Reaction post!

Oct 13, 2010 19:26

Book reactions I promised, and one that I didn't promise but want to include anyway ( Read more... )

the demon's lexicon, i can't shut up!, bakurae, the queen's thief, yu-gi-oh!

Leave a comment

lacewood October 14 2010, 01:55:14 UTC
The plan is for the series to have 6 books, so the encroaching wars etc are probably on their way to being addressed eventually. XD Yeah, their very understated and yet nonetheless compelling - maybe because MWT doesn't try and hit you over the head with what she's trying to do, just touches on it and moves on. Or maybe there is just no defining HOW AWESOME she is. (So jealous)

The Medes appear to come from a VERY patriarchal society - I say this based on their REPEATED tendency to overlook and underestimate women. WELL GUYS, I GUESS YOU DIDN'T LEARN YOUR LESSON FROM ATTOLIA AND LOOK WHERE THAT'S GOTTEN YOU *ZING*

And oh man, yes, Annabel! ;______________; And seriously, you have to wonder at the magicians and their COMPLETE, repeated inability to consider that threatening/hurting someone's family that he CLEARLY cares a great deal about is not exactly the best persuasion tactic ever. My assumption is that this is a deliberate indication of how very deeply they simply can't CONCEIVE of valuing a life that doesn't belong to a magician, so they just believe that oh, Jamie will get over it once he comes ONE OF THEM. Which is just... man, guys, that's gonna bite you bitches good.

Reply

demoerin October 15 2010, 03:49:07 UTC
(repost for the correction of sad HTML failure)

The plan is for the series to have 6 books, so the encroaching wars etc are probably on their way to being addressed eventually.
Six! *JOY*

I say this based on their REPEATED tendency to overlook and underestimate women.
Then the Medes deserve NOTHING. It would be slightly better even if they said something along the lines of, "She is like a man in a woman's body!" and marked a big red exception around Attolia (and Eddis, she's no pushover either). Everything about Attolia screams DOES NOT MESS AROUND and they don't notice, repeatedly? Whatevs, Medes!

My assumption is that this is a deliberate indication of how very deeply they simply can't CONCEIVE of valuing a life that doesn't belong to a magician
A reasonable explanation! It didn't seem like there could be one, and I shall cling to it. The murder is still stupid but Gerald did prove beforehand that there's a big disconnect between the magicians and the rest of humanity - even Mae did to an extent, with how much she loves the feeling of magic. (But the disconnect being that big is still stupiiiiiiid--sorry, it seems I need more time to get over this.)

Reply

lacewood October 15 2010, 05:24:32 UTC
Yes! The worry is more how long she's going to take to write the following books. I think there was a 10 year gap between some of them, which is just D:

Yeah, seriously, why exactly did they think Attolia's entire court walks on tiptoes around her? I would tell you more about the Medes underestimating the ladies to their great and well deserved detriment, but that would be a spoiler for the 4th book. XD

I assume it's deliberate because the other magicians have displayed the same massive blind spot. See: Celeste, who seemed to see no issues with blatantly trying to KIDNAP Jamie. Oh no, why would he object to joining your circle when you've just told him you're not giving him a choice?!) Unless they're secretly engaging in massive arguments where the Muggles can't see - or they have a brainwashing machine hidden in the basement?!

Isn't Helen under Celeste's control rather than Gerald's? So at least he's not to blame for THAT especially terrible decision. I hope the third book touches on this because right now it's like a gaping abyss of LOGIC FAIL from villains who seem reasonably intelligent otherwise.

Reply

demoerin October 15 2010, 17:54:11 UTC
TEN YEARS... Hopefully she has now hit her stride?!

Yeah, seriously, why exactly did they think Attolia's entire court walks on tiptoes around her?
It really should be a hint. And even if Nahuseresh thinks that she's just mimicking what she was once taught by far more intelligent men, you'd think he'd STILL be careful of someone who was taught to dangle people from the city walls by their ankles.

Unless they're secretly engaging in massive arguments
Hee. One minute a united front, and the moment the Muggles are gone it's "WHO ENCHANTED MY PEANUT BUTTER? Oh yeah and killed my sister that time."

Oh yeah, true, Helen is Celeste's problem. I think I like blaming things on Gerald because I sort of hate him. He's a good villain that way.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up