The Girl Who Waited: Official review post *spoilers*

Sep 10, 2011 22:50

If you'd like to share your review of The Girl Who Waited, please post a link to your journal n the comments.

Don't forget to make the entry public so people can see it!

Obviously, the reviews contain spoilers, so not wise to read if you haven't seen this episode yet...

reviews, spoilers, the girl who waited, initial reactions

Leave a comment

meegat September 11 2011, 23:13:29 UTC
Loved it to bits - and my review has a little defence of the Doctor's actions (which seem to have upset a person or two...)

http://who-natic.blogspot.com/2011/09/review-girl-who-waited.html

Reply

eaweek September 12 2011, 00:15:33 UTC
Amazing review. I agree with every word.

Reply

meegat September 12 2011, 06:52:51 UTC
Thank you!

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

meegat September 12 2011, 13:27:06 UTC
Thanks - and I love Terry Pratchett - especially the Witches.

I think it was definitely something that Rory had to face himself - a choice HE had to make.

The Doctor is very self-loathing - but maybe also there was a bit of an attempt to make Rory and Amy understand that these are the kind of decisions the Doctor faces all the time.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up