Recs within each fandom are alphabetical by author's username, with anonymous or mystery authors at the top. Also, I am forgoing the standard rating system in favor of my own highly subjective labels (gen, UST, pre-slash/OT3/het, not-porn/fade-to-black, barely-porn/mostly-plot, porn, kinky porn). If I ever rec anything with an unhappy ending or character death, there will also be a tissue warning.
The Big Bang Theory
Reunion, by
jujuberry136. (gen, crossover with Criminal Minds) Summary: Spencer’s in Pasadena and wants to catch up with an old…acquaintance.
Criminal Minds
Upward Over the Mountain, by
coffeecocktails. (Hotch/Reid, barely-porn) Summary: When Rossi realizes that Hotch is interested in Reid, he pretends to show interest in our favorite genius to make Hotch jealous enough to finally pursue the relationship.
Road Trip!, by
cydoniia. (gen) Summary: The team road-trips it. Twelve hours of living Hell.
& thanks to this artifice we manage to endure, by,
eudaimon. (Hotch/Prentiss/Reid, porn) Summary: It's only a bottle of wine; she has no idea how it ended up like this.
-- Sequel to the above,
to the measure of our own desires, by
eudaimon. (Hotch/Reid, porn) Summary: epistolary; they don't always talk.
5 times Spencer Reid didn't notice he was out of coffee, and one time he did, by
hardlyabird. (Morgan/Reid, not-porn) Summary: Just what the title says.
I Never, by
innerslytherin. (Morgan/Reid, pre-slash) Summary: When Morgan hosts a Christmas party for the team, he doesn't quite expect things to go the way they do.
I have no comment on the matter, by
jujuberry136. (gen) Summary: It’s all fun and games until somebody starts cheating at Klingon Boggle.
I'm not going to be ignored, Agent Sugar Lips!, by
jujuberry136. (gen, crossover with Psych) Summary: Juliet checked over her shoulder, “Seriously guys, you need to get out of here before Lassiter notices you’re here. I’m surprised you even showed up after Agent Rossi kicked you out of the briefing room on Monday.”
“We chose to leave,” Gus said primly, “Our investigative techniques can’t be pigeonholed by bureaucratic checklists, so there was no reason to stay.”
Reunion, by
jujuberry136. (gen, crossover with The Big Bang Theory) Summary: Spencer’s in Pasadena and wants to catch up with an old…acquaintance.
The Time Has Come to be Gone, by
jujuberry136. (gen, crossover with Supernatural) Summary: When Aaron Hotchner stepped into the interrogation room to interview one of the FBI’s most wanted unexpectedly apprehended earlier in the afternoon, he never thought the evening would end with bloodshed and rock references.
Pretty Boy, by
lagolindari. (Morgan/Reid, pre-slash) Summary: Morgan and Reid interrogate a pedophile. Reid is clever. Morgan is upset.
Every Inch is Black and Blue, by
poisontaster. (Hotch/Reid, slightly kinky not-porn) Summary: He wonders if he's ever been this adolescently infatuated with anyone.
Thicker Than Blood, by
rawumber. (Morgan/Reid, not-porn) Summary: Sometimes family reunions aren't under the best circumstances. Jossed by canon, but still a good read. Continued in
part 2 and
part 3.
All This Will Pass, by
recrudescence. (Hotch/Reid, porn) Summary: "Um, have you heard of public indecency, by any chance?" Reid asks with only partial facetiousness, a quivery smile playing over his mouth even as he’s pressing it gently to Aaron’s throat. "Because this seems awfully close to the line."
Lady in Red, by
severity-softly. (Hotch/Reid, porn) Summary: Reid goes undercover in drag to catch an unsub. Hotch appreciates the view.
Worthy of the Word, by
severity-softly. (Hotch/Reid, porn) Hotch and Reid get a push towards each other from an unexpected source, but often, it's easier to admit to what you want than it is to actually take it.
Make Your Own Luck, by
sperrywink. (Hotch/Morgan/Reid, porn) Summary: Morgan and Hotch both want Reid. Reid seems oblivious to either of them, so they decide on a wager. Whichever of them can get Reid in bed first wins. Only it turns out Reid knew about it from the beginning, and he has a better plan--to get all three of them in bed together.
Following a Bright Shiny Thing, by
travelinthedark. (Hotch/Reid, not-porn) Summary: Wherein Reid feels like a 6th grade girl, the girls squee from time to time, and there are little blue drinks.
NCIS
Agents and Hunters, by
sg2009fic. (gen, crossover with Supernatural) Summary: People who work in Abby's lab are never what they seem. Sam is no exception.
Psych
I'm not going to be ignored, Agent Sugar Lips!, by
jujuberry136. (gen, crossover with Criminal Minds) Summary: Juliet checked over her shoulder, “Seriously guys, you need to get out of here before Lassiter notices you’re here. I’m surprised you even showed up after Agent Rossi kicked you out of the briefing room on Monday.”
“We chose to leave,” Gus said primly, “Our investigative techniques can’t be pigeonholed by bureaucratic checklists, so there was no reason to stay.”
