Session 02: Round 05: Results
eliminated:
by meow_kiss with -9 votes
by simpleflower with -7 votes
sorry, hope to see you in the come back round!
people's choice:
by sarenka_xd
banner
01|-9
02|-7
03|-1+3=2
04|-4+3=-1
05|+3
06|+3-1=2
07|-1+5=4
08|-4+1=-3
09|-3+2=-1
COMMENTS:
ELIMINATIONS:
#1 - frame doesn't match with the icon
#1 - icon is oversharpened
#001 - Texture/border doesn't fit picture and crop very well.
#1 - texture doesn't fit the icon.
#1 - bad texture use
001 - the texture is overpowering
01 - The texture was not a good choice for the icon as it makes the icon look empty.
01 - crop is distracting, this texture doesn't fit the image
#1 - the texture doesn't suit the icon
002 - the text is distracting and oversharpened.
#002 - Coloring is a bit too pale and placement of text is not good, text is not necessary here.
#2 - I think colouring isn't good
#2 - bad use of text.
#2 - coloring is too pale
#2 - too easy - simple pale coloring and primitive text :/
2 - crop is not bad, but looks not attractive, and text placement not good
3 - blue&red skin, looks blurry and needs some contrast i think, text texture isnt good here
#004 - Clemence is not blend good enough and icon seems a bit blurry/foggy.
4 - too blurry, looks a bit empty
04 - The mirror texture just seems too random, there's too much contrast in the icon.
#4 - a bit weird look - I guess her head is too big for the frame
006 - the image isn't sharpened enough, other's are more striking
#7 - really nice icon, but it's too simple
#8 - cropping isn't good and the violet texture makes userpic too dark
08 - icon is too sharp and a bit too pale
#8 - coloring is too vivid
#8 - the colouring is very bland
09 - crop is really strange and grey face of clemence could be more bright.
09 - The crop is too close up and the details are too sharp. Some colour would have been nice.
#9 - there should be more contrast on the icon
FAVOURITES:
#3 - really love the use of textures.
03 - Excellent use of textures.
003 - nice use of brush and light texture
#4 - great texture use!
#4 - nice colors and texture use
#4 - outstanding
#5 - I like the idea and composition
#5 - quite simple, but looks well:)
5 - i like frame and blue soft tone :) net is also looks good
06 - I adore the cop and colouring - amazing:)
#006 - Great coloring, cropping and rotation.
#6 - good use of colouring and crop
07 - I really like the composition here and colouring is also nice.
#7 - good crop and nice colouring
#7 - great texture use
7 - i like coloring and using of black flower texture
07 - Replacing the wall with a pattern was creative and it was done cleanly.
#8 - beautiful coloring!
#009 - Nice crop and sharp enough.
009 - lovely use of black and white