2011 Winners!!
The winners of the 2011 Criminal Minds Favorite Fics!
Thank you everyone who participated in getting the word out and especially those who went through the long list of nominees! And again, congratulations to the nominees themselves - even if you didn't win this year, you all still deserve the recognition for writing such amazing fic for the fandom! Keep it up!!
Now, here's a list of the winners!!
-- Author Awards --
Best New Author:
1st: justjasper
2nd: nix1978
3rd (tie): freakingdork
3rd (tie): morejoyful
Best Author Team Up:
1st: mildly_neurotic and ashesintwilight for "The Reid Effect"
2nd: microgirl8225 and mingsmommy for "Saturday Night at the Movies"
Best Author Overall:
1st: justjasper
2nd: coffeebuddha
3rd (tie): ficdirectory
3rd (tie): hotchityhotchhotch
3rd (tie): kuriadalmatia
-- General Awards --
Best Drabble:
1st: Close to the Vest by ficdirectory
2nd (tie): Don’t Even Take this Bet by coffeebuddha
2nd (tie): What a Pair We Make by magisterequitum
2nd (tie): Wrecked by coffeebuddha
3rd: Give Me Something by justjasper
Best Oneshot:
1st: Reading Reid by bluesunflower
2nd (tie): Indirect Confessions by welfycat
2nd (tie): Midnight Meetings by coffeebuddha
2nd (tie): Scars by ficdirectory
3rd (tie): Just Like Him by justjasper
3rd (tie): My Heart by sussiray
3rd (tie): Show Me Your Teeth by freakingdork
Best Multichapter:
1st: Keep the Suit Lose the Nickname: Book 1 by kuriadalmatia
2nd: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
3rd: Eternal Changes by nebula2
Best Case Fic:
1st (tie): Eternal Changes by nebula2
1st (tie): Reclaimations by seditionary/ragcat
2nd: Missing by ficdirectory
3rd: When Happily Ever After Fails by mcgarrygirl78 5
Best Series:
1st: Triggers and Ties by kuriadalmatia
2nd: Spun Hearts 'Verse by justjasper
3rd (tie): Everybody Loves Hotch by hotchityhotchhotch
3rd (tie): OT3-Verse by justjasper
Best Work-in-Progress:
1st: Departing Sun by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd: The Way You Lie by coffeebuddha
3rd (tie): Come Daylight by justjasper
3rd (tie): The Winter is Warmer by justjasper
-- Genre Awards --
Best Comedy:
1st: With A Little Help From My Friends by coffeebuddha
2nd: Showdown at Sunsplash Estates by starofoberion
3rd: One Smart Cookie by hotchityhotchhotch
Best Drama:
1st: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd: Losing Henry by ficdirectory
3rd (tie): Left Behind by ficdirectory
3rd (tie): The Five Times Aaron Hotchner had a Panic Attack by usakeh
Best Tragedy/Angst:
1st: Wash the Echoes Out by coffeebuddha
2nd: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
3rd: Un-break My Heart by morejoyful
Best Alternative Universe:
1st: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd: Model!AU by justjasper
3rd (tie): Keep the Suit Lose the Nickname by kuriadalmatia
3rd (tie): War Crimes by mosylu
Best Parody:
1st: The Behavioral Analysis Mutiny by amichevole
2nd: Devolution by jaynel
3rd: Threads of Thought by amy494walker
Best Crossover:
1st: Like a Funhouse Mirror Only Better by lat
2nd: The Behavioral Analysis Mutiny by amichevole
3rd (tie): And The Beat Goes On by coffeebuddha
3rd (tie): Familiar Strangers by nix1978
Best Death Scene/Story:
1st: Vows by justjasper
2nd (tie): Departure: One for Each Word by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd (tie): Part of the Script by kuriadalmatia
3rd: Souls at Sea by justjasper
-- Relationship Awards --
Best Het Romance - Hotch/Prentiss:
1st: 10 Seconds by charleswhatnow
2nd: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
