For those who know Asimov and Alex Proyas

[delirium9]

Hello, there!

I received this mail because I belong to an Alex Proyas bulletin board. I will be e-mailing my opinion back to the guy, but I figured I could help him by posting his question elsewhere and getting other people's opinions. So, if you wish, answer here, and I'll forward your answers to him, 'k? Thanks!

~*~

Both myself and a class

Comments

[masterxmind]

I read most of Asimov's books and short stories, I also saw Dark City and The Crow, two of Proyas' movies. To be honest, I really don't associate Proyas' dark, brooding style with Asimov's stories, that aren't really like that. Maybe they relate more to M. Night Shyamalan's style (Signs) without being that obvious (the glasses of water throughout the whole movie).

What can he bring to I, Robot? I don't know. For what I've seen on the trailers, the script for the movie is completely different to the story. So I can't really relate Proyas to what I know of I, Robot. I hope Proyas makes a good movie in the smart sense, not just some pop-corn blockbuster that has no substance.

[judgement_today]

but remember, my dear hobbit, las movies no tienen que ser igual a los libros pa ser buenas... nene

[delirium9]

Pero igual, my darling FRODO, hay películas basadas en libros que son un asco. Es más, diría que TODAS, o el 99% al menos, lo son.

Carlos, gracias por ser el único en contestar algo coherente y serio :P

Muax.

[masterxmind]

de nada... lo posteaste en el bulletin board? quiero ver q responden a lo q dije... si es q no me ignoran jajaj

[delirium9]

No, en realidad se lo envié por mail, porque él me contactó por mail... Veremos qué dice...