Upon reflection, Voldemort’s grandiose and utterly unnecessary kidnapping/murder scheme in GoF wasn’t actually as stupid as we thought. We fans criticized: Why not have Barty/Moody just toss the kid a Portkey in class? (Or, if witnesses mattered, any time Barty might corner Harry alone in the halls
(
Read more... )
Reply
Reply
Another alternative would be to have Nagini eat a bit of Harry's body and send the rest of it back - maybe to disguise the knife-cut. Assuming Tom had sufficient control over her. Harry would look more heroic, thus making the 'conspirators' igor and Viktor look even worse.
Reply
Reply
I may have a possible explanation for this. Barty was only ostensibly teaching Harry to resist Imperius. In reality, he was testing his own ability to hold Harry under the curse.
The lesson on unforgivables took place before the triwizard tournament began. Perhaps the original plan had been for Barty to put Harry under Imperius in order to make him enter his own name into the goblet of fire.* But Barty wasn't sure if this plan would work, for Harry was known to be a powerful wizard and therefore potentially capable of resisting Imperius.
Indeed, after four tries, Barty concluded that he would not be able successfully use the Imperius curse on Harry Potter.
*Or he was planning to Imperius Harry at some other point during the tournament.
Reply
Leave a comment