Upon consideration, and the Mad Scientist's confirming my fears that "On the Thirteenth Day of Christmas" was too hokey and "Gifts from an Improbable Winter" was too cumbersome and awkward (he was wearing his muse hat), the current favorite for contest title is:
Spec the Halls
A Winter Celebration of the Weird and the Fantastic
Thanks,
nemoren! The Mad Scientist had to reassure me that it wasn't too pun-ny.*
Um. I know I've asked you this question a lot lately, but--what do you think?
* He also told me I was being way too indecisive, as usual...just so y'all know that I'm not actually getting away with it.