30 Day Book Meme - Days 17, 18, 19

Sep 15, 2010 21:08

Day 01 - Best book you read last year - I went back through the "book report" tag on this one, and am going to have to go with a fairly recent read, Mission of Honor by David Weber.  After 5 years of keeping us waiting for a mainline Honor Harrington book, he gave us one that rocked.  It wasn't 800 pages in hardcover, the technical stuff didn't go to insane extremes, he killed off major characters, and he made me cry a little.  The review is here, but it has SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS!  I picked it as the best book because it brought me roaring back into a series that I started considering dead (especially since it was almost 5 years since the last book).

Day 02 - A book that you’ve read more than 3 times  - So this question makes me wonder what kind of audience this thing is geared for, because there are LOTS of books I've read more than 3 times.

I'm going to go with a Christie triple feature: Murder on the Orient Express (Murder in the Calais Coach), Cards on the Table, and After the Funeral (Funerals are Fatal).  These three probably rank as my favorite mysteries featuring Poirot.

Orient Express/Calais Coach (I have copies under both titles) is just fun to watch.  I like the whole stuck-on-a-train aspect, and it's probably one of the few books where you actually root for the murderer(s).  It also has an excellent AND faithful movie adaptation, which makes it a little more accessible.  It makes an excellent book for when I don't want stress, I just want to enjoy the ride.

Cards on the Table features a race of sleuths vs. criminals.  It's fun to read, especially how the different detectives deal with the different criminals.  I don't play bridge, so that part of the book gets boring, but the rest is pretty good.  There is a Suchet adaptation, but it changes things slightly (for one, in the TV adaptation, it doesn't come down to last criminal alive, so helps the tension some) and I think it preserves the spirit of the book.

After the Funeral captures my imagination, although I'm not sure exactly why.  I think it has to do with the dysfunctional family angle, because I really enjoy those in my fiction.  It also has a Suchet adaptation that changes some aspects, but preserves the story's spirit.  It makes another good mental vacation.

Day 03 - Your favorite series - There are so many answers for this one, because I read quite a few series.

There's the Vorkosigan Saga by Lois McMaster Bujold, the Honor Harrington series by David Weber, the Nantucket series by SM Stirling, Star Wars (pre-switch to Del Rey), the various incarnations of Star Trek, LMB's Chalion series, the Discworld books, and Elizabeth Moon's Serrano series and Vatta's War series ...and that's just on the sci-fi/fantasy shelf.

Mysteries tend to run to series as well: the Gaslight Mysteries by Victoria Thompson, the Amelia Peabody series, Peter Wimsey, early Robert Tanenbaum Karp and Ciampi, Anne Perry's Thomas Pitt series, and The Cat Who... books.

Let's not even open the YA box.

For favorite series, however, I'm going to go with JD Robb (Nora Roberts) and the "In Death" series.  Yes, it's like popcorn or candy for your brain.  I enjoy the range, and I love her characterizations because she does NOT overdo the characters with too many walkons, or give us the LKH treatment of page-long descriptions.  Some of them are better than others in quality and plot, and despite the series having a sort of futuristic facade (set in 2060s, with stuff like hovercars), the one that was actual sci-fi is probably my least favorite of the group.  They're an instant buy-in-hardcover, because she's never let me down yet.  I love Eve, even though in real life I'm probably more like Peabody.  :)  Yes, Roarke is pure wish fulfillment, but if you're going to dream, might as well go for the really satisfying ones.

Day 04 - Favorite book of your favorite series - So, having admitted how much I love the "In Death" series (so maybe I'm not a serious-all-the-time reader, your point?), let me share my favorite book with you.  There's several good contenders, but I'd have to go with Visions in Death, which is near the midpoint of the series currently.  It's the one where the psychic uses her connection with a serial killer to try covering up her own murder of a rival (in her eyes at least)... and for those of us enjoying the series continuity, it's the one where Ian McNabb finally finds out that Delia Peabody (girlfriend and about-to-be cohabitation partner) never did sleep with Charles Monroe, the sexy licensed companion (sex work is legal and regulated in Eve Dallas's world).  Overall, it has one of the better plots, and some of the better dialogue.  Runners up would include Witness in Death, where the killer commits the murder during a production of Witness for the Prosecution with Eve in the audience, and the short story "Haunted in Death", where Eve wraps up an eighty-five year old murder and a much newer one, with a few brushes with the spirit world.

