Challenge #5 - Round #1 - Results
I'm really sorry, but we have to say goodbye to this participants:
by rubber_dick with 4 votes
by kreengles with 4 votes
People's choice:
by smelltheflowers with 3 votes
Mod's choice:
by mangoninja
Voting Tally
If your icon number is not listed here, then it means that you have received no votes! Congratulations!
1.-4
3.-1/+1=0
4.-1/+1=0
5.-2
6.+3
7.-1
8.-2
9.-1
10.-2/+1=-1
11.-1/+1=0
12.-2
13.-4
- = lesser quality vote(s)
+ = favorite icon vote(s)
Elliminate:
12 - is too brightly
9 - the image does not have much contrast and the colors don't pop
13 - the coloring is too easy and have also not contrast
#01 -- grunge is took dark and oddly colored
#05 -- burn lights are distracting and poor text
#13 -- very dull coloring and layout
1: The texture is overpowering and the coloring is too muddy, it doesn't compliment the icon.
4: I like the text use, but the icon is too light and the coffee is unnaturally yellow.
10: The icon lacks of conrast, the coffee is unnaturallly red, the text is too light and very difficult to read.
01. The texture is really unappealing, and the colouring is far too dark.
11. The text is really hard to read, and the separate crops are a bit distracting.
13. There is too little colouring in this icon, there's nothing that makes it pop.
08. the light texture is too bright
07. the icon is dark and the light texture/text are not attractive
13. the icon is really plain, there is nothing special about it
#3: text is too small
#5: text is in an awkward place
#10: colouring is too light that one can barely read the writing.
08: The text wasn't really the best chosen for this icon.
01: A bit to dark-toned for a coffee icon.
12: The texture, and brush really threw off the theme.
Keep:
06: Very neatly done, love the usage of text. Really creative
#6: colouring is excellent and offers a nice splash of colour with the flowers.
11. great crop & duplication of the image
06. Lovely text, and the brush really compliments the colours used.
3: Good cropping, beautiful natural coloring and the tiny text is a nice touch.
#10 -- very nice, soft coloring and good text
4 - Love the coloring and the croop
Good luck to everyone in next round :)
by rubber_dick with 4 votes
by kreengles with 4 votes
People's choice:
by smelltheflowers with 3 votes
Mod's choice:
by mangoninja
Voting Tally
If your icon number is not listed here, then it means that you have received no votes! Congratulations!
1.-4
3.-1/+1=0
4.-1/+1=0
5.-2
6.+3
7.-1
8.-2
9.-1
10.-2/+1=-1
11.-1/+1=0
12.-2
13.-4
- = lesser quality vote(s)
+ = favorite icon vote(s)
Elliminate:
12 - is too brightly
9 - the image does not have much contrast and the colors don't pop
13 - the coloring is too easy and have also not contrast
#01 -- grunge is took dark and oddly colored
#05 -- burn lights are distracting and poor text
#13 -- very dull coloring and layout
1: The texture is overpowering and the coloring is too muddy, it doesn't compliment the icon.
4: I like the text use, but the icon is too light and the coffee is unnaturally yellow.
10: The icon lacks of conrast, the coffee is unnaturallly red, the text is too light and very difficult to read.
01. The texture is really unappealing, and the colouring is far too dark.
11. The text is really hard to read, and the separate crops are a bit distracting.
13. There is too little colouring in this icon, there's nothing that makes it pop.
08. the light texture is too bright
07. the icon is dark and the light texture/text are not attractive
13. the icon is really plain, there is nothing special about it
#3: text is too small
#5: text is in an awkward place
#10: colouring is too light that one can barely read the writing.
08: The text wasn't really the best chosen for this icon.
01: A bit to dark-toned for a coffee icon.
12: The texture, and brush really threw off the theme.
Keep:
06: Very neatly done, love the usage of text. Really creative
#6: colouring is excellent and offers a nice splash of colour with the flowers.
11. great crop & duplication of the image
06. Lovely text, and the brush really compliments the colours used.
3: Good cropping, beautiful natural coloring and the tiny text is a nice touch.
#10 -- very nice, soft coloring and good text
4 - Love the coloring and the croop
Good luck to everyone in next round :)