[ Round Two ] Challenge 01 | Results

[trickle]

Let me get things straight :/
I said I would be strict about voting and I'm not joking. Some of you didn't read the voting guidelines. I'm fine with notifying you guys if you need to elaborate more on your voting but not voting when I've said that all participants should vote to avoid disqualification just bothers me

Comments

[trickle]

LEAST QUALITY VOTES;

- The text choice does not support the icon well. It feels generic for Halloween's sake more than having to do with the icon. Maybe a different text choice, or even no text (it still looks quite creepy/Halloweenish, though I'm not sure if it would have passed the mod. ^^; It's not a terrible icon, just a lesser quality.
- The coloring is nice but that texture takes up about a good 30 percent of the icon, causing it lose focus on the subject of the icon, it could have been shift down a bit with the text resized.
- The icon is nice overall, with the red and yellow hues giving a very spooky feeling and fits into the Halloween theme, but the text compromises the icon by taking up a bit too much of the icon space, and the black is distracting while the white font doesn't seem to match the icon well. Perhaps lowering the opacity of the black bar would help it?
- The colors are overly saturated & the text looks a bit too small which makes it hard to read. I would suggest desaturating the icon to make the coloring a bit more subtle & natural aswell as making the text bigger or putting a more effective word =)

FAVOURITE ICON;
- Unique concept. The text (although a different font could've been used) and the image complement each other to execute the concept. The lightning adds to the concept and is a nice touch.

SPECIAL CATEGORY - BEST COLOURING
- You've really brought out the oranges in Greymon and the eerie look to the sky is great.