Day 05 - A book that makes you happy - This one is actually pretty easy.  I love to pick up and reread Barbara Metzger's Saved by Scandal.  It's a Regency, and was my introduction to Metzger's writing, which is IMO some of the funniest in the Regency genre.  It's a book to pick up when you need to read about someone being in a way worse situation than you.  Plus, smart wealthy handsome heir to a dukedom with artistic talents - sign me up!  It never fails to make me laugh and feel better.

Day 06 - A book that makes you sad - I thought about this one on the way home, and the problem is that lots of books have PARTS that make me sad.  I also actively avoid books that are going to make me sad, because there's enough real bad stuff in the world without adding the fictional.

I ended up picking The First Four Years, the last of the original Little House set.  It just depresses me.  I know the story was based on Laura's reality, but I just hate to think that all the good in These Happy Golden Years is followed by all the financial problems, health problems, inability to have more than one living child... It just makes me sad.  So for me, they stop at These Happy Golden Years.

Day 07 - Most underrated book - I don't really pay attention to how people "rate" books, so this question was kind of hard.  I read a lot of "genre" stuff (romance, mystery, sf/f) and it's hard not to notice the hate a lot of people have for genre stuff.  Just because something isn't critically acclaimed doesn't mean it isn't worth reading.  What's important is that you enjoy reading it.

Day 08 - Most overrated book - I'm going to go with the Twilight saga.  I read the first one while I was in Iraq, just to see what all the buzz was about.  It wasn't the best book I'd ever read,  but I didn't feel outraged that trees died to produce it.  I got fifty or so pages into the second one and stopped, because I did feel outraged that trees died to produce it.  Also, having seen the movie, I do NOT understand why we're supposed to think that Edward is sexy.  The guy who plays Jacob is, but I feel mildly pervy thinking about it.  Basically, I felt like I didn't care if the whole town of Falls fell into a gaping chasm (lava optional).  However, to those that enjoyed it, see Day 7.

Day 09 - A book you thought you wouldn’t like but ended up loving - I don't usually pick up books I don't think I'll enjoy, unless they're for a class.  I'd have to go with Dickens here and A Tale of Two Cities.  I didn't have high hopes for TOTC after being forced to read Great Expectations and Oliver Twist, but I loved it.  It has adventure, romance, tragedy, action, and Mme Defarge.  It also has an awesome movie adaptation.  Ronald Colman plays Sydyney Carton in one of his best roles, Basil Rathbone is evil and class-conscious, and Mme Defarge is awesome.  Not to mention the fight between her and Miss Pross.  Maybe Dickens got paid by the word, but surely everyone who has written a paper can sympathize with the need to make word count.

Day 10 - Favorite classic book - For Christmas 1990, after my grandmother's death at Thanksgiving, I recieved a set of 8 books that would really open some doors for me in the world of reading.  She had picked out our Christmas gifts, possibly because she knew she would not be in the world on Christmas morning.  Then, of course, it was too raw for me to even take the books out of the cardboard box they were displayed in, so they went in my room.  I think it was about four months later when I finally felt able to try the books.  I picked up the first one, and stayed awake all night to read it (hiding out in my closet so my parents wouldn't see the light), with the other seven following in very short order.

That is how I was introduced to Anne Shirley, a character I had an almost instant connection with.  A character who had a temper, who forgot to do stuff because she got too busy daydreaming, a character who wasn't too afraid of seeming silly or daydreamy.  My favorite isn't actually Anne of Green Gables, but a toss between Anne of the Island and Anne of Windy Poplars, which I usually just read back to back anyway, because I love them.

Day 11 - A book you hated - Oliver Twist.  If I never hear "Please sir, I'd like some more" again, it would be too soon.  We had to read it for AP English, and ever since I have hated it with a burning passion.  To me, this book is one of the reasons people hate Dickens.  And English class.  (Well, that and Great Expectations.)

