I am, currently, finally finishing up Episode 4 of Umineko. I knew the spoilers before, but I had never played the last part of it.
Shit. My mind is properly fucked. If only the things that piece-Battler sees are the truth in the first four arcs, and he saw piece-Beatrice, but the 18th person X does not exist, and no more than 17 humans exist on this island, then who the hell was he talking to? There are 17 people on that island. Does people included furniture? But hasn't Beatrice used the red to include Kanon, Shannon, and the rest as humans? So then who was the person who claimed to be Beatrice in the end of Episode 4? And why did everyone say Kinzo was there when he was already dead at the start of the game? Were all the adults in on it? Along with Kanon and Shannon? Is it all a giant conspiracy? Since no person would mistake Ushiromiya Kinzo by sight, who did they actually see? Was it Kinzo's corpse? And why would they all lie, especially Krauss and Kyrie to Jessica and Battler, and Shannon and Kanon as well to their loved ones?
And what the hell is Battler's sin that's causing everyone to be murdered again and again--
Screw it. Ryukishi07 is a horrible genius who I want to kill.