Chocolate Box 2022 letter
Fandoms:
Malevolent
Bloodborne
Crossovers (Malevolent/Re-Animator, Malevolent/Seance)
Hi writer/artist, and thank you for creating for me! I'm opting in to fic and/or art and I'm up for anything.Please feel free to take inspiration from my prompts and likes as needed, but otherwise go nuts!
General
In general I like fics that are on the serious side. I like characters that are conflicted, romances that have to be worked for, settings that are scary or mysterious. Sadfics that range anywhere from bittersweet to soul-crushing are welcome. Action, adventure, thriller, horror, dark comedy, all good. Porn is also awesome. Art of any kind and non-standard formats (IF, epistolary, etc) is great.
I'm okay with a rating level anywhere from general to explicit, in terms of violence or sex.
Things I like
Here are some specific tropes I'm into in case you want to work them in:
-First times. Not just in reference to sex, but characters having revelations, doing things they've never done before, exploring sides of themselves they didn't want to admit, things of that nature. And yes first time sex, too, whether it's with a specific person or ever.
-Whump and hurt/comfort in all forms, I enjoy characters being pushed to their physical limits, injured, needing to be held or helped up by each other, especially if danger is still present.
-Horror, gore, psychological horror, body horror, cosmic horror, medical horror
-Canon divergence
-Characters glaring at each other (even the ones missing eyes).
-Characters exhaustedly leaning on each other, asleep or just resting
-Characters in rumbled clothing, partially undressed
Do Not Wants
-Underage.
Porn
I am always happy to receive porn! I like porn that is intense rather than sweet. I like complicated situations and when desire overrides inhibition. Here're some of my porn-specific likes:
-Dub-con and Non-con
-Breathplay
-Sex while still partially clothed
-Voyeurism
-Tentacles
-Xeno/demons/Eldritch abominations
-Bondage
-Mind control
-Anonymous sex, like one character blindfolded or in a mask
-Aphrodisiacs and sex pollen
Characters getting off on things they didn't think they would ever get off on is SUPER awesome.
Malevolent John/Arthur, John/Arthur/Hastur, Arthur/Peter
Listen to the podcast on Spotify
I'm a patron so I'm totally caught up and interested in a story told at any point in the canon.
John/Arthur:
I love Malevolent and everything about it. The slow build from distrust to trust between John and Arthur is a joy to listen to, and I love them just as much when they're bickering as when they're confiding in each other. I love that Arthur is stubborn and fierce but still has that traumatic, vulnerable side of him. I love that John is pushy and short-tempered, but also curious and insecure. I love that they're both trying to better themselves, and that they don't always click, but they try.
-Porn. Preferably either while they are still bodysharing, or if John is in some kind of monster form. Open to any scenario and including other characters/monsters. Fingersucking, breathplay, toys? Tentacles? Especially like top!Arthur taking back his control/taking some frustration out on John somehow, and John overwhelmed and loving it.
-Prison pit fic. Lay on that angst. What do they fight about? Do they have any gentler moments, times where they almost start to come together again, only to ruin it? Break my heart!
-Canon divergence. What if Arthur drank the Selenine? Dark World time? Does Arthur immediately regret it? Does he have to fight to get John back?
-What if John hadn't been a giant dick and they were still "friends" when the King launched his madness assault? Would things have happened any differently?
-They get to play the piano some more ;_;
Arthur/John/The King
The King is underrated, we have NOT seen enough of him! I love the ways in which he and John are similar, and also where they're different. The exasperation he must feel at seeing a part of himself DEBASED by this stinky little human. The desperation he has for Arthur's body, paired with his willingness to wreak havoc against it. He's so eager to get to Earth but we don't really know why, and we don't know how he feels about Arthur specifically being his current only option. Like, does he think Arthur is hot enough to be his host?
-Porn. King is tired of waiting and he tries to win Arthur over by fucking him silly. SO many orgasms. John can do nothing. If John's still mad at Arthur, does he start out feeling one way about it, but gradually gets more or less into it?
-King does get into Arthur's body, whether in Part 12 during the ritual or later. But John is still in there, too, and it's time for a slap fight.
-Conversely, it's time for King to fall for Arthur, too.
-Arthur said at one point that if he died, "YOU [king] would die too." We've been told that if Arthur dies, John will likely go back to the Dark World, but...what does that mean for Hastur? Is he somehow bound enough to John that he would get dragged down too? What if that happens and now they're ALL stuck?
-Conversely, Hastur gives up on Arthur and kicks him back to Earth, and shows up in his own human body to gloat. He doesn't know why, but he finds himself still obsessed with Arthur and John and continues to try to win them over alongside his cult.
-We don't get to hear any King talking to John - would love to see them interacting, King whispering in his ear specifically (however their ears work in whatever inhuman form they have). King telling John about all the terrible, filthy things they could do to Arthur together, and the ways in which John finds that tempting and repulsive.
