Lets see, who agree's with austin's comments???? (This may make you furious)

Jun 08, 2004 13:44

LittleFishie827: traitor
AustinFalley: hah! u know that wicked had two amazing performances . . but Q had the goods without big stars
LittleFishie827: umm wicked had a HELL of a lot more then a few good preformances
AustinFalley: i'm just happy that idina won
LittleFishie827: and if it has stars or not means NOTHING
LittleFishie827: it means the show was better.....because it was
LittleFishie827: is*
AustinFalley: avenue q is a better written and has better music/lyrics and it was fresh and original
LittleFishie827: better written/
LittleFishie827: ?????????
LittleFishie827: the music is better the stevens?
LittleFishie827: and the book?
LittleFishie827: and the lighting....costumes...set?
AustinFalley: a lot! idina and kristin are better performers and the music is rocking . . .but wicked is just children of eden
LittleFishie827: not to mention....norbert leo butz joel grey idina and kristen
LittleFishie827: its not at all children of eden!!!
AustinFalley: norbert's character is paper thin . . .NO SUBSTANCE
AustinFalley: compare it man!
AustinFalley: Spark of Creation = Wizard and I
AustinFalley: Sentimental Man = Fathers Day
AustinFalley: For Good = Hardest Part of Love
AustinFalley: Generations = Thank Goodness
LittleFishie827: not really..
LittleFishie827: and those are both amazing scores
AustinFalley: Dancing Through Life = Lost in the Wilderness

(this is where i must comment that Lost in the Wilderness is NOTHING like Dancing Through Life. Um..lets see..Dancing Through Life is about 6 minutes long and tells the plot, and umm is sung by the whole chorus and MANY different solo parts..lost in the wilderness is one song solo...that doesn't involve the plot at all Enough said)

LittleFishie827: ohh not EVEn!!!!!!!!!
LittleFishie827: that is not a comparison
AustinFalley: but q deserved it . . . .it really did
LittleFishie827: not at allllll
AustinFalley: it was soooo fresh and original
AustinFalley: nothing like it!
LittleFishie827: okay...avenue Q is like a comedy show playing the same thing everynight
LittleFishie827: it will get old after a while
LittleFishie827: it was fresh and new
AustinFalley: so will wicked
LittleFishie827: NO IT WONT!
AustinFalley: Q WON'T EITHER!
LittleFishie827: the entire thing is breathdefying
LittleFishie827: is avenue Q?
LittleFishie827: not really
LittleFishie827: funny
LittleFishie827: thats it
AustinFalley: it actually tackled a lot of serious subjects with humor
AustinFalley: JUST LIKE SESAME ST!
LittleFishie827: yea....
LittleFishie827: and sesame st. didn't win a tony
AustinFalley: ever heard of the word "witty?"
LittleFishie827: yea...something just witty shouldn't win for best musical
AustinFalley: wicked was good . . . but it wasn't a great piece of theatre . . .critics teared it apart
AustinFalley: the only reason it is still open is b/c of idina and kristin
LittleFishie827: why was it not a great piece of theatre?
AustinFalley: most of the lyrics are shitty and sometimes are laughable . . .most of the melodies are very unoriginal

(HOLD THE FUCK UP!!!! Wicked's score is NOT unoriginal and the lyrics are NOT shitty. I would like to see someone else write a better score.)

AustinFalley: it has good sets and costumes and two great leading characters
AustinFalley: every other character is poorly developed and you really never understand what the wizard is standing for

(I'm sure that austin came up with that on his own..there's no way he read that on the internet...)

LittleFishie827: you are making fun of the music/
LittleFishie827: ?????????????????
AustinFalley: i love defying gravity/popular/wizard and i/for good
AustinFalley: but most of the other songs look like they were put together in five seconds
LittleFishie827: no good deed?
AustinFalley: "The Wickedest Witch there ever was the enemy of all of us here at Oz is dead" COME ON STEPHEN!!!
LittleFishie827: what?
LittleFishie827: you couldn't write that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AustinFalley: if you use circumvented in a song . . .you got trouble
AustinFalley: neither could most critics
AustinFalley: but it doesn't take talent to notice shitty lyrics

wow...this is the point where i left the conversation..i couldn't take it any longer....

PLEASE comment people...i know i can't be the only person furious at this...
Previous post Next post
Up