When I'm Wrong, I'm Wrong.

Sep 13, 2010 18:04

Okay, before I explain, I have to ask you guys who write or read fanfiction something ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

gaffsie September 13 2010, 22:10:57 UTC
Short answer: Fuck them and the horse they rode in on.

It's only an AU if it explicably contradicts canon. If you write a season five fic where Rodney never gets together with Keller, it's an AU. If you write a post-season five where he breaks up with her, it's not.

Reply

eviinsanemonkey September 13 2010, 22:19:23 UTC
This is what I was trying to say! I should know better than to comment when I'm exhausted

(also, who is that in your icon?)

Reply

gaffsie September 13 2010, 22:23:19 UTC
It's Hawkeye Pierce from M*A*S*H.

Reply

eviinsanemonkey September 13 2010, 22:23:59 UTC
Thought so! :D

Reply

gaffsie September 13 2010, 22:26:51 UTC
He gives great face. :D I used to record the reruns of that show every night when I was a teenager. I was obsessed with it!

Reply

eviinsanemonkey September 13 2010, 22:27:53 UTC
He does! I used to watch the reruns on CBS til they stopped showing it, now I have the Season 1 DVDs and I watch it on TV Land when it's on at reasonable hours instead of 5:30 in the morning (aka 8-10 on Sundays xD)

Reply

gaffsie September 13 2010, 22:30:45 UTC
The reruns were on right before the National Anthem, around 3 AM, but sometimes they'd be delayed and the tape wouldn't catch the ending. That always put a crimp in my day.

I really should invest in the DVDs. That show is considered a classic for a reason.

Reply

eviinsanemonkey September 13 2010, 22:33:28 UTC
I almost got season 2, but it was in a broke case so I exchanged it for something else (Numb3rs season 1, actually...) but I intend to eventually get all the seasons. It's just so worth it. MASH and Hogan's Heroes are top on my list for DVDs to get.

Reply

equusentric September 13 2010, 22:20:32 UTC
*points up* What she said.

Reply

darsynia September 13 2010, 22:31:31 UTC
I agree. But in their mind, everyone lives in a state of hellish limbo where everything is exactly the same because it's not explicitly stated in canon.

I mean, if Jack/Sam being married is AU because it's not shown, what the fuck?! What if I write a fic 50 years in the future and someone who would have been 117 years old died? Is that AU?

I rarely use the word but this is asinine.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up