3rd: Coming Back Home by sussiray
Best Het Romance - Morgan/Prentiss:
1st: Persuasion by Sarah Nublas
2nd: Elysium by amichevole
3rd: A Kiss During a Snowy Bliss by aslycsi1315
Best Het Romance - Prentiss/Reid:
1st (tie): Outward in the Same Direction by dialectheart
1st (tie): Scar Tissue by x_forgetromeo
2nd: Halloween by winkevii
3rd: The Phoenix's Child by mosylu
Best Het Romance - Prentiss/Rossi:
1st: Shopping With Benefits by mingsmommy
2nd: Saturday Night at the Movies by microgirl8225 and mingsmommy
3rd: One Night at McCool's by took_skye
Best Het Romance - Other Pairings:
1st: Love is Spelled L-O-L by coffeebuddha (Hotch/Garcia)
2nd: Foxtrot Whiskey Bravo by kuriadalmatia (Elle/Reid)
3rd: When Words Don’t Say Enough by graveygraves (JJ/Hotch)
-
Best Slash Romance - Hotch/Reid:
1st: Aftermark by bowie28
2nd: May I Have Another by kuriadalmatia
3rd: Hush by kuriadalmatia
Best Slash Romance - Hotch/Rossi:
1st: Ten Scenes at Various Stages of Domesticity by sarcasticsra
2nd: Unspoken by sarcasticsra
Best Slash Romance - Morgan/Reid:
1st: Bacon by coffeebuddha
2nd: Scars We Don't Want to Stitch by justjasper
3rd: Anything Can Happen In Vegas by nebula2
-
Best Femslash Romance - JJ/Prentiss:
1st (tie): Fireworks by babydykecate
1st (tie): Gin on Ice by babydykecate
2nd: Always and Forever by logicbomb.32
Best Femslash Romance - Other Pairings:
1st: Gin on Ice by babydykecate (Elle/JJ)
2nd: There is Something you Don't Know by ficdirectory (Prentiss/OFC)
3rd: Unexpected Dreams by pandorabox82 (Garcia/Prentiss)
-
Best Het Smut/Sex Scene - Hotch/Prentiss:
1st (tie): I'd Like To... by lat
1st (tie): Some Like It Hot by tigerlily888
2nd: Sextortion by sussiray
3rd: Garrulous by bibliothekara
Best Het Smut/Sex Scene - Prentiss/Reid:
1st: Crutch by justjasper
2nd: Refractory by justjasper
3rd: The Season of Miracles by l3petitemort
Best Het Smut/Sex Scene - Other Pairings:
1st: Triad by justjasper (Morgan/Prentiss)
2nd: Make You Feel Better by avferreira/darksideo'me/pgsbitchnow (Hotch/Garcia)
3rd: In the Arms of Love by smacky30 (Prentiss/Rossi)
-
Best Slash Smut/Sex Scene - Hotch/Reid:
1st: Wrecked by coffeebuddha
2nd (tie): Hedonistic by bowie28
2nd (tie): Ultimate Grand Supreme by kuriadalmatia
Best Slash Smut/Sex Scene - Morgan/Reid:
1st: Equal Eleven by justjasper
2nd: Here in the Dark by romankate
3rd: Breed by justjasper
Best Slash Smut/Sex Scene - Other Pairings:
1st: Change My Needs by justjasper (Hotch/Morgan/Reid)
2nd (tie): Like a Funhouse Mirror Only Better by lat (Hotch/Greg Montgomery)
2nd (tie): You'll Want The Delicate Cycle For Those by lat (Hotch/Morgan)
-
Best Femslash Smut/Sex Scene:
1st: Sigh No More by abvj (JJ/Prentiss)
2nd: A Neglected Girlfriend and Her Toy by talyn64 (JJ/Prentiss)
-
Best Friendship Fic:
1st (tie): With A Little Help From My Friends by coffeebuddha (Hotch/Morgan)
1st (tie): You Have One New Message by ficdirectory (Garcia/Prentiss)
2nd (tie): Blizzard by justjasper (Morgan/Prentiss/Reid)
2nd (tie): It's Us Against the World by shadowtights (Jordan/Seaver)
3rd: Nature vs. Nurture by nebula2 (Morgan/Reid)
Best Team Fic:
1st: Alaska by ficdirectory
2nd (tie): A Short About Shorts by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd (tie): Gates of Horn and Ivory by bookkeeperthe
2nd (tie): Lucky Pennies by avferreira/darksideo'me/pgsbitchnow
3rd: 135 Hours by mcgarrygirl78
-- Character Awards --
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Morgan:
1st (tie): Amen by justjasper
1st (tie): The Batter's Box by ficdirectory
2nd (tie): All the Times you Sat and Sang With Me by justjasper