Day 12 - A book you used to love but don’t anymore - It's more like a series - Laurell K. Hamilton's Anita Blake series.  I read Guilty Pleasures back in 2000, when I had my wisdom teeth out and was up all night anyway, and really enjoyed the books until the series went to hell, or rather to the Unsexy Porn Shop.  Anita used to be cool (not likable, but cool), and now she's just stupid, and the supposedly feminist aspects of the character are insulting, IMO, to actual real-life feminists.  The badness that is now the series even contaminates earlier books, because now you know where the road is going and it's not pretty. The books have gone from having plot with porn to porn porn porn - and LKH's "sexy writing" is really NOT sexy. There's a few pitstops along the way, although a big one is Narcissus in Chains with the possible-rape scene (the scene has changes from original hardcover to paperback, but it's still disturbing) with Micah (not to mention, using soap for lubrication purposes is SOOOO NOT A GOOD IDEA) and the downward cycle that follows.  There's even a LJ comm dedicated to the subject - lkh_lashouts.

The question has come up as to what would make those of us who have abandoned the series (at least, abdandoned paying for it) read again, and generally the answer is this: Anita realizes that she's been used, and starts shooting.

Day 13 - Your favorite writer - These questions are not making it easier.  I'm having to go with a tie between Agatha Christie and Amanda Quick, with honorable mention for Peter David.

Dame Christie, because I enjoy mysteries, and I enjoy seeing what hat she's going to pull the rabbit out of.  That, and her mysteries aren't always the same from book to book.  I admit to being a fan of Poirot, even when everyone wants to strangle him (the reader included), and I enjoy Miss Marple now more than I did previously.  Some of her books don't have a "big name" investigator, including And Then There Were None and Crooked House.  She could write, and she's still fun to read now, and this is why her books have an entire shelf on the case dedicated to mystery.

Amanda Quick (yes, I know it's a pen name for Jayne Ann Krentz, but I don't enjoy her moderns as much) takes the place as my favorite romance writer.  I enjoy her historicals - I preferred the Regencies, but the Victorians/Arcane Society books are growing on me.  I like her heroines and the situations, even if having "modern" men makes them somewhat anachronistic.  I just really enjoy sinking into one of them for a good read, and waiting to see where we go next.

The honorable mention goes to Peter David, for his Star Trek work, because he's one of the writers who can make me cry and have me laughing five minutes later.  Some of the humor is very oriented to the subject, but he's good.

Day 14 - Favorite book of your favorite writer - Since I picked 3 authors, you get three answers!

Agatha Christie - I've already given Murder on the Orient Express and After The Funeral some love, so for this one, I have to go with Death on the Nile or And Then There Were None.  (You may be noticing my inability to pick just ONE!)  Nile is one of my favorites because it's got that closed-room case feel mixed with the obvious suspect being unable to have done it.  Colonel Race is also part of a fabulous cast of characters.  The 1978 movie adaptation with Peter Ustinov is excellent, also.  And Then There Were None is probably one of her best-known works, and it gets read over and over because it's good.  It's creepy and intense, and I prefer the book ending where everyone dies, because otherwise there is no puzzle for the authorities to solve.  It rocks, and I wish some would do a good English-language movie that follows the book.

Amanda Quick - My favorite of hers is currently The Perfect Poison, because the characters are good, the romance is better, and the plot is very nicely done.  It's so good, I own it in hardcover and paperback, AND audiobook format.  It just has something about it that makes me love it, although I can't quite put my finger on it.  I also like how she bounces back and forth between past and present in the Arcane Society timeline, and it's setup so the writer can always have a Better Idea.

Peter David - Q-Squared, hands down, is his best work.  I am prejudiced by being a Picard/Crusher fan, and this book playing heavily on that relationship but - it is awesome.  His knowledge for and love of Trek shows through in the book, and it has parts that just make you want to rip your heart out, along with parts where you just cannot stop laughing.  Some of the humor is dark, but sometimes you have to laugh or cry.  It's also got an excellent time-travel/multiverse hook, and when they get a little tangled up, it's pretty intense.  It brings together TOS and TNG, and I know the book has been out for like 12 years, just go read it.