Arthur/Peter
I love Peter, or at least, I love the idea of a concept that is Arthur's best friend who is now dead (lol). I've written about Peter but, and I 100% mean this, I don't care if you want to use or ignore my headcanons. We know almost nothing about this man and I'm open to everything.
-Porn. They're young, they're drunk, they're dumb. Or they're old, and drunk, and dumb. Peter submitting entirely to whatever Arthur wants because he's a pushover like that. Peter jealous when Arthur fucks around, and he tries to "win him back." Or maybe they just happen to end up fucking accidentally (blindfold orgy, glory hole etc) and their friendship is a little awkward after.
-Slightly less angstily, maybe Peter and Arthur have a very amicable friends with benefits situation, without feelings attached.
-Peter tenderly caring for Arthur after Faroe passes ;_;
-Casefic! What kind of adventures have they gone on together as investigators? Anything spooky?
-Peter didn't actually die AU, or was resurrected by some means, and he runs into Arthur later. How does he react to his best friend who murdered him, now host to an alien god? Can be Arthur/John/Peter.
-Arthur gets back to Earth, but without John. He's broken, maybe blind/lame without John, but Peter is still there somehow, and he takes care of him.
Bloodborne
Edgar/Micolash
My favorite Let's Play by Christopher Odd
Thanks to the Mico boss fight I have spent a lottttt of time in the Nightmare of Mensis, and it never gets less creepy. As much as I hate that brain, I love the tension it gives the area, knowing that at any moment something is going to stab into your skull and destroy your sanity. I'm really interested in how long Micolash has been its "host," and how Edgar got to be there. We know from lore he's a spy for the church, or at least started out that way. How did he infiltrate? Was his cover ever blown, was he converted to Micolash's cause? When the hunter encounters him, was he defending Micolash from us, or on his way to kill him? By the end, he and Micolash are the only "humans" left in the nightmare. Why are they special?
I'm open to any kind of shipping, whether Micolash wins Edgar over, exposes and torments him, or if one of them has a one-sided pining/obsession, or if they just want each other dead.
-Edgar trying to cope with being the only "sane" person among so many lunatics, his sanity slowing being chipped away as he struggles to complete his mission for the church.
-Edgar was there to kill Micolash for the Church, and the Hunter is late so this time he makes it to him. How does that confrontation go down? Sexily? Angsty "I must murder my lover"? Do they die together?
-Micolash discovers Edgar's identity and he and the other scholars torture him for information. Maybe they experiment on him to try and get him to birth a Great One (mpreg anyone??). Alternatively, Micolash doesn't let on that he knows and tries to trick/seduce Edgar into the fold by whatever ghastly means.
-An AU where Edgar successfully kidnaps Micolash and brings him back to the Choir. How does the Choir reward him, and what do they do with Micolash? Does Edgar regret this outcome, or does he prove the Choir is every bit as mad and cruel as the scholars?
-Sometime before Micolash became head of the scholars, he and Edgar were friends, enemies, lovers, etc. But Yharnam twisted them, like it does everything.
-I looooooooove fashionborne, any attention paid to their outfits is a plus (can Micolash give a blowjob from within the cage????)
Crossovers
John/Arthur & Herbert/Dan (Re-Animator)
So, John needs a body. Who better to go to than the Re-Animator himself? Arthur asking Herbert to build and revive a body for John to inhabit makes perfect sense and can not possibly go wrong. At all.
Would love to see any interaction between these two dysfunctional couples. Most awkward double date ever. I love the idea of Investigator!Arthur vs Scientist!Herbert, their skepticism of each other, the ways they might compliment each other. Or conversely, Arthur and Dan bonding over being tied to giant weirdos. Herbert giving Arthur his stink eye when he can't see it, but John can, and he hates this gremlin-man. Maybe Herbert doesn't believe that John exists at all until they find someway to prove it to him.
OR, maybe some AU where Herbert has been psychically bonded to Dan the way John is to Arthur.
-John/Arthur and Oliver (Séance)
You can listen to Séance on Spotify
Séance was a ton of fun, and ripe for a Malevolent crossover. Up for anything.
-Arthur goes to the séance earlier in his relationship with John when they're still actively trying to be separated. It works??
-It doesn't work, and in fact, Arthur is possessed by another spirit. John viciously defends his territory to kick the thing out.
-Oliver truly screws up and HE ends up bound to Arthur. Or, in a weird twist, John is expelled and pushed into him instead. Arthur has to face up to the realization that he doesn't want anyone else to have John and demands Oliver reverse the spell.
-Oliver keeps casting different spells on Arthur to try to get John out, but for whatever weird reason, the magic instead just makes him hornier/keeps giving him orgasms. Or alternates between him and John getting off on it. Thanks for trying, Ollie, let's try again next week!
-Whatever other fun you can get up to with Arthur tied to a chair.
That's it! Thank you for writing for me!!