02:55:36 UTC

That's exactly what I did, too. :D