Day 15 - Favorite male character - It's more like a top 11 list (I had hard time excluding anyone on it), but there are a lot of male characters I really enjoy - and not all of them fall into the Imaginary Boyfriend status.

#11 - Ramses Emerson (Amelia Peabody series) - What can I say?  He's smart, handsome, devoted to his wife, and he likes cats.  He loves his family, even when things get (okay, stay) crazy. He's also one of the few characters that's as much fun as a child as an adult.

#10 - Hercule Poirot (Agatha Christie) - I know there's a lot of people who don't like him, including his creator, but I love to read the books and watch him driving everyone crazy before he solves the mystery.  He's also a man of compassion, and he respects justice.

#9 - Peter Dobbs (Judy Bolton series) - He's a lawyer who cares more about justice than money, and he loves the woman he loves enough to let her be herself (and enough to wait for her to make up her mind).

#8 - (Chief) Inspector Hemingway (Georgette Heyer mysteries) - He's up there with Poirot on the driving people crazy factor, only he's also part of the police force.  He sees stuff others don't see, and he's pretty silver-tongued when he needs to be.

#7 - Archie Goodwin (Nero Wolfe series) - He's a great right-hand man for a detective who doesn't always have great people skills - and pretty down to earth.  Even better with Timothy Hutton playing him.

#6 - Gabriel Jones and Caleb Jones (Amanda Quick's Arcane Series) - They aren't your stereotypical Victorian men-about-town, but I wouldn't like them so much if they were.  Caleb wins over Gabriel by the slightest, since he actually RUNS the paranormal detective agency.

#5 - Delaney Brown (Nora Roberts, Savor the Moment) - If I ever wanted a guy to step out of the pages of a romance novel, this one is it.  We'll hear more about him on Day 20.  Also a lawyer with a sense of justice, even if he's not dealing with criminal matters.

#4 - Gilbert Blythe (honorable mentions to sons Jem and Walter) (Anne of Green Gables series) - He's likable, what can I say?  And one of the reasons my taste for tall, dark, handsome, and SMART was set so early in life.

#3 - Alistair McKeon (Honor Harrington series) - One of my favorite Weber characters, from the first to the last.  I might have given up Honor here and there, but I didn't give up on him until Weber killed him off (and played with us about it).  I especially enjoyed him in books 7 & 8, and still can't read the end of At All Costs without getting choked up.

#2 - Frank Hardy (Hardy Boys series) - The other reason my taste for tall, dark, handsome, and smart was settled so early.  He's smart, and a little geeky (especially in the 80s/90s) but he's always in charge and calm.  He has a taste for justice and solving mysteries, and a sense of humor.

#1 - Aral Vorkosigan (LMB's Vorkosigan saga) - Honestly, I could probably do a top 10 just of male characetrs from this series, because there are so many wonderful ones.  I can safely say that even though the series is technically about his son, I would never have kept reading without Aral.  He's a man of integrity and loyalty, no matter the cost for himself.  He's compelling, if not movie star handsome, and he gets the best speeches.  (honorable mentions to Ivan, Gregor, and Simon - if you read the series, you know who they are - if you haven't read the series, look up Cordelia's Honor and dive in!)

Day 16 - Favorite female character - Much like I couldn't just list one, I bring you a top 16 list - because female characters are awesome, and don't get enough love, IMO.

#16 - Cherry Ames (Cherry Ames series) - I prefer the Cherry-during-the-war stories, because after that, they were a little on the silly side sometimes.  Cherry is a nursing student when we meet her, and dabbles in detective work.  She's fearless and cheerful and not super goody-goody.  She's fun, and I like that the books have been reissued.

#15 - Charlotte (Charlotte's Web) - I know she's not a human female, but she gets stuff done.  And she's smart, and uses her words.

#14 - Elizabeth Shelby (Star Trek: New Frontier) - Peter David's brought her a long way from the two TNG episodes she appears in - he's given her humor, back story, and a willingness to go along with the crazy, because it just might work.  She gets to be authoritative without being considered a bitch.