2nd (tie): Close to the Vest by ficdirectory
3rd: Methods in the Dark by justjasper
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Prentiss:
1st: For All That Was Lost by charleswhatnow
2nd: Coming Back Home by sussiray
3rd: The Distance Between by spyglass_
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Reid:
1st: Wash the Echoes Out by coffeebuddha
2nd: Lost In Translation by ficdirectory
3rd (tie): Lessons Learned by bluesunflower
3rd (tie): The Modern Pinocchio by starsoverhead/backtothelight
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Other (current teammates):
1st: Sew My Lips Shut by magisterequitum (JJ)
2nd (tie): All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch (Garcia)
2nd (tie): Lucky Pennies by avferreira (Garcia)
3rd: Failure is the Only Option by welfycat (Rossi)
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Other (previous teammates):
1st: Taboo by greenaways (Elle)
2nd: Foxtrot Whiskey Bravo by kuriadalmatia (Elle)
3rd: Secrets by just_chiara (Seaver)
Best Portrayal of a Side Character:
1st: Lost Souls in Sin City by coffeebuddha (Ethan)
2nd (tie): All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch (Jessica Brooks)
2nd (tie): The Path by amy494walker (Strauss)
3rd: When Happily Ever After Fails by mcgarrygirl78 (Strauss)
Best Original Character:
1st: Confide by justjasper (Alejandro)
2nd: Lost Souls in Sin City by coffeebuddha (Amelia)
3rd: Eye of the Hurricane by luna argenta (Chief Dex Brown)
Congratulations to all the winners!
We will be making a post this week with all of the banners for the winners to choose from. Check back here this week for your banners!
If you notice any mistakes, please let us know. Also, please leave any suggestions or complaints below, or send an email to cmfavoritefics@gmail.com.
Thanks again, everyone!
Thank you everyone who participated in getting the word out and especially those who went through the long list of nominees! And again, congratulations to the nominees themselves - even if you didn't win this year, you all still deserve the recognition for writing such amazing fic for the fandom! Keep it up!!
Now, here's a list of the winners!!
-- Author Awards --
Best New Author:
1st: justjasper
2nd: nix1978
3rd (tie): freakingdork
3rd (tie): morejoyful
Best Author Team Up:
1st: mildly_neurotic and ashesintwilight for "The Reid Effect"
2nd: microgirl8225 and mingsmommy for "Saturday Night at the Movies"
Best Author Overall:
1st: justjasper
2nd: coffeebuddha
3rd (tie): ficdirectory
3rd (tie): hotchityhotchhotch
3rd (tie): kuriadalmatia
-- General Awards --
Best Drabble:
1st: Close to the Vest by ficdirectory
2nd (tie): Don’t Even Take this Bet by coffeebuddha
2nd (tie): What a Pair We Make by magisterequitum
2nd (tie): Wrecked by coffeebuddha
3rd: Give Me Something by justjasper
Best Oneshot:
1st: Reading Reid by bluesunflower
2nd (tie): Indirect Confessions by welfycat
2nd (tie): Midnight Meetings by coffeebuddha
2nd (tie): Scars by ficdirectory
3rd (tie): Just Like Him by justjasper
3rd (tie): My Heart by sussiray
3rd (tie): Show Me Your Teeth by freakingdork
Best Multichapter:
1st: Keep the Suit Lose the Nickname: Book 1 by kuriadalmatia
2nd: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
3rd: Eternal Changes by nebula2
Best Case Fic:
1st (tie): Eternal Changes by nebula2
1st (tie): Reclaimations by seditionary/ragcat
2nd: Missing by ficdirectory
3rd: When Happily Ever After Fails by mcgarrygirl78 5
Best Series:
1st: Triggers and Ties by kuriadalmatia
2nd: Spun Hearts 'Verse by justjasper
