CFUW 119 - DAY FOUR

[cfuw_shepherd]

Comments

[rhymeswithgrim]

So four sheep, two wolves are left.

[marypoopins]

And Kida and Itachi were definitely sheep.

[rhymeswithgrim]

Then that doesn't make sense. Even assuming Robin and I were wolves and voted against Itachi and Kida for that reason, why would the rest of the wolves dog-pile on one of their own on the first night?

[rhymeswithgrim]

Unless the definite wolf of that clue was Hiroki. That leaves Anri and Ryoutarou as the wolves from our clue, effectively making my team and Labrador the safe sheep.

[tsundeargodwhy]

There was no dog pile the first night. The suspicion poll was a tie and the ousting was nearly a tie as well. Your team voted for the sheep.

[rhymeswithgrim]

You're Hiroki's partner, right?

[tsundeargodwhy]

That's correct.

[notmakingout]

And we still have no idea which clue one of the wolves is in.

[rhymeswithgrim]

That leaves Hiroki's team as being the only possible wolves if Itachi and Jubilee's teams weren't.

[notmakingout]

Or it could still have been Jubilee's and either you or Labrador. I still think the second oustin' was a lot more suspicious of a pileup than the first.

[rhymeswithgrim]

It's difficult to label Labrador and my team as "safe" without knowing if Jubilee and Belphegor were wolves or not.

At this point, the best choices left to vote against are Hiroki's team, my team, and Labrador. With the elimination of Itachi and Kida and my new theory that Anri and Ryoutarou were wolves, my vote would be on Hiroki, but obviously you're still open to suspecting me as a wolf instead.

[textbooktsun]

Would you mind explaining why you've switched from Labrador to Anri? I know now that Jubilee was the wolf.

[rhymeswithgrim]

We can't independelty verify Jubilee and Belphegor were the wolves. If Jubilee and Belphegor sheep, that leaves Anri and Ryoutarou as the wolves we did eliminate, and vice versa. This narrows down the best possible suspects to our team, your team, and Labrador.

[textbooktsun]

You're not answering my question. I agree that one of the three of us has to be a wolf - and from my point of view that means you or Labrador.

Mostly I'm curious why you're telling people you think Anri was the wolf, when it was Anri who got dog-piled rather than Jubilee who was only voted out at the last minute, and Labrador you were all over yesterday.

[notmakingout]

I think ya've done a lot more than a wolf usually would, but yeah, I still can't completely eliminate ya as a possibility, sorry.

[rhymeswithgrim]

No offense taken. We're one of the three best possible choices. That can't be helped.