CARSON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Before I'd even sniffed Sunday, I'd heard the rumours that Carson would be in Season 4. Then, when my friend texted me "Carson!", I knew it was true. Since then, I have waited and WAITED for his return.
As soon as I heard "Hoff", I knew this was the episode. You can't bring up the Hoffans without screaming "CARSON! IT'S ABOUT CARSON!". And then Michael's all 'I worked with someone' - and I was waiting for Carson to step out of the shadows!
Then, when they said they were holding an Atlantis person, I knew it had to be him. When they kicked down the first door, I waited. And then FINALLY they got to the second door! CARSON!
Really, I'm not going to be more coherent than that. I just wished I didn't have to get up early tomorrow, so I could watch the next two episodes. Oh well - will content myself with watching that last scene again and grinning madly.
ETA: So, what are our options?
1) Exploded!Carson was real; Prisoner!Carson is a duplicate/fake
2) Exploded!Carson was a duplicate/fake; Prisoner!Carson is real
For obvious reasons, I prefer option 2. However, if 2 is true, when was Carson replaced?
It makes more sense for 1 to be true and Prisoner!Carson to be a Replicator!Human.
Tenderhooks!