3rd (tie): Everybody Loves Hotch by hotchityhotchhotch
3rd (tie): OT3-Verse by justjasper
Best Work-in-Progress:
1st: Departing Sun by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd: The Way You Lie by coffeebuddha
3rd (tie): Come Daylight by justjasper
3rd (tie): The Winter is Warmer by justjasper
-- Genre Awards --
Best Comedy:
1st: With A Little Help From My Friends by coffeebuddha
2nd: Showdown at Sunsplash Estates by starofoberion
3rd: One Smart Cookie by hotchityhotchhotch
Best Drama:
1st: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd: Losing Henry by ficdirectory
3rd (tie): Left Behind by ficdirectory
3rd (tie): The Five Times Aaron Hotchner had a Panic Attack by usakeh
Best Tragedy/Angst:
1st: Wash the Echoes Out by coffeebuddha
2nd: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
3rd: Un-break My Heart by morejoyful
Best Alternative Universe:
1st: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd: Model!AU by justjasper
3rd (tie): Keep the Suit Lose the Nickname by kuriadalmatia
3rd (tie): War Crimes by mosylu
Best Parody:
1st: The Behavioral Analysis Mutiny by amichevole
2nd: Devolution by jaynel
3rd: Threads of Thought by amy494walker
Best Crossover:
1st: Like a Funhouse Mirror Only Better by lat
2nd: The Behavioral Analysis Mutiny by amichevole
3rd (tie): And The Beat Goes On by coffeebuddha
3rd (tie): Familiar Strangers by nix1978
Best Death Scene/Story:
1st: Vows by justjasper
2nd (tie): Departure: One for Each Word by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd (tie): Part of the Script by kuriadalmatia
3rd: Souls at Sea by justjasper
-- Relationship Awards --
Best Het Romance - Hotch/Prentiss:
1st: 10 Seconds by charleswhatnow
2nd: All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch
3rd: Coming Back Home by sussiray
Best Het Romance - Morgan/Prentiss:
1st: Persuasion by Sarah Nublas
2nd: Elysium by amichevole
3rd: A Kiss During a Snowy Bliss by aslycsi1315
Best Het Romance - Prentiss/Reid:
1st (tie): Outward in the Same Direction by dialectheart
1st (tie): Scar Tissue by x_forgetromeo
2nd: Halloween by winkevii
3rd: The Phoenix's Child by mosylu
Best Het Romance - Prentiss/Rossi:
1st: Shopping With Benefits by mingsmommy
2nd: Saturday Night at the Movies by microgirl8225 and mingsmommy
3rd: One Night at McCool's by took_skye
Best Het Romance - Other Pairings:
1st: Love is Spelled L-O-L by coffeebuddha (Hotch/Garcia)
2nd: Foxtrot Whiskey Bravo by kuriadalmatia (Elle/Reid)
3rd: When Words Don’t Say Enough by graveygraves (JJ/Hotch)
-
Best Slash Romance - Hotch/Reid:
1st: Aftermark by bowie28
2nd: May I Have Another by kuriadalmatia
3rd: Hush by kuriadalmatia
Best Slash Romance - Hotch/Rossi:
1st: Ten Scenes at Various Stages of Domesticity by sarcasticsra
2nd: Unspoken by sarcasticsra
Best Slash Romance - Morgan/Reid:
1st: Bacon by coffeebuddha
2nd: Scars We Don't Want to Stitch by justjasper
3rd: Anything Can Happen In Vegas by nebula2
-
Best Femslash Romance - JJ/Prentiss:
1st (tie): Fireworks by babydykecate
1st (tie): Gin on Ice by babydykecate
2nd: Always and Forever by logicbomb.32
Best Femslash Romance - Other Pairings:
1st: Gin on Ice by babydykecate (Elle/JJ)
2nd: There is Something you Don't Know by ficdirectory (Prentiss/OFC)
3rd: Unexpected Dreams by pandorabox82 (Garcia/Prentiss)
-
Best Het Smut/Sex Scene - Hotch/Prentiss:
1st (tie): I'd Like To... by lat
1st (tie): Some Like It Hot by tigerlily888
2nd: Sextortion by sussiray
3rd: Garrulous by bibliothekara
Best Het Smut/Sex Scene - Prentiss/Reid:
1st: Crutch by justjasper