What Happens in Freedom Stays in Freedom, by Lenore. (Shawn/Lassiter, barely-porn) Summary: Carlton wheeled around to the Chief. "No. Absolutely not. O'Hara will back from Cancun on Monday. I can--"
"I really hope Jules brings me a sombrero," Spencer interjected. "I'm trying to cultivate a Juan Valdez kind of thing."
The Message is in the Medium, by
nixa-jane. (Shawn/Lassiter, not-porn) Summary: "I can't believe he solved the case on a post-it," Juliet said in awe.
The Dah-Ling Store-It-Yourself, by
nixa-jane. (Shawn/Lassiter, not-porn) Summary: The bad news is that one of Lassiter's highest profile arrests has just escaped from prison. The worse news is that his best hope of tracking him down is a sleep-deprived Shawn Spencer.
Supernatural
steal me from under my clothes, by
hardlyabird. (Anna/Dean/Castiel, porn) Summary: “He looks good like this, doesn’t he?” Anna asks Castiel.
The Time Has Come to be Gone, by
jujuberry136. (gen, crossover with Criminal Minds) Summary: When Aaron Hotchner stepped into the interrogation room to interview one of the FBI’s most wanted unexpectedly apprehended earlier in the afternoon, he never thought the evening would end with bloodshed and rock references.
Agents and Hunters, by
sg2009fic. (gen, crossover with NCIS) Summary: People who work in Abby's lab are never what they seem. Sam is no exception.
White Collar
Kink Meme, round 1. (all pairings, mostly porn)
Confidence Man, by
captanddeastar. (Peter/Neal, porn) Summary: the sex pollen cliche. “It’s some kind of aerosol aphrodisiac. He’s not in danger, per se, but we don’t know what the effects are, and he’s pretty miserable right now. So, Elizabeth, I really hate to ask this, but would you be willing to drive or fly to Buffalo so that you can… perform your conjugal duties?”
Silence reigns on the other end of the phone.
Finally, Elizabeth says, “Well, why can’t you do it?”
Devil in a Blue Dress, by
captanddeastar. (Peter/Neal, pre-slash) Summary: “You are not going undercover as a woman,” says Peter, firmly.
Just Like in the Movies, by
captanddeastar. (Peter/Neal, not-porn) Summary: Neal affects shock and hurt. “Ridiculous? Peter, that’s our love story, and every word of it is true!”
Pay Grade, by
captanddeastar. (Peter/Neal, pre-OT3) Summary: “Oh, don’t mind me,” Neal says. “I’m just basking in the irony over here.”
Two Hundred and Eight Weeks, by
elandrialore. (Neal/Peter/Elizabeth, porn) Summary: Peter likes to figure things out for himself.
Ground Floor, by
entropical87. (Neal/Peter/Elizabeth, pre-OT3) Summary: "Want to give him a show he'll never forget?" she asks when she hears Peter’s car pull into the driveway. A devious little smile tugs at the corners of her mouth. Followed by
Stem Game.
The Zombie Story, by Giglet. (Neal/Peter/Elizabeth, pre-OT3) Summary: In which Peter is a big damn action hero, Elizabeth pwns Brooklyn, and Neal ruins a pair of very nice Italian shoes.
Mastermind, by jmtorres. (Neal/Peter, gen-ish) Summary: "And the only crime I managed to nail you on was securities fraud? That's not winning, Neal."
A Sure Thing, by
lightgetsin. (Peter/Neal, scorchingly hot kinky porn) Summary: "Okay," Peter says, and there's a rasp in his voice. "Repeat after me: theft is not foreplay."
Figure It Out, by
lightgetsin. (Peter/Neal/Elizabeth, porn) Summary: "You, upstairs," El said to Neal. He beamed, twirled on one foot, and trotted out. "And you need to stop making it so fun to mess with you," she added to Peter.
She surprised a look of such melting fondness on his face as he looked after Neal that her breath caught. "No," he said quietly. "I really don't."
Kate, Short for Kevin, by
moonythestrals. (Neal/Peter/Elizabeth, UST) Summary: "I promise, El," Peter says, holding his hands up and speaking slowly and deliberately, "there's a very good explanation for this."
It's a good thing that Elizabeth is the person she is, or else she would not have the self-control to ask calmly, "And that reason is?" when she finds Neal Caffrey handcuffed naked to their bed.
Contractual Obligations: A Love Story in Three Traffic Lights, by
shaenie. (Neal/Peter/Elizabeth, pre-OT3) Summary: Neal huffs out something that's not quite laughter. "What could 'exemption situations' even be?" Followed by
part two (scorchingly hot porn).
Pet Convict, by
shea. (Neal/Peter/Elizabeth, porn) Summary: Peter likes smart. Doesn't mind bad either. He likes dark hair and big, blue eyes. So does Elizabeth.
Study of an Interior, by sinead. (Neal/Peter/Elizabeth, not-porn) Summary: El said, "Only you could have a genuinely altruistic motive for having a polyamorous relationship with your wife and a convicted felon." He cast her a skeptical glance, and she added dryly, "I didn't say it was your only motive."