Round One - Challenge Fourteen: Results
Congratulations on making it to the Final 4!
Prompt.
Voting.
ELIMINATED:
by benelie
# 1 [ -6 + 0 ] = -6
# 7 [ -6 + 0 ] = -6
for a Total of -12
VOTER'S CHOICE:
by hobbitofkobol
# 08 [ -01 + 08 ] = 07
MOD'S CHOICE:
by bananacosmic
# 04
Great coloring. Very intense.
POINTS
# 01 [ -06 + 00 ] = -06
# 02 [ -04 + 02 ] = -02
# 03 [ 00 + 05 ] = 05
# 04 [ 00 + 01 ] = 01 Moderator's Choice
# 05 [ -01 + 03 ] = 02
# 06 [ -02 + 00 ] = -02
# 07 [ -06 + 00 ] = -06
# 08 [ -01 + 08 ] = 07 Voter's Choice
ICON PAIRS ADDED
# 1 [ -6 + 0 ] = -6
# 7 [ -6 + 0 ] = -6
Total: -12 Eliminated
# 4 [ 0 + 1 ] = 1
# 6 [ -2 + 0 ] = -2
Total: -1 Final Three
# 2 [ -4 + 2 ] = -2
# 5 [ -1 + 3 ] = 2
Total: 0 Final Three
# 3 [ 0 + 5 ] = 5
# 8 [ -1 + 8 ] = 7
Total: 12 Final Three
In the round worst votes received -1 points, and favorite votes received +1. Also reasons were not given on some votes as allowed per the revised voting rules this challenge.
WORST VOTE COMMENTS
#01 - I can't read the text and it's really distracting.
#01 - The coloring is too bland.
#01 - Some light colouring in the texture would have looked nicer - and the font choice seems to playful for the subject.
#01 - the text placement is unflattering, a bit too dark and could use some colour
#02 - the font + font colour and placement are extremely unflattering
#02 - Echo is a little blurry.
#02 - the cutting around Echo's hair is strange and the font is not the most perfect.
#05 - The picture is too small and the black and white seems to obscure it.
#06 - The icon is a bit too dark but the idea is good
#06 - The texture doesn't really fit well with the image and with the expression on her face. It just looks too dull and grungy.
#07 - the blending of the two images looks weird
#07 - The blend looks strange, like Echo is somehow coming out of Boyd.
#07 - I think this would have looked better with a harsher outline in the blending - the softness looks too organic for the amount of action in the icon. The contrasts on Boyd's shirt are awesome, though.
#07 - The blending doesn't flow well and it is a little akward looking.
#07 - The blending could use some work and the coloring looks too washed out and dull.
FAVORITE VOTE COMMENTS
#02 - The texture and picture and text all fit together really well.
#03 - Great text, great, cutout, love the texture
#03 - Nice composition and background choice.
#03 - font fits, great composition
#04 - Nicely cropped and colored.
#05 - Great composition.
#06 - very original and it really looks like she's coming out of the frame!
#08 - nice use of texture and text.
#08 - Terrific use of texture and text.
#08 - This icon is just put together very nicely!
#08 - Nice use of colors, text and cut.
#08 - Nice composition. Just a bit too sharpen
#08 - amazingly cool font use, colouring and composition
MOD NOTE:
Congratulations to everyone who participated in this round! The next challenge will be up shortly.
{comments are not screened. | to leave a screened comment for the mods please go to the contact us post.}
Prompt.
Voting.
ELIMINATED:
by benelie
# 1 [ -6 + 0 ] = -6
# 7 [ -6 + 0 ] = -6
for a Total of -12
VOTER'S CHOICE:
by hobbitofkobol
# 08 [ -01 + 08 ] = 07
MOD'S CHOICE:
by bananacosmic
# 04
Great coloring. Very intense.
POINTS
# 01 [ -06 + 00 ] = -06
# 02 [ -04 + 02 ] = -02
# 03 [ 00 + 05 ] = 05
# 04 [ 00 + 01 ] = 01 Moderator's Choice
# 05 [ -01 + 03 ] = 02
# 06 [ -02 + 00 ] = -02
# 07 [ -06 + 00 ] = -06
# 08 [ -01 + 08 ] = 07 Voter's Choice
ICON PAIRS ADDED
# 1 [ -6 + 0 ] = -6
# 7 [ -6 + 0 ] = -6
Total: -12 Eliminated
# 4 [ 0 + 1 ] = 1
# 6 [ -2 + 0 ] = -2
Total: -1 Final Three
# 2 [ -4 + 2 ] = -2
# 5 [ -1 + 3 ] = 2
Total: 0 Final Three
# 3 [ 0 + 5 ] = 5
# 8 [ -1 + 8 ] = 7
Total: 12 Final Three
In the round worst votes received -1 points, and favorite votes received +1. Also reasons were not given on some votes as allowed per the revised voting rules this challenge.
WORST VOTE COMMENTS
#01 - I can't read the text and it's really distracting.
#01 - The coloring is too bland.
#01 - Some light colouring in the texture would have looked nicer - and the font choice seems to playful for the subject.
#01 - the text placement is unflattering, a bit too dark and could use some colour
#02 - the font + font colour and placement are extremely unflattering
#02 - Echo is a little blurry.
#02 - the cutting around Echo's hair is strange and the font is not the most perfect.
#05 - The picture is too small and the black and white seems to obscure it.
#06 - The icon is a bit too dark but the idea is good
#06 - The texture doesn't really fit well with the image and with the expression on her face. It just looks too dull and grungy.
#07 - the blending of the two images looks weird
#07 - The blend looks strange, like Echo is somehow coming out of Boyd.
#07 - I think this would have looked better with a harsher outline in the blending - the softness looks too organic for the amount of action in the icon. The contrasts on Boyd's shirt are awesome, though.
#07 - The blending doesn't flow well and it is a little akward looking.
#07 - The blending could use some work and the coloring looks too washed out and dull.
FAVORITE VOTE COMMENTS
#02 - The texture and picture and text all fit together really well.
#03 - Great text, great, cutout, love the texture
#03 - Nice composition and background choice.
#03 - font fits, great composition
#04 - Nicely cropped and colored.
#05 - Great composition.
#06 - very original and it really looks like she's coming out of the frame!
#08 - nice use of texture and text.
#08 - Terrific use of texture and text.
#08 - This icon is just put together very nicely!
#08 - Nice use of colors, text and cut.
#08 - Nice composition. Just a bit too sharpen
#08 - amazingly cool font use, colouring and composition
MOD NOTE:
Congratulations to everyone who participated in this round! The next challenge will be up shortly.
{comments are not screened. | to leave a screened comment for the mods please go to the contact us post.}