2nd: Refractory by justjasper
3rd: The Season of Miracles by l3petitemort
Best Het Smut/Sex Scene - Other Pairings:
1st: Triad by justjasper (Morgan/Prentiss)
2nd: Make You Feel Better by avferreira/darksideo'me/pgsbitchnow (Hotch/Garcia)
3rd: In the Arms of Love by smacky30 (Prentiss/Rossi)
-
Best Slash Smut/Sex Scene - Hotch/Reid:
1st: Wrecked by coffeebuddha
2nd (tie): Hedonistic by bowie28
2nd (tie): Ultimate Grand Supreme by kuriadalmatia
Best Slash Smut/Sex Scene - Morgan/Reid:
1st: Equal Eleven by justjasper
2nd: Here in the Dark by romankate
3rd: Breed by justjasper
Best Slash Smut/Sex Scene - Other Pairings:
1st: Change My Needs by justjasper (Hotch/Morgan/Reid)
2nd (tie): Like a Funhouse Mirror Only Better by lat (Hotch/Greg Montgomery)
2nd (tie): You'll Want The Delicate Cycle For Those by lat (Hotch/Morgan)
-
Best Femslash Smut/Sex Scene:
1st: Sigh No More by abvj (JJ/Prentiss)
2nd: A Neglected Girlfriend and Her Toy by talyn64 (JJ/Prentiss)
-
Best Friendship Fic:
1st (tie): With A Little Help From My Friends by coffeebuddha (Hotch/Morgan)
1st (tie): You Have One New Message by ficdirectory (Garcia/Prentiss)
2nd (tie): Blizzard by justjasper (Morgan/Prentiss/Reid)
2nd (tie): It's Us Against the World by shadowtights (Jordan/Seaver)
3rd: Nature vs. Nurture by nebula2 (Morgan/Reid)
Best Team Fic:
1st: Alaska by ficdirectory
2nd (tie): A Short About Shorts by hotchityhotchhotch
2nd (tie): Gates of Horn and Ivory by bookkeeperthe
2nd (tie): Lucky Pennies by avferreira/darksideo'me/pgsbitchnow
3rd: 135 Hours by mcgarrygirl78
-- Character Awards --
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Morgan:
1st (tie): Amen by justjasper
1st (tie): The Batter's Box by ficdirectory
2nd (tie): All the Times you Sat and Sang With Me by justjasper
2nd (tie): Close to the Vest by ficdirectory
3rd: Methods in the Dark by justjasper
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Prentiss:
1st: For All That Was Lost by charleswhatnow
2nd: Coming Back Home by sussiray
3rd: The Distance Between by spyglass_
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Reid:
1st: Wash the Echoes Out by coffeebuddha
2nd: Lost In Translation by ficdirectory
3rd (tie): Lessons Learned by bluesunflower
3rd (tie): The Modern Pinocchio by starsoverhead/backtothelight
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Other (current teammates):
1st: Sew My Lips Shut by magisterequitum (JJ)
2nd (tie): All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch (Garcia)
2nd (tie): Lucky Pennies by avferreira (Garcia)
3rd: Failure is the Only Option by welfycat (Rossi)
Best Portrayal of a Main Character - Other (previous teammates):
1st: Taboo by greenaways (Elle)
2nd: Foxtrot Whiskey Bravo by kuriadalmatia (Elle)
3rd: Secrets by just_chiara (Seaver)
Best Portrayal of a Side Character:
1st: Lost Souls in Sin City by coffeebuddha (Ethan)
2nd (tie): All This Time by hotchityhotchhotch (Jessica Brooks)
2nd (tie): The Path by amy494walker (Strauss)
3rd: When Happily Ever After Fails by mcgarrygirl78 (Strauss)
Best Original Character:
1st: Confide by justjasper (Alejandro)
2nd: Lost Souls in Sin City by coffeebuddha (Amelia)
3rd: Eye of the Hurricane by luna argenta (Chief Dex Brown)
Congratulations to all the winners!
We will be making a post this week with all of the banners for the winners to choose from. Check back here this week for your banners!
If you notice any mistakes, please let us know. Also, please leave any suggestions or complaints below, or send an email to cmfavoritefics@gmail.com.
Thanks again, everyone!