#13 - Kristy Thomas and Mary Anne Spier (Baby-sitters' Club) - Yes, I'm serious.  I love the "best friends who are opposites" thing, and I like that the relationship between the two of them feels real.

#12 - Amelia Peabody Emerson (Amelia Peabody series) - I enjoy reading about her, although maybe I wouldn't want to be in her path when she's on a mission.  (Plus, every time I read the Nancy Drew/Hardy Boys novel that's set in Egypt, I wonder if she's the reason the tour guide is named Mrs. Peabody.  It gives me a giggle.)

#11 - Elizabeth Bennet and Fanny Price (Jane Austen) - These characters couldn't be less alike.  Yet they both make their respective books worth reading.

#10 - Ariadne Oliver and Jane Marple (Agatha Christie) - They each have their own style, but I like them.  Mrs. Oliver, a mystery novelist (sort of a self-insert of Christie) insists that if we had a woman at the Yard, crimes would get solved.  Miss Jane Marple of Mary St. Mead solves all her crimes through knowing human nature - and knitting.

#9 - Laura Ingalls Wilder, Caroline Quiner Ingalls (Little House) - When I was a kid, I really liked Laura, and identified with her (especially as I had dark hair, dark eyes, and vivid imagination).  As I get older, I find I like Caroline more and more - and admire the courage both characters show.  (They're also the only "real" characters to make the list)

#8 - Parker Brown (Nora Roberts, Savor The Moment) - She's the sister of Delaney in yesterday's question, and "her book" is coming out in November, so I am quite excited.  She's organized and cool under pressure, and she gets stuff done.

#7 - Jenny Chawleigh Lynton, Lydia Lynton, Kitty Charing, Ancilla Trent, Anthea Daracott (Georgette Heyer Regencies) - There's several wonderful female characters in the books, but these five are at the top of my list.  Jenny is from A Civil Contract, which isn't very romantic and dashing, but is touching and real.  Lydia is her young sister-in-law who consistently steals the scene.  Kitty is the heroine of Cotillion - she seizes hold of an opportunity to change her life, and she's smart enough to realize that she's found a better man than the one she had dreams about - and she helps out the people around her.  Ancilla Trent is a governess, and the heroine of The Nonesuch, in which it's nice to see the bluestocking get her man and the spoiled brat man-trap to get no one.  Anthea Darracott is one of the dysfunctional Darracotts in The Unknown Ajax, and deserves an award for not killing any of her relations.

#6 - Prudence Merryweather, Emily Faringdon, Lucinda Bromley, and Venetia Jones (Amanda Quick romances) - Prudence is one of my favorites because she's a peacemaker and problem solver, and drives a hard bargain.  Emily was really the first romance novel heroine who made me think that she was worth reading about - and I sympathized with her habit of withdrawing into fantasy to get away from the reality of her family.  Lucinda and Venetia belong to the Arcane Society novels (with Caleb and Gabriel from yesterday, respectively).  They get things done and keep me entertained.

#5 - Eve Dallas, Delia Peabody, Nadine Furst, Louise Dimatto, Mavis Freestone, and Charlotte Mira (JD Robb "In Death" series) - These are the core female members of the series, and I love them.  More importantly, I love the way they work together and play off each other, and everything does NOT have to revolve around men (unless they're a criminal).  They have work lives and personal lives and they act like real people.  Eve is prickly and pragmatic, Peabody soothes all the people Eve irritates, Nadine wants her next media accomplishment as much as she wants to breathe, Louise is the crusader, Mavis keeps an eye on everyone's mental health, and Dr. Mira provides the insight.  I can't wait to see what they're up to next.

#4 - Judy Bolton (Judy Bolton series) - She's considered to be more feminist than Nancy Drew, and she actually grows and changes.  I enjoy reading her, although I don't like the later books as much.  In one, she really impressed me when comparing her two suitors, noting that one wants to do things for her, and one wants to do things with her.  She's smart enough to pick the second one.  She also has a temper, and sometimes acts without thinking.  She's worth reading.

