Rumble II - Final results!
SETS
1st place
cool_spectrum
You get +6 points
2nd place
adriftingsea
You get +4 points
3rd place
erinm_4600
You get +3 points
Mod's Choice
kirtash_girl
I like both icons, and they complement each other very well! I also like how you repeated the silhouette in the background. Great composition!
You get +2 points
ICONS
1st place
adriftingsea
You get +6 points
2nd place
cool_spectrum
You get +4 points
3rd place (Tie)
&
ccol_spectrum & luminousdaze
You both get +3 points
Mod's Choice
luminousdaze
Great use of texture and colouring!
You get +2 points
Tallies
1st place votes give you +3, 2nd place +2, 3rd place +1.
To ask to view your comments, simply reply to this post with your letter, which you can get here.
Set
Comments received ?
Tally & Total
A
Yes
Set
Icon 1
Icon 2
1+1 = 2
3
0
B
Yes
Set
Icon 3
Icon 4
3+3+2+1+1+1 = 11
3+3+2+2+1+1 = 12
0
C
Yes
Set
Icon 5
Icon 6
3+2+1+1 = 7
1
3+2+1 = 6
D
Yes
Set
Icon 7
Icon 8
3+3+3+3+3+2+2 = 19
3+3+2 = 8
3+2+2 = 7
E
Yes
Set
Icon 9
Icon 10
2+2+2+2+1 = 9
1+1 = 2
1+1 = 2
F
Yes
Set
Icon 11
Icon 12
3
3+2+2 = 7
3+2 = 5
G
Yes
Set
Icon 13
Icon 14
2+1 = 3
1
0
Total
/
54
54
And on to the final results...
1st place
cool_spectrum
2nd place
adriftingsea
3rd place
bobness1
Overall Mod's Choice
kirtash_girl
You can find all the detailed results on the Scoresheet.
Congrats and thanks to everyone who voted and participated. I hope you had fun! I certainly did.
I'd like to give special thanks to everyone who took the time to comment as well as vote. I know from experience that giving constructive criticism (even positive) is not the easiest thing to do. Yet, it's invaluable to an icon maker. So thanks so much, and thank you especially to neaptidea, who left a comment with every single vote!
Finally, I'd also like to acknowledge mayfrayn and emmatheslayer who voted even though they were not participating to the rumble. Thanks for your help!
Now, disney_hush will go back to normal for a little while, though I'd really like to do a colour-based long-term challenge (maybe even a turbo LIMS or Rumble?) in the near future! I guess it'll depend on how much time I have on my hands ^^;;;
Thanks again everyone, and congrats!