AMC--Chapter Forty-Eight

Mar 30, 2006 10:37

I am posting a day early because Bobby and I are driving up north to Hershey tonight to see Stars on Ice, and I am off from work tomorrow. And I know myself. I will not wake up until ten (maybe eleven); Bobby and I will go out to lunch; we will find ways to distract ourselves for a couple of hours. By the time I find my way onto the computer, you ( Read more... )

amc

Leave a comment

digdigil April 3 2006, 11:24:43 UTC
Chapter 48 - AMC Comments

I love this chapter that is sort of a transition from the last one as Mae & Mac return from Alqualonde to Tirion. Mac is adorable, drooling on Mae and sloppily eating his bread & honey. Also, his costume ideas are so funny! I loved your descriptions of the costumes.

I love the paragraph about the New Year and the dancers. I love that you bring primitivism into the story to remind us that these are ancient times despite the Elves’ rather advanced civilization.

I love the family dynamics when they get home, and the undercurrent of trouble brewing between Feany & Nerds is a good portent of what is to come. And, of course, Turko & Carni are delightful, as always! “We suppose that the guest is a ‘he’!” LOL! That is so adorable!

I love the stuff about the Palantir! It’s so cool that you brought it into this story. It adds a nice degree of spookiness. And that Feany is talked about but not actually present in this chapter just adds to the spookiness.

I think on the seeing-stone. I am consumed by thoughts of the seeing-stone, pushing my food around my plate. I wonder what uncle Nolofinwë was saying; I wonder if I can see far enough to locate Annawendë. Or maybe she is here. Atar engrossed in work is akin to a horse in blinders, able to see only that on which he fixes his gaze. Macalaurë’s eyes are drooping, and he will likely retire early to bed. I will use the chance, I decide, to visit Vorondil.

Awww…I think it’s really sad that Nelyo would think of using the seeing-stone to try to find out about Annawendë. (But does this mean he has some of the same ‘Peeping-Tom’ qualities of his cousin Finrod? Hmmm?)

“I will,” I say, giving her a smile that will satisfy her, painting it onto my face with-I realize now-the same skill that Atar makes shapes out of stone and Macalaurë weaves song into the wind, into the mingled scents of flowers and trees, in perfect counterpoint to the rhythm of the rain, the laughter of a fountain, or lilting melodious birdsong. She sculpts statues and I sculpt myself, into the image of what she wants to see.

Awww…There is something so sad about Maitimo wishing only to be what other people want him to be. Sad? Tragically heartbreaking is what it is.

I have questions:

1. Are the chapters going to get increasingly sadder?
2. Will I need a hanky for the last one?
3. Is Findekáno going to be in the story again?
4. Is Nelyo going to see Annawendë ever again?
5. Is Fëanor going to get scarier?

P.S. At first I thought the 'guest' must be Rúmil, but on second reading I really thought that Turko and Carni probably heard Feany talking to the Palantir and just thought Feany had a guest! Is there a real guest?

Reply

dawn_felagund April 3 2006, 17:33:05 UTC
I love the paragraph about the New Year and the dancers. I love that you bring primitivism into the story to remind us that these are ancient times despite the Elves’ rather advanced civilization.

I think that they may have been more primitive once, when they first arrived at Cuivienen. And there were scary things happening, so they needed a way of coping (since the Valar weren't much help. *ahem*)

But working with the different Elven cultures in this story has been such a delight for me! I've only scratched the surface, I know, but I hope to do much, much more.

(But does this mean he has some of the same ‘Peeping-Tom’ qualities of his cousin Finrod? Hmmm?)

Only where Fingon is concerned. >:^D *evil cackle*

1. Are the chapters going to get increasingly sadder?

Well, there's only three chapters left. My "Maitimo conflict" was to have him slowly lose the poise and special regard he's always treasured. As to whether he gets it back in this story.... *mum* You know he gets it back eventually, but that's all I'm saying for now. ;)

2. Will I need a hanky for the last one?

*more mum* I don't want to spoil the ending....

3. Is Findekáno going to be in the story again?

He's in the last sentence of the epilogue, iirc. ;) And he's featured prominently in one of the upcoming chapters.

4. Is Nelyo going to see Annawendë ever again?

I'll never tell.... ;)

5. Is Fëanor going to get scarier?

At last, a straight answer: Yes. :)

P.S. At first I thought the 'guest' must be Rúmil, but on second reading I really thought that Turko and Carni probably heard Feany talking to the Palantir and just thought Feany had a guest! Is there a real guest?

Oh, a third theory! Well, of the (now three) theories that I've heard about the Mystery Guest, one is correct. And it is part of Tolkien's canon why the other is not correct.

That's all I'm saying. ;)
(the elusive) Dawn Felagund

Reply

digdigil April 3 2006, 18:14:35 UTC
Well, there's only three chapters left. My "Maitimo conflict" was to have him slowly lose the poise and special regard he's always treasured. As to whether he gets it back in this story.... *mum* You know he gets it back eventually, but that's all I'm saying for now. ;)

There is something very hott about disillusioned Maitimo. So very vulnerable. Mmm. You should know that Alina and I secretly have the hotts for him. Sorry, Alina, I couldn't keep my mouth shut. You could probably figure it out, though, from our fics about him, although we do try to hide it with other characters.

*more mum* I don't want to spoil the ending....

I can understand that but think you are evol just the same.

He's in the last sentence of the epilogue, iirc. ;) And he's featured prominently in one of the upcoming chapters.

Oh thank you, Dawn! You have made me very happy!

I'll never tell.... ;)

Unfair question, I know!

At last, a straight answer: Yes. :)

Ahh!! Yess!! Ooo! *rubs hands eagerly awaiting next chapters*

Oh, a third theory! Well, of the (now three) theories that I've heard about the Mystery Guest, one is correct. And it is part of Tolkien's canon why the other is not correct.

Hmmm!!! Very interesting! Must put brain to work guessing on this one!

Reply

dawn_felagund April 3 2006, 19:28:29 UTC
You should know that Alina and I secretly have the hotts for him.

*giggles* I don't mind! After all, I think that Feanor and Fingon are pretty hott too. Especially Fingon as you write him.... *wipes drool* Like in "The Speed of the End"...pretty pretty!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up