#3 - Anne Shirley Blythe (Anne of Green Gables) - I already talked at length about the Anne of Green Gables books, so let me just say: She's delightful.  She gets lost in daydreams, loses her temper, and never loses hope.  She also doesn't give up, and while she might be accused of having rose colored glasses, she really doesn't - at least, she knows when to take them off.

#2 - Cordelia Naismith Vorkosigan and Alys Vorpatril (LMB's Vorkosigan Saga) - I love Aral Vorkosigan, but I don't think he would be as interesting without Cordelia.  The two of them together make a formidable team, and they share a talent for cutting through to the heart of things, so to speak.  Alys handles all of the social things (which on Barrayar is much needed) and ensures everything is done Properly - or people suffer.

#1 - Nancy Drew (Nancy Drew series) - Yes, I am serious.  I love her, in her various incarnations.  She has provided me with many a break for a tired-out brain that can't take one more serious book.  From the original Nancy in the 1930s (yes, there are class/race issues in the books, but Original Nancy takes charge and has adventures) to the revised "yellow spine" Nancy Drew, in which the books were updated (i.e., let's get rid of the lazy Irish stereotype and bad dialect for anyone NOT white) in which she lost some of her moxie and got more correct, to the 80s and 90s, when she got back into action and flirted with Frank Hardy, to the newest update, which I'm not liking so much.  And yes, I write Nancy Drew fanfic, because she's fun to read about, and fun to play with.

Day 17 - Favorite quote from your favorite book - One of the most quotable authors I read is Lois McMaster Bujold.  There's so many pieces of truth in what she writes that they stick with you.  For quotes, it's hard to beat Barrayar, and it's my second favorite Vorkosigan book.  (The most favorite gets discussed on Day 30.)

"My home is not a place, sir.  It is a person...People" - Aral Vorkosigan

"Yes, Admiral Vorkosigan will certainly want to see that...Put it down as a Winterfair gift for Admiral Vorkosigan from his wife." - Lt. Koudelka, referring to Vordarian's head in a shopping bag

and, of course, the favorite one word quote from LMB - "Shopping."

Day 18 - A book that disappointed you - I had to flip back through my "book report" tag, but I decided to nominate Mr. and Mrs. Fitzwilliam Darcy - Two Shall Become One by Sharon Lathan.  My review of the book is here.

Now I know there are some people who think there are no good Pride and Prejudice sequels, but they don't all suck.  This one sucked.  It's bad.  I think this bit from my review sums it up:

Essentially, it’s Darcy and Elizabeth crackfic, that got published.  It was such a train wreck that I had to finish it, just to see what would happen, so I could share it with you.

Had I actually read the foreword of the book, I could have saved myself the trouble, because I would have read something that probably would have stopped me cold.  The author, you see, had never read Pride and Prejudice, until she saw the 2005 movie.  In short, she thinks the 2005 movie adaptation is the best.  I must, respectfully, disagree.  One actually did a good job of translating the book, using the dialogue, bringing Miss Austen’s work to life - and one just looked pretty.  (Also, one has dripping-wet Colin Firth as Mr. Darcy, and one does not.  I leave to you to decide the effect on quality.)

Let's put it this way - it was so bad, I was afraid to leave it on a shelf.

Day 19 - Favorite book turned into a movie - I've already mentioned the two Agatha Christie books that made really smashing movies (Murder on the Orient Express and Death on the Nile, for the curious), so on this one, I'm going to go with Pride and Prejudice.  The two BBC productions, the 1980 one with David Rintoul and the 1995 A&E production with Colin Firth, are both well worth watching, all I think the 1995 one wins by a little bit.


Day 20 - Favorite romance book
Day 21 - Favorite book from your childhood
Day 22 - Favorite book you own
Day 23 - A book you wanted to read for a long time but still haven’t
Day 24 - A book that you wish more people would’ve read
Day 25 - A character who you can relate to the most
Day 26 - A book that changed your opinion about something
Day 27 - The most surprising plot twist or ending
Day 28 - Favorite title
Day 29 - A book everyone hated but you liked
Day 30 - Your favorite book of all time

30 day book meme, memeage, reading, lmb

Previous